中介变量值低于检测限时的因果中介分析
针对中介变量为生物标志物且受检测下限限制的问题,提出外推法和数值优化积分观测似然法两种估计间接与直接效应的方法,仅依赖中介公式因而适用于自然、可分离和有机间接与直接效应。模拟研究比较了两种方法与用检测限一半进行插补的效果,并利用Li等2016年AIDS和Lok与Bosch 2021年Epidemiology描述的艾滋病临床试验组HIV中断研究数据,示例估计假设HIV治愈治疗通过细胞相关HIV-RNA和单拷贝血浆HIV-RNA介导的对病毒抑制的有机/纯间接效应。
要点
- 中介变量受检测下限影响时,外推法和数值优化积分法可估计间接与直接效应。
- 两种方法仅依赖中介公式,适用于自然、可分离和有机间接与直接效应。
- 模拟研究比较了两种方法与用检测限一半插补的效果。
核心结论
- 提出两种在中介变量受检测限限制时估计间接与直接效应的方法:外推法和数值优化与积分观测似然法。
- 两种方法仅依赖中介公式,因而适用于自然、可分离和有机间接与直接效应。
研究设计与样本
- 方法学研究,提出两种估计方法并进行模拟研究比较。
- 使用艾滋病临床试验组HIV中断研究数据(Li等2016年AIDS;Lok和Bosch 2021年Epidemiology)进行示例分析。
主要发现
- 模拟研究比较了两种估计方法与用检测限一半进行插补的效果。
- 示例分析估计了假设HIV治愈治疗通过细胞相关HIV-RNA和单拷贝血浆HIV-RNA介导的对病毒抑制的有机/纯间接效应。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Causal indirect and direct effects provide an interpretable method for decomposing the total effect of an exposure on an outcome into the indirect effect through a mediator and the direct effect through all other pathways. A natural choice for a mediator in a randomized clinical trial is the treatment's targeted biomarker. However, when the mediator is a biomarker, values can be subject to an assay lower limit. The mediator is affected by the treatment and is a putative cause of the outcome, so the assay lower limit presents a compounded problem in mediation analysis. We propose two approaches to estimate indirect and direct effects with a mediator subject to an assay limit: (1) extrapolation and (2) numerical optimization and integration of the observed likelihood. Since these estimation methods solely rely on the so-called Mediation Formula, they apply to most approaches to causal mediation analysis: natural, separable, and organic indirect, and direct effects. A simulation study compares the two estimation approaches to imputing with half the assay limit. Using HIV interruption study data from the AIDS Clinical Trials Group described in Li et al 2016, AIDS; Lok and Bosch 2021, Epidemiology, we illustrate our methods by estimating the organic/pure indirect effect of a hypothetical HIV curative treatment on viral suppression mediated by two HIV persistence measures: cell-associated HIV-RNA and single-copy plasma HIV-RNA.
引用
- Chernofsky A, Bosch RJ, Lok JJ, et al. Causal mediation analysis with mediator values below an assay limit. Stat Med. 2024. PMID: 38556761. doi:10.1002/sim.10065
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。