颞下颌关节紊乱病继发慢性疼痛的治疗:随机试验的系统综述与网状Meta分析
该系统综述与网状Meta分析检索MEDLINE、EMBASE、CINAHL、CENTRAL和SCOPUS至2021年5月并于2023年1月再次检索,纳入233项随机对照试验,其中153项(8713例受试者、59种干预或干预组合)进入网状Meta分析。结果显示,在中等至高质量证据下,促进应对与鼓励活动运动的干预对缓解慢性颞下颌关节紊乱病疼痛最有效。
要点
- 认知行为疗法联合生物反馈或放松治疗、治疗师辅助下颌松动术、手法触发点治疗可能对疼痛缓解最有效。
- 认知行为疗法、监督下姿势锻炼、监督下颌锻炼与拉伸等干预效果较弱但仍优于安慰剂。
- 疼痛缓解与物理功能以外结局及所有不良事件证据的质量为低或极低。
核心结论
- 在中等或高质量证据范围内,促进应对并鼓励活动与运动的干预对减轻慢性颞下颌关节紊乱病疼痛最为有效。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与随机临床试验网状Meta分析,检索MEDLINE、EMBASE、CINAHL、CENTRAL和SCOPUS至2021年5月并于2023年1月再次检索。
- 233项试验符合纳入标准,其中153项试验(8713例受试者、59种干预或干预组合)纳入网状Meta分析。
- 由成对评价者独立筛选研究、提取数据并评估偏倚风险,采用频率学网状Meta分析汇总证据,并用GRADE方法评定证据确定性。
主要发现
- 疼痛缓解方面有8种干预获得高至中等确定性证据支持,所有效应均为与安慰剂或假操作比较。
- 疼痛缓解可能最有效的三种疗法:认知行为疗法联合生物反馈或放松治疗(达到10 cm视觉模拟量表上1 cm最小重要差异的风险差36%(95%CI 33至39))、治疗师辅助下颌松动术(风险差36%(95%CI 31至40))、手法触发点治疗(风险差32%(95%CI 29至34))。
- 另有5种干预效果较弱但仍优于安慰剂,风险差介于23%至30%:认知行为疗法、监督下姿势锻炼、监督下颌锻炼与拉伸、监督下颌锻炼与拉伸联合手法触发点治疗、常规照护(如居家锻炼、自我拉伸、安抚)。
- 中等确定性证据显示4种干预可能改善物理功能:监督下颌锻炼与拉伸(达到简表-36物理成分总分量表5分最小重要差异的风险差43%(95%CI 33至51))、手法治疗(风险差43%(95%CI 25至56))、针灸(风险差42%(95%CI 33至50))、监督下颌锻炼与松动术(风险差36%(95%CI 19至51))。
- 其他干预的疼痛缓解或物理功能证据以及所有不良事件证据均为低或极低确定性。
关键数值与推荐
- 疼痛缓解最有效:认知行为疗法联合生物反馈或放松治疗风险差36%(95%CI 33至39),治疗师辅助下颌松动术风险差36%(95%CI 31至40),手法触发点治疗风险差32%(95%CI 29至34),均为与安慰剂或假操作比较。
- 效果较弱但仍优于安慰剂的5种干预风险差为23%至30%,包括认知行为疗法、监督下姿势锻炼、监督下颌锻炼与拉伸、监督下颌锻炼与拉伸联合手法触发点治疗、常规照护。
- 物理功能改善:监督下颌锻炼与拉伸风险差43%(95%CI 33至51),手法治疗风险差43%(95%CI 25至56),针灸风险差42%(95%CI 33至50),监督下颌锻炼与松动术风险差36%(95%CI 19至51)。
临床怎么用
- 作者结论认为,在中等或高质量证据范围内,促进应对并鼓励活动与运动的干预对减轻慢性颞下颌关节紊乱病疼痛最为有效。
局限性
- 其他干预的疼痛缓解或物理功能证据以及所有不良事件证据为低或极低确定性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: We explored the comparative effectiveness of available therapies for chronic pain associated with temporomandibular disorders (TMD). DESIGN: Systematic review and network meta-analysis of randomised clinical trials (RCTs). DATA SOURCES: MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL, CENTRAL, and SCOPUS were searched to May 2021, and again in January 2023. STUDY SELECTION: Interventional RCTs that enrolled patients presenting with chronic pain associated with TMD. DATA EXTRACTION AND SYNTHESIS: Pairs of reviewers independently identified eligible studies, extracted data, and assessed risk of bias. We captured all reported patient-important outcomes, including pain relief, physical functioning, emotional functioning, role functioning, social functioning, sleep quality, and adverse events. We conducted frequentist network meta-analyses to summarise the evidence and used the GRADE approach to rate the certainty of evidence and categorise interventions from most to least beneficial. RESULTS: 233 trials proved eligible for review, of which 153-enrolling 8713 participants and exploring 59 interventions or combinations of interventions-were included in network meta-analyses. All subsequent effects refer to comparisons with placebo or sham procedures. Effects on pain for eight interventions were supported by high to moderate certainty evidence. The three therapies probably most effective for pain relief were cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) augmented with biofeedback or relaxation therapy (risk difference (RD) for achieving the minimally important difference (MID) in pain relief of 1 cm on a 10 cm visual analogue scale: 36% (95% CI 33 to 39)), therapist-assisted jaw mobilisation (RD 36% (95% CI 31 to 40)), and manual trigger point therapy (RD 32% (29 to 34)). Five interventions were less effective, yet more effective than placebo, showing RDs ranging between 23% and 30%: CBT, supervised postural exercise, supervised jaw exercise and stretching, supervised jaw exercise and stretching with manual trigger point therapy, and usual care (such as home exercises, self stretching, reassurance).Moderate certainty evidence showed four interventions probably improved physical functioning: supervised jaw exercise and stretching (RD for achieving the MID of 5 points on the short form-36 physical component summary score: 43% (95% CI 33 to 51)), manipulation (RD 43% (25 to 56)), acupuncture (RD 42% (33 to 50)), and supervised jaw exercise and mobilisation (RD 36% (19 to 51)). The evidence for pain relief or physical functioning among other interventions, and all evidence for adverse events, was low or very low certainty. CONCLUSION: When restricted to moderate or high certainty evidence, interventions that promote coping and encourage movement and activity were found to be most effective for reducing chronic TMD pain. REGISTRATION: PROSPERO (CRD42021258567).
引用
- Yao L, Sadeghirad B, Li M, et al. Management of chronic pain secondary to temporomandibular disorders: a systematic review and network meta-analysis of randomised trials. BMJ. 2023. PMID: 38101924. doi:10.1136/bmj-2023-076226
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。