临床试验中治疗效应的置信分布:无先验的后验
本文讨论置信分布在随机临床试验治疗效应分析中的应用,其无需设定先验分布即可给出类似后验的概率分布,并与频率学推断完全兼容。文中给出置信分布的介绍、与临床试验相关的示例及基于真实临床试验的案例,建议试验统计师在报告分析时考虑呈现治疗效应的置信分布。
要点
- 置信分布可在不设定先验的情况下总结治疗效应的不确定性,并与频率学推断兼容。
- 置信分布给出的类后验概率分布,与频率学推断所用的相对频率概率解释并存但不同。
- 作者建议试验统计师在报告临床试验分析时考虑呈现治疗效应的置信分布。
核心结论
- 作者建议试验统计师在报告临床试验分析时考虑呈现治疗效应的置信分布。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为方法学论文,讨论置信分布在随机临床试验治疗效应分析中的应用,并给出相关示例与基于真实临床试验的案例。
主要发现
- 置信分布提供无需先验分布、且与频率学推断完全兼容的概率分布,用以总结治疗效应的不确定性。
- 置信分布提供类后验的概率分布,该分布与频率学推断所用的相对频率概率解释不同但并存。
- 尽管已被讨论数十年,置信分布在临床试验统计师中仍不广为人知。
临床怎么用
- 作者建议试验统计师在报告临床试验分析时考虑呈现治疗效应的置信分布。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
An attractive feature of using a Bayesian analysis for a clinical trial is that knowledge and uncertainty about the treatment effect is summarized in a posterior probability distribution. Researchers often find probability statements about treatment effects highly intuitive and the fact that this is not accommodated in frequentist inference is a disadvantage. At the same time, the requirement to specify a prior distribution in order to obtain a posterior distribution is sometimes an artificial process that may introduce subjectivity or complexity into the analysis. This paper considers a compromise involving confidence distributions, which are probability distributions that summarize uncertainty about the treatment effect without the need for a prior distribution and in a way that is fully compatible with frequentist inference. The concept of a confidence distribution provides a posterior-like probability distribution that is distinct from, but exists in tandem with, the relative frequency interpretation of probability used in frequentist inference. Although they have been discussed for decades, confidence distributions are not well known among clinical trial statisticians and the goal of this paper is to discuss their use in analyzing treatment effects from randomized trials. As well as providing an introduction to confidence distributions, some illustrative examples relevant to clinical trials are presented, along with various case studies based on real clinical trials. It is recommended that trial statisticians consider presenting confidence distributions for treatment effects when reporting analyses of clinical trials.
引用
- Marschner IC. Confidence distributions for treatment effects in clinical trials: Posteriors without priors. Stat Med. 2024. PMID: 38205556. doi:10.1002/sim.10000
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。