GRADE工作组与CINeMA方法对阿片类药物治疗慢性非癌性疼痛的网络Meta分析证据确定性评级不一致
本研究以慢性非癌性疼痛的阿片类药物网络Meta分析为例,分别用GRADE工作组方法与CINeMA框架评估证据确定性。在105项疼痛缓解比较中34%(36/105)评级不一致,66项躯体功能比较中17%(11/66)不一致,所有差异均相差一个等级,CINeMA通常给出更低评级,主要源于传递性和异质性评估差异。
要点
- GRADE工作组与CINeMA对同一网络Meta分析证据确定性评级存在不一致。
- 疼痛缓解比较中34%(36/105)评级不一致,躯体功能比较中17%(11/66)不一致。
- 所有不一致均相差一个等级,CINeMA通常评级更低,主要因传递性和异质性评估不同。
核心结论
- GRADE工作组方法与CINeMA框架应用于网络Meta分析时给出的证据确定性评级存在差异,需进一步研究在其他网络Meta分析中重复或反驳该发现并评估对临床决策的影响。
研究设计与样本
- 基于慢性非癌性疼痛阿片类药物网络Meta分析,分别用GRADE工作组方法与CINeMA框架评估单个阿片类药物对疼痛缓解和躯体功能治疗效应的证据确定性,两者均将证据确定性评为高、中、低或极低,并量化评级不一致的例数及差异幅度(一个等级、两个等级或三个等级)。
主要发现
- 疼痛缓解方面共105项单个阿片类药物间比较,GRADE工作组与CINeMA评级不一致占34%(36/105)。
- 躯体功能方面共66项比较,评级不一致占17%(11/66)。
- 所有不一致均相差一个等级,CINeMA框架通常较GRADE工作组给出更低的证据确定性评级,主要因传递性和异质性评估差异。
局限性
- 原文指出需进一步研究在其他网络Meta分析中重复或反驳该发现并评估对临床决策的影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Assessment of the certainty of evidence (CoE) from network meta-analysis is critical to convey the strength of inferences for clinical decision-making. Both the GRADE (Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation) Working Group (GWG) and the Confidence in Network Meta-Analysis (CINeMA) framework have been designed to assess the CoE of treatment effects informed by network meta-analysis; however, the concordance of results is uncertain. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We assessed the CoE for treatment effects of individual opioids on pain relief and physical functioning from a network meta-analysis for chronic noncancer pain using the GWG approach and the CINeMA framework. Both approaches evaluate the CoE as high, moderate, low or very low. We quantified the number of discrepant CoE ratings between approaches and the magnitude of the difference (ie, one level, two levels, or three levels). RESULTS: Across 105 comparisons among individual opioids for pain relief, the GWG and CINeMA approaches provided different CoE ratings in 34% of cases (36 of 105). Across 66 comparisons for physical functioning, there was discordance in 17% of cases (11 of 66). All discrepancies were separated by one level. The CINeMA framework typically provided lower CoE ratings compared to the GWG approach, predominantly because of differences in the assessment of transitivity and heterogeneity. CONCLUSION: Our findings suggest there are differences between the CoE ratings provided by the GWG and CINeMA approaches when applied to network meta-analyses. Further research is needed to replicate or refute our findings in other network meta-analyses and assess the implications for clinical decision-making.
引用
- Noori A, Sadeghirad B, Thabane L, et al. The GRADE Working Group and CINeMA approaches provided inconsistent certainty of evidence ratings for a network meta-analysis of opioids for chronic noncancer pain. J Clin Epidemiol. 2024. PMID: 38341047. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2024.111276
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。