优化动态系统评价的流程与方法:历经30次检索更新与3次系统评价更新后的经验
本文描述Cochrane动态系统评价(LSR)的流程,并分享从规划、检索、筛选、提取、发表到传播的经验,以帮助计划开展LSR的作者。该LSR由国际作者团队实施,已持续两年,每月进行检索更新,期间共发表3次完整更新。作者建议LSR应具备合理依据、周密规划(包括检索更新频率、发表与终止触发条件)、及时发表、清晰的传播计划以及强大的核心作者团队。
要点
- LSR流程需在方案中明确检索频率与完整更新的触发条件。
- 每月检索更新要求有清晰的周期性活动计划并简化流程。
- LSR应具备合理依据、周密规划、及时发表、清晰传播计划及强大核心团队。
核心结论
- 作者推荐LSR应具备合理依据、周密规划(包括检索更新时机、发表与终止触发条件)、及时发表、清晰的传播计划以及强大的核心作者团队。
研究设计与样本
- 研究设计为对一项Cochrane动态系统评价(LSR)流程与经验的描述,该LSR由国际作者团队实施,已持续两年,每月进行检索更新,期间共发表3次完整更新。
主要发现
- LSR流程中需考虑的关键特征包括:在方案中明确检索频率与完整更新的触发条件、利益相关者输入、发表与传播每月检索结果。
- 强大且包含方法与主题专业知识的团队,以及定期会面的核心成员至关重要;定期检索更新要求有清晰的周期性活动计划。
- 为实现及时更新,流程应简化,例如使用自动化每月检索和系统评价软件进行筛选;LSR为纳入利益相关者反馈提供了独特机会。
临床怎么用
- 作者推荐LSR应具备合理依据、周密规划(包括检索更新时机、发表与终止触发条件)、及时发表、清晰的传播计划以及强大的核心作者团队。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To describe the living systematic review (LSR) process and to share experience of planning, searches, screening, extraction, publishing and dissemination to inform and assist authors planning their own LSR. Many LSR do not publish more than one update, we hope this paper helps to increase this. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: A Cochrane LSR with an international author team that has been 'living' for two years, with monthly search updates and three full updates published in this time. LSRs are regularly updated systematic reviews that allow new evidence to be incorporated as it becomes available. LSR are ideally suited to policy-relevant topics where there is uncertainty and new evidence will likely impact the interpretation and/or certainty of outcomes. RESULTS: The key features of the process that require consideration are: specifying the frequency of searches and triggers for full updates in the protocol; stakeholder input; publishing and disseminating monthly search findings. A strong team, incorporating methodological and topic expertise, with core members that meet regularly is essential. Regular search updates make it important to have a clear cyclical schedule of activity. To achieve timely updates this process should be streamlined, for example, using automated monthly searches, and systematic reviewing software for screening. LSR provide a unique opportunity to incorporate stakeholder feedback. CONCLUSIONS: We recommend that LSRs should be: justified; carefully planned including the timing of search updates, triggers for publication and termination; published in a timely manner; have a clear dissemination plan; and a strong core team of authors.
引用
- Butler AR, Hartmann-Boyce J, Livingstone-Banks J, et al. Optimizing process and methods for a living systematic review: 30 search updates and three review updates later. J Clin Epidemiol. 2023. PMID: 38043829. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2023.111231
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。