复发事件与竞争终止事件的联合脆弱模型:应用于ICU谵妄研究
针对ICU谵妄复发事件,提出联合脆弱模型同时处理复发事件与多个竞争终止事件(存活出院与死亡),以解决独立删失假设被违反时的推断偏倚。基于一项安慰剂对照临床试验数据拟合模型,并通过模拟研究评估偏倚与置信区间覆盖等性质,展示仅用单一终止事件联合模型的不足,模型已纳入R包frailtypack。
要点
- ICU谵妄复发事件中,存活出院与死亡作为竞争终止事件,独立删失假设不成立。
- 谵妄与死亡风险关联方向可能和谵妄与ICU出院风险关联方向相反,需竞争联合模型。
- 模拟研究显示仅用单一终止事件的联合模型存在不足,竞争联合模型已纳入frailtypack。
核心结论
- 提出竞争联合模型,用潜在脆弱项连接患者复发事件与竞争终止事件过程,避免将任一终止事件视为独立删失所致推断偏倚。
研究设计与样本
- 基于一项已完成的安慰剂对照临床试验(研究氟哌啶醇能否预防ICU患者死亡和谵妄)的数据拟合竞争联合模型,并以该试验为基础开展模拟研究评估模型偏倚与置信区间覆盖等性质。
主要发现
- 模拟研究显示,使用仅含复发谵妄过程和单一终止事件的联合模型研究ICU谵妄存在不足。
- 竞争联合模型已加入R包frailtypack,该包用于拟合多种联合模型。
局限性
- 原文在讨论部分讨论了竞争联合模型的局限性及可能的扩展方向。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Joint models linking longitudinal biomarkers or recurrent event processes with a terminal event, for example, mortality, have been studied extensively. Motivated by studies of recurrent delirium events in patients receiving care in an intensive care unit (ICU), we devise a joint model for a recurrent event process and multiple terminal events. Being discharged alive from the ICU or experiencing mortality may be associated with a patient's hazard of delirium, violating the assumption of independent censoring. Moreover, the direction of the association between the hazards of delirium and mortality may be opposite of the direction of association between the hazards of delirium and ICU discharge. Hence treating either terminal event as independent censoring may bias inferences. We propose a competing joint model that uses a latent frailty to link a patient's recurrent and competing terminal event processes. We fit our model to data from a completed placebo-controlled clinical trial, which studied whether Haloperidol could prevent death and delirium among ICU patients. The clinical trial served as a foundation for a simulation study, in which we evaluate the properties, for example, bias and confidence interval coverage, of the competing joint model. As part of the simulation study, we demonstrate the shortcomings of using a joint model with a recurrent delirium process and a single terminal event to study delirium in the ICU. Lastly, we discuss limitations and possible extensions for the competing joint model. The competing joint model has been added to frailtypack, an R package for fitting an assortment of joint models.
引用
- Etzkorn LH, Coënt QL, van den Boogaard M, et al. A joint frailty model for recurrent and competing terminal events: Application to delirium in the ICU. Stat Med. 2024. PMID: 38564224. doi:10.1002/sim.10053
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。