文献速递临床试验与 GCP

探索自闭症儿童感觉统合治疗评估中的关键干预特征与试验过程

Exploring critical intervention features and trial processes in the evaluation of sensory integration therapy for autistic children.
PubMed 文献 · Trials · 2024-02-17

该研究在双臂随机对照试验中评估自闭症儿童感觉统合治疗(SIT)的临床与成本效果,并嵌套过程评估。共招募138名儿童及照护者,77.5%在随机化后6个月保留、69.9%在12个月保留;干预以结构和过程保真度实施,78.3%接受足够剂量,未报告不良事件;照护者与治疗师认为试验过程总体可接受,但预约时间、出行和COVID限制是常见障碍。

要点

  • 招募138名儿童及照护者,为筛查者的92%、表达兴趣者的53.5%。
  • 随机化后6个月保留77.5%、12个月保留69.9%。
  • 78.3%接受足够剂量干预,未报告不良事件。

核心结论

  • 过程评估在识别可能影响该个体化干预效果的背景因素方面具有很高价值。
  • 对自闭症儿童干预进行严格评估很重要,尤其考虑到既往研究面临样本量有限和随访短期等局限。
  • 挑战之一在于照护者认为重要的结局存在变异性,因为每个自闭症儿童面临独特挑战。
  • 考虑父母或其他照护者在促进这些干预可及性方面的作用及其对效果的影响至关重要。

研究设计与样本

  • 在双臂随机对照试验中嵌套过程评估,过程评估依照医学研究理事会(Medical Research Council)指南进行。
  • 共招募138名儿童及照护者,为筛查者的92%、表达兴趣者的53.5%。
  • 采用描述性统计报告招募、人口学、保留、依从性和不良效应。
  • 依据干预评分手册报告干预实施保真度。
  • 对治疗师和照护者进行定性访谈以探索干预和试验过程的可接受性,对照护者的定性访谈探索潜在污染。

主要发现

  • 招募、覆盖和保留达到预期阈值。
  • 随机化后6个月保留77.5%,12个月保留69.9%。
  • 干预以结构和过程保真度实施,多数(78.3%)接受足够剂量干预,但接受会话次数存在 considerable 个体间变异。
  • 照护者和治疗师报告试验过程总体可接受,但预约时间、出行和COVID限制等后勤挑战是接受干预的常见障碍。
  • 未报告不良事件。

局限性

  • 既往研究面临样本量有限和随访短期等局限。
  • 照护者认为重要的结局存在变异性,因为每个自闭症儿童面临独特挑战。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: We evaluated the clinical and cost-effectiveness of manualised sensory integration therapy (SIT) for autistic children with sensory processing difficulties in a two-arm randomised controlled trial. Trial processes and contextual factors which may have affected intervention outcomes were explored within a nested process evaluation. This paper details the process evaluation methods and results. We also discuss implications for evaluation of individual level, tailored interventions in similar populations. METHODS: The process evaluation was conducted in line with Medical Research Council guidance. Recruitment, demographics, retention, adherence, and adverse effects are reported using descriptive statistics. Fidelity of intervention delivery is reported according to the intervention scoring manual. Qualitative interviews with therapists and carers were undertaken to explore the acceptability of the intervention and trial processes. Qualitative interviews with carers explored potential contamination. RESULTS: Recruitment, reach and retention within the trial met expected thresholds. One hundred thirty-eight children and carers were recruited (92% of those screened and 53.5% of those who expressed an interest) with 77.5% retained at 6 months and 69.9% at 12 months post-randomisation. The intervention was delivered with structural and process fidelity with the majority (78.3%) receiving a 'sufficient dose' of intervention. However, there was considerable individual variability in the receipt of sessions. Carers and therapists reported that trial processes were generally acceptable though logistical challenges such as appointment times, travel and COVID restrictions were frequent barriers to receiving the intervention. No adverse effects were reported. CONCLUSIONS: The process evaluation was highly valuable in identifying contextual factors that could impact the effectiveness of this individualised intervention. Rigorous evaluations of interventions for autistic children are important, especially given the limitations such as limited sample sizes and short-term follow-up as faced by previous research. One of the challenges lies in the variability of outcomes considered important by caregivers, as each autistic child faces unique challenges. It is crucial to consider the role of parents or other caregivers in facilitating access to these interventions and how this may impact effectiveness. TRIAL REGISTRATION: This trial is registered as ISRCTN14716440. August 11, 2016.

来源:Trials,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Randell E, McNamara R, Busse M, et al. Exploring critical intervention features and trial processes in the evaluation of sensory integration therapy for autistic children. Trials. 2024. PMID: 38368387. doi:10.1186/s13063-024-07957-6

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。