指南小组社会动态影响临床实践推荐意见的形成:一项混合方法系统综述
该混合方法系统综述检索文献数据库,纳入12项来自6个国家的研究,分析指南制定会议中的认知与社会过程。发现主席、联合主席和方法学家贡献至少三分之一的讨论时间,患者伙伴贡献最少;男性性别和医生职业与贡献量正相关;未采用GRADE方法的小组在证据不足或质量低时更依赖临床经验;会议中存在认知「是」偏倚。
要点
- 主席、联合主席和方法学家贡献至少三分之一的讨论时间,患者伙伴贡献最少。
- 在跨学科小组中,男性性别和医生职业与贡献量呈正相关。
- 未采用GRADE方法的小组在证据不足或质量低时更依赖临床经验。
核心结论
- 讨论的社会动态与每位小组成员的活跃角色、专业背景和性别相关,这些因素影响了其在指南制定会议中的贡献水平。
研究设计与样本
- 采用收敛分离式方法的混合方法系统综述,检索文献数据库中研究指南制定会议组内动态的实证研究,共筛选5899条引文,最终纳入来自6个国家的12项研究。
主要发现
- 主席、联合主席和方法学家贡献了指南制定会议中至少三分之一的讨论时间;患者伙伴贡献最少。
- 在跨学科小组中,男性性别和医生职业与贡献量呈正相关。
- 与采用GRADE方法的小组相比,未采用GRADE方法的小组在面临证据不足或低质量证据时更依赖其临床经验。
- 会议中存在明显的认知「是」偏倚:小组成员倾向于顺从肯定性陈述,因为肯定性陈述比否定性陈述需要更少的认知努力。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To synthesize empirical studies that investigate the cognitive and social processes involved in the deliberation process of guideline development meetings and determine the distribution of deliberated topics. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We conducted a mixed-method systematic review using a convergent segregated approach. We searched for empirical studies that investigate the intragroup dynamics of guideline development meetings indexed in bibliographic databases. RESULTS: Of the 5,899 citations screened, 12 studies from six countries proved eligible. Chairs, cochairs, and methodologists contributed to at least one-third of the discussion time in guideline development meetings; patient partners contributed the least. In interdisciplinary groups, male gender and occupation as a physician were positively associated with the amount of contribution. Compared to groups that used the Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation approach, for groups that did not, when faced with insufficient or low-quality evidence, relied more on their clinical experience. The presence of a cognitive "yes" bias was apparent in meetings: panelists tended to acquiesce with positive statements that required less cognitive effort than negative statements. CONCLUSION: The social dynamics of the discussions were linked to each panelist's activity role, professional background, and gender, all of which influenced the level of contributions they made in guideline development meetings.
引用
- Li SA, Guyatt GH, Yao L, et al. Guideline panel social dynamics influence the development of clinical practice recommendations: a mixed-methods systematic review. J Clin Epidemiol. 2023. PMID: 38036187. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2023.111224
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。