理解试验方法研究结果的实施:应用实施框架与行为改变模型的混合方法研究
该混合方法研究通过案例调查、访谈和行为改变轮,探讨英国临床试验单位实施试验方法研究建议的障碍与促进因素。27家单位参与调查,16名资深成员接受访谈,发现实施率因建议类型而异,资源不足和认知缺乏是主要障碍,参与试验网络和配套资源是主要促进因素,并据此提出潜在策略。
要点
- 调查显示多数试验单位实施了试验实施方面的建议,仅少数实施了报告方面的建议。
- 资源问题和建议认知不足是常见的实施障碍。
- 参与试验网络和配套相关资源的建议是常见的实施促进因素。
核心结论
- 识别了影响试验方法建议实施的几个关键领域,并提出了增强促进因素、减少障碍的潜在方法;未来研究需要完善这些方法并评估其可行性和可接受性。
研究设计与样本
- 三阶段混合方法研究:首先在试验设计、实施、分析和报告领域识别已完成的提供方法学建议的项目作为案例;然后对英国临床试验单位通过电子邮件邀请经验丰富的试验人员进行调查,调查基于实施研究综合框架评估案例的实施率和单位人口学特征;最后对资深成员进行访谈,访谈和分析基于行为的能力、机会、动机模型,并通过行为改变轮生成策略。
- 共27家英国试验单位回应调查,16名资深成员接受访谈。
主要发现
- 各案例的实施率不一,多数试验单位实施了试验实施方面的建议,仅少数实施了报告方面的建议。
- 多数报告实施建议很重要,但缺乏资源。
- 访谈生成的主题大致涉及方法学建议本身、试验单位或影响实施的外部因素;主题中的信念陈述表明资源问题和建议认知是常见的实施障碍。
- 参与试验网络和附带相关资源的建议被频繁提及为实施促进因素;这些障碍和促进因素与调查结果一致。
局限性
- 未来研究需要完善这些方法并评估其可行性和可接受性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Trial method research produces recommendations on how to best conduct trials. However, findings are not routinely implemented into practice. To better understand why, we conducted a mixed method study on the challenges of implementing trial method research findings into UK-based clinical trial units. METHODS: Three stages of research were conducted. Firstly, case studies of completed projects that provided methodological recommendations were identified within trial design, conduct, analysis, and reporting. These case studies were used as survey examples to query obstacles and facilitators to implementing method research. Survey participants were experienced trial staff, identified via email invitations to UK clinical trial units. This survey assessed the case studies' rates of implementation, and demographic characteristics of trial units through the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research. Further, interviews were conducted with senior members of trial units to explore obstacles and facilitators in more detail. Participants were sampled from trial units that indicated their willingness to participate in interviews following the survey. Interviews, and analysis, were structured via the Capability, Opportunity, Motivation Model of Behaviour. Finally, potential strategies to leverage lessons learned were generated via the Behaviour Change Wheel. RESULTS: A total of 27 UK trial units responded to the survey. The rates of implementation across the case studies varied, with most trial units implementing recommendations in trial conduct and only few implementing recommendations in reporting. However, most reported implementing recommendations was important but that they lacked the resources to do so. A total of 16 senior members of trial units were interviewed. Several themes were generated from interviews and fell broadly into categories related to the methods recommendations themselves, the trial units, or external factors affecting implementation. Belief statements within themes indicated resources issues and awareness of recommendations as frequent implementation obstacles. Participation in trial networks and recommendations packaged with relevant resources were cited frequently as implementation facilitators. These obstacles and facilitators mirrored results from the survey. Results were mapped, via the Behaviour Change Wheel, to intervention functions likely to change behaviours of obstacles and facilitators identified. These intervention functions were developed into potential solutions to reduce obstacles and enhance facilitators to implementation. CONCLUSIONS: Several key areas affecting implementation of trial method recommendations were identified. Potential methods to enhance facilitators and reduce obstacles are suggested. Future research is needed to refine these methods and assess their feasibility and acceptability.
引用
- Coffey T, Williamson PR, Gillies K, et al. Understanding implementation of findings from trial method research: a mixed methods study applying implementation frameworks and behaviour change models. Trials. 2024. PMID: 38389093. doi:10.1186/s13063-024-07968-3
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。