全随机效应模型在协变量数据缺失时的性能
研究利用全球健康数据集(20421名儿童)构建全随机效应模型(FREM),并通过模拟数据(n=1000)比较FREM与全固定效应模型(FFEM)在协变量数据完全随机缺失(MCAR)和随机缺失(MAR)下的表现。结果显示,随着MCAR缺失比例增加,FREM偏倚仅轻微增加、精度仅轻微损失,在MAR场景下表现相似;而FFEM完整病例分析在MCAR缺失≥70%时崩溃,FFEM均值插补则偏倚大幅增加、精度损失。作者认为FREM适用于协变量数据缺失(MCAR和MAR)的数据集协变量建模。
要点
- FREM在MCAR协变量缺失比例增加时偏倚仅轻微增加、精度仅轻微损失。
- FFEM完整病例分析在MCAR协变量缺失≥70%时崩溃。
- FFEM均值插补在MCAR协变量缺失增加时偏倚大幅增加、精度损失。
核心结论
- FREM是适用于协变量数据缺失(MCAR和MAR)数据集协变量建模的合适方法,例如全球健康研究。
研究设计与样本
- 研究使用全球健康数据集(20421名儿童)构建描述年龄别身高Z评分(HAZ)随时间变化的FREM。
- 生成模拟数据集(n=1000),设置可变比例的MCAR协变量缺失(0%-90%)以及基于观察协变量或预测HAZ的MAR缺失不同比例。
- 使用三种方法重新估计模型并比较偏倚与精度:FREM、FFEM完整病例分析、FFEM均值插补。
主要发现
- 随着MCAR协变量缺失比例增加,FREM偏倚仅轻微增加、精度仅轻微损失。
- FREM在MAR场景下表现与FFEM相似。
- FFEM完整病例分析在MCAR协变量缺失≥70%时崩溃。
- FFEM均值插补在MCAR协变量缺失增加时偏倚大幅增加、精度损失。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
During drug development, a key step is the identification of relevant covariates predicting between-subject variations in drug response. The full random effects model (FREM) is one of the full-covariate approaches used to identify relevant covariates in nonlinear mixed effects models. Here we explore the ability of FREM to handle missing (both missing completely at random (MCAR) and missing at random (MAR)) covariate data and compare it to the full fixed-effects model (FFEM) approach, applied either with complete case analysis or mean imputation. A global health dataset (20 421 children) was used to develop a FREM describing the changes of height for age Z-score (HAZ) over time. Simulated datasets (n = 1000) were generated with variable rates of missing (MCAR) covariate data (0%-90%) and different proportions of missing (MAR) data condition on either observed covariates or predicted HAZ. The three methods were used to re-estimate model and compared in terms of bias and precision which showed that FREM had only minor increases in bias and minor loss of precision at increasing percentages of missing (MCAR) covariate data and performed similarly in the MAR scenarios. Conversely, the FFEM approaches either collapsed at ≥ $$ \ge $$ 70% of missing (MCAR) covariate data (FFEM complete case analysis) or had large bias increases and loss of precision (FFEM with mean imputation). Our results suggest that FREM is an appropriate approach to covariate modeling for datasets with missing (MCAR and MAR) covariate data, such as in global health studies.
引用
- Nyberg J, Jonsson EN, Karlsson MO, et al. Properties of the full random-effect modeling approach with missing covariate data. Stat Med. 2023. PMID: 38128126. doi:10.1002/sim.9979
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。