文献速递医学教育与科研方法流行病学与生物统计

学术与科学出版中学术出版商和期刊对作者使用生成式人工智能的指南:文献计量分析

Publishers' and journals' instructions to authors on use of generative artificial intelligence in academic and scientific publishing: bibliometric analysis.
PubMed 文献 · BMJ · 2024-01-31

该横断面文献计量研究于2023年5月19-20日筛查并2023年10月8-9日更新,分析前100大学术出版商和前100高排名科学期刊网站关于生成式人工智能(GAI)的作者指南。结果显示24%的出版商和87%的期刊提供GAI指南,禁止将GAI列为作者的比例分别为96%和98%,指南内容与披露要求异质性大,12种期刊指南与其出版商直接冲突。

要点

  • 前100大学术出版商中24%提供GAI使用指南,前100高排名科学期刊中87%提供指南。
  • 有指南的出版商和期刊中,禁止将GAI列为作者的比例分别为96%和98%。
  • 仅1种期刊(1%)明确禁止使用GAI生成稿件,指南在披露标准与位置上异质性大。

核心结论

  • 部分顶级出版商和期刊缺乏关于作者使用GAI的指南。
  • 在提供指南的机构中,GAI的允许使用方式和披露方式差异很大,这种异质性在附属出版商和期刊之间也持续存在。
  • 缺乏标准化给作者带来负担,并可能限制规定的有效性。
  • 随着GAI日益普及,需要标准化指南以保护科学产出的完整性。

研究设计与样本

  • 横断面文献计量研究,于2023年5月19-20日筛查学术出版商和科学期刊网站,并于2023年10月8-9日更新检索。
  • 对象为前100家最大规模学术出版商和前100种高排名科学期刊,不限学科、语言或来源国。
  • 出版商按期刊组合总数识别,期刊通过Scimago期刊排名使用Hirsch指数(H指数)作为期刊生产力和影响力指标识别。
  • 主要结局指标为前100家学术出版商和科学期刊网站上列出的GAI指南内容,以及出版商与其附属期刊之间指南的一致性。

主要发现

  • 前100家最大出版商中24%提供了GAI使用指南,其中15家(63%)属于前25家出版商。
  • 前100种高排名期刊中87%提供了GAI指南。
  • 有指南的出版商和期刊中,禁止将GAI列为作者的比例分别为96%和98%。
  • 仅1种期刊(1%)明确禁止使用GAI生成稿件,2家(8%)出版商和19种(22%)期刊表示其指南仅适用于写作过程。
  • 披露GAI使用时,75%的出版商和43%的期刊包含具体披露标准;披露位置各异,包括方法或致谢、投稿信或新章节;12种期刊的GAI指南与出版商指南直接冲突。

关键数值与推荐

  • 前100家最大出版商中24%提供GAI指南,其中15家(63%)为前25家出版商。
  • 前100种高排名期刊中87%提供GAI指南。
  • 有指南的出版商中96%禁止将GAI列为作者,有指南的期刊中98%禁止将GAI列为作者。
  • 仅1种期刊(1%)明确禁止使用GAI生成稿件;2家出版商(8%)和19种期刊(22%)的指南仅适用于写作过程。
  • 75%的出版商和43%的期刊包含具体GAI披露标准;12种期刊的GAI指南与出版商指南直接冲突。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: To determine the extent and content of academic publishers' and scientific journals' guidance for authors on the use of generative artificial intelligence (GAI). DESIGN: Cross sectional, bibliometric study. SETTING: Websites of academic publishers and scientific journals, screened on 19-20 May 2023, with the search updated on 8-9 October 2023. PARTICIPANTS: Top 100 largest academic publishers and top 100 highly ranked scientific journals, regardless of subject, language, or country of origin. Publishers were identified by the total number of journals in their portfolio, and journals were identified through the Scimago journal rank using the Hirsch index (H index) as an indicator of journal productivity and impact. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The primary outcomes were the content of GAI guidelines listed on the websites of the top 100 academic publishers and scientific journals, and the consistency of guidance between the publishers and their affiliated journals. RESULTS: Among the top 100 largest publishers, 24% provided guidance on the use of GAI, of which 15 (63%) were among the top 25 publishers. Among the top 100 highly ranked journals, 87% provided guidance on GAI. Of the publishers and journals with guidelines, the inclusion of GAI as an author was prohibited in 96% and 98%, respectively. Only one journal (1%) explicitly prohibited the use of GAI in the generation of a manuscript, and two (8%) publishers and 19 (22%) journals indicated that their guidelines exclusively applied to the writing process. When disclosing the use of GAI, 75% of publishers and 43% of journals included specific disclosure criteria. Where to disclose the use of GAI varied, including in the methods or acknowledgments, in the cover letter, or in a new section. Variability was also found in how to access GAI guidelines shared between journals and publishers. GAI guidelines in 12 journals directly conflicted with those developed by the publishers. The guidelines developed by top medical journals were broadly similar to those of academic journals. CONCLUSIONS: Guidelines by some top publishers and journals on the use of GAI by authors are lacking. Among those that provided guidelines, the allowable uses of GAI and how it should be disclosed varied substantially, with this heterogeneity persisting in some instances among affiliated publishers and journals. Lack of standardization places a burden on authors and could limit the effectiveness of the regulations. As GAI continues to grow in popularity, standardized guidelines to protect the integrity of scientific output are needed.

来源:BMJ,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Ganjavi C, Eppler MB, Pekcan A, et al. Publishers' and journals' instructions to authors on use of generative artificial intelligence in academic and scientific publishing: bibliometric analysis. BMJ. 2024. PMID: 38296328. doi:10.1136/bmj-2023-077192

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。