文献速递流行病学与生物统计

罕见事件Meta分析中风险比或率比随机效应分布的非参数估计:基于arm-based与contrast-based方法

Nonparametric estimation of the random effects distribution for the risk or rate ratio in rare events meta-analysis with the arm-based and contrast-based approaches.
PubMed 文献 · Stat Med · 2023-12-19

针对罕见事件Meta分析中风险比参数的效应异质性估计,本文研究两种基于似然的非参数混合方法:arm-based与contrast-based模型,采用EM算法实现最大似然估计,并通过模拟评估性能。结果显示在嵌套治疗组抽样设计下,基于contrast-based方法的非参数混合模型在AIC和BIC等模型选择准则上更合适;在arm-based设计下arm-based模型表现良好,但部分情况下仍被contrast-based模型超越。

要点

  • 对比了arm-based与contrast-based非参数混合模型估计罕见事件风险比异质性。
  • 模拟显示嵌套治疗组抽样下contrast-based模型按AIC/BIC更合适。
  • 大样本量时contrast-based方法与其他方法差异可忽略。

核心结论

  • 在罕见事件Meta分析中,基于contrast-based方法的非参数混合模型在模型选择准则上表现更合适,尤其在大样本量时与其他方法差异可忽略。

研究设计与样本

  • 方法学研究,采用两种基于似然的非参数混合方法(arm-based与contrast-based模型)估计罕见事件Meta分析中风险比参数的效应异质性,通过EM算法实现最大似然估计,并用模拟评估性能。

主要发现

  • 在嵌套治疗组抽样设计下,基于contrast-based方法的非参数混合模型在AIC和BIC等模型选择准则上更合适。
  • 在arm-based设计下,arm-based模型表现良好,但部分情况下仍被contrast-based模型超越。
  • 模拟中,contrast-based方法在估计效应异质性方面似乎优于所比较的方法,但当研究内样本量较大时差异可忽略。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Rare events are events which occur with low frequencies. These often arise in clinical trials or cohort studies where the data are arranged in binary contingency tables. In this article, we investigate the estimation of effect heterogeneity for the risk-ratio parameter in meta-analysis of rare events studies through two likelihood-based nonparametric mixture approaches: an arm-based and a contrast-based model. Maximum likelihood estimation is achieved using the EM algorithm. Special attention is given to the choice of initial values. Inspired by the classification likelihood, a strategy is implemented which repeatably uses random allocation of the studies to the mixture components as choice of initial values. The likelihoods under the contrast-based and arm-based approaches are compared and differences are highlighted. We use simulations to assess the performance of these two methods. Under the design of sampling studies with nested treatment groups, the results show that the nonparametric mixture model based on the contrast-based approach is more appropriate in terms of model selection criteria such as AIC and BIC. Under the arm-based design the results from the arm-based model performs well although in some cases it is also outperformed by the contrast-based model. Comparisons of the estimators are provided in terms of bias and mean squared error. Also included in the comparison is the mixed Poisson regression model as well as the classical DerSimonian-Laird model (using the Mantel-Haenszel estimator for the common effect). Using simulation, estimating effect heterogeneity in the case of the contrast-based method appears to behave better than the compared methods although differences become negligible for large within-study sample sizes. We illustrate the methodologies using several meta-analytic data sets in medicine.

来源:Stat Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Sangnawakij P, Böhning D, Holling H, et al. Nonparametric estimation of the random effects distribution for the risk or rate ratio in rare events meta-analysis with the arm-based and contrast-based approaches. Stat Med. 2023. PMID: 38111986. doi:10.1002/sim.9981

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。