探索新冠疫情期间被隔离防护的初级医生的经历:一项半结构化访谈的定性研究
该定性研究通过2022年9月2日至11月30日的半结构化访谈,了解苏格兰11名初级医生和2名顾问在新冠疫情期间因屏蔽措施离开临床环境的经历。多数初级医生感到工作被低估、支持不足,并遭遇负面态度。作者认为支持体系不适用,建议改善支持基础设施以构建更具包容性的临床环境。
要点
- 多数初级医生(73%,8/11)感到屏蔽期间工作被低估,所有参与者报告职业健康和工作场所支持不足。
- 82%(9/11)的初级医生遭遇负面态度,包括合理调整被拒和面临解雇威胁。
- 顾问面临监督挑战,缺乏指导与资源,且疫情后支持残疾和怀孕初级医生的问题持续存在。
核心结论
- 屏蔽对初级医生造成负面影响,支持基础设施不适用,作者建议改善支持基础设施以迈向更具包容性的临床环境。
研究设计与样本
- 定性研究,采用个体半结构化访谈和反思性主题分析,于2022年9月2日至11月30日进行虚拟访谈。
- 通过苏格兰范围的目的性和滚雪球抽样招募11名初级医生和2名顾问,13名参与者中12名为女性。
主要发现
- 多数初级医生(73%,8/11)认为屏蔽期间工作被低估,感到被遗忘,需纠缠主管才能获得工作任务。
- 所有参与者报告职业健康和工作场所层面支持不足,包括监督有限或培训影响信息缺乏。
- 82%(9/11)的初级医生遭遇负面态度,包括合理调整被拒和如不遵循屏蔽建议则面临解雇威胁。
- 顾问描述监督挑战,包括未收到指导或资源,以及疫情后支持残疾和怀孕初级医生的持续问题。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 样本量小。
- 研究限于特定区域。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The term "Shielding" was introduced in the UK during the COVID-19 pandemic to protect approximately 4 million people at highest risk from infection. Shielding was characterised by extreme isolation and applied to those with certain illnesses, disabilities, and during pregnancy. For the estimated 1300 high-risk doctors, shielding meant abrupt departure from the clinical environment. We aimed to understand the impact of shielding on junior doctors (JDs) by interviewing them and their consultants. METHODS: This qualitative study used individual semi-structured interviews and reflexive thematic analysis. Virtual interviews were conducted between Sept 2, and Nov 30, 2022, using an interview guide, including open questions around impacts on training, career, and health. 11 JDs and 2 consultants were recruited via Scotland-wide purposive and snowball sampling. Written informed consent was obtained. 12 of 13 participants were women. Eight JDs were shielding because of health issues, and three because of pregnancy. Participant specialties included primary care, secondary care, and foundation and specialty training. Interview transcripts were coded by the lead author and the second author acted as a critical friend. FINDINGS: Despite making important contributions working from home, most JDs (73%, eight of 11) felt that their work was undervalued during shielding. They felt forgotten, feeling they had to "pester" supervisors to be allocated work. All participants reported inadequate support at Occupational Health and workplace levels, including limited supervision or information about training impacts. Negative attitudes towards JDs were experienced by 82% (nine of 11) of JDs, including being denied reasonable adjustments and threatened with dismissal if not following shielding advice. Consultants described supervisory challenges including not receiving guidance or resources and ongoing issues supporting disabled and pregnant JDs beyond the pandemic. INTERPRETATION: These findings offer novel qualitative insight into the impacts of shielding on JDs in Scotland. Findings indicated that support infrastructure was not fit for purpose. Given the significant number of JDs that take prolonged leave from the clinical environment, and the JDs working with disabilities and during pregnancy, these findings are of ongoing concern. Although the sample size was small and the study was set in a specific region, these findings suggest there is potential to improve support infrastructure and move towards a more inclusive clinical environment that recognises, celebrates, and benefits from the value of a diverse workforce. FUNDING: Scottish Medical Education Research Consortium.
引用
- Martin A, Jamieson S. Exploring the experiences of junior doctors who were shielding during the COVID-19 pandemic: a qualitative study of semi-structured interviews. Lancet. 2023. PMID: 37997112. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(23)02084-6
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。