文献速递临床试验与 GCP流行病学与生物统计

临床试验中条件性与非条件性激励对最大化参与者完成问卷返还的对比:一项试验内整群随机研究

Conditional versus non-conditional incentives to maximise return of participant completed questionnaires in clinical trials: a cluster randomised study within a trial.
PubMed 文献 · Trials · 2023-11-07

该研究嵌套于ALIC4E试验,以全科诊所整群随机比较招募时即发代金券(非条件性)与返还14天日记后发放(条件性)对随访问卷返还比例的影响。42个随机化站点中仅28个招募到至少1名参与者,原始返还比例分别为0.58(127/220)与0.73(91/125),校正站点配对后差异无统计学显著(-0.09,95%CI -0.29至0.10,P=0.34)。结论为无明确证据表明两组返还比例存在差异,结果存在较大统计不确定性。

要点

  • 条件性与非条件性代金券激励的日记返还比例无显著差异(校正后-0.09,95%CI -0.29至0.10,P=0.34)。
  • 两组问卷返还时间和完成页数比例在主分析中均无统计学显著差异(均P>0.05)。
  • 基于观察数据,条件性激励每份返还日记约节省23英镑;部分敏感性分析提示条件性激励可能存在有意义的获益。

核心结论

  • 条件性与非条件性激励组在参与者完成日记返还比例上无明确统计学显著差异,问卷返还时间和完成度两组相似,结果存在较大统计不确定性。

研究设计与样本

  • 一项嵌套于ALIC4E试验的整群随机试验内研究,匹配站点对(全科诊所)按计算机生成随机数分为非条件性或条件性代金券激励组。
  • 共42个站点随机(每组21个),仅28个站点招募到至少1名参与者,仅10个站点对的两个组成站点均招募到参与者。

主要发现

  • 非条件性激励组原始日记返还比例为0.58(127/220),条件性激励组为0.73(91/125)。
  • 校正站点配对后回归分析显示返还比例无显著差异(-0.09,95%CI -0.29至0.10,P=0.34);加权分析仍无明确差异(0.15,95%CI -0.02至0.31,P=0.07)。
  • 主分析中两组问卷返还时间和完成页数比例均无统计学显著差异(均P>0.05)。
  • 基于观察数据,条件性激励每份返还日记约节省23英镑。

局限性

  • 42个随机化站点中仅28个招募到至少1名参与者,仅10个站点对的两个组成站点均招募到参与者。
  • 结果存在较大统计不确定性,部分敏感性分析提示条件性激励可能存在有意义的获益。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: High participant retention enhances the validity of clinical trials. A monetary incentive can increase retention, but it is not known if when it is provided and if it is conditional matters. We aimed to determine whether there was a difference in the number of follow-up trial questionnaires returned when a monetary (gift voucher) incentive was given to participants at recruitment (non-conditional), compared to informing participants at recruitment that the incentive would be given only once their 14-day daily diary (questionnaire) had been returned (conditional). METHOD: A cluster randomised study within a trial embedded within the Antivirals for influenza-Like Illness, An rCt of Clinical and Cost effectiveness in primary CarE (ALIC4E) Trial. Matched site pairs (GP practices) were randomised using computer-generated random numbers, to either a non-conditional or conditional monetary voucher incentive (only once their 14-day daily diary (questionnaire) had been returned. Sites were matched on previous recruitment levels and practice list size. Analyses were conducted according to randomised groups irrespective of compliance with a two-sided 5% level statistical significance level. The main analysis of the primary outcome (site proportion of diaries returned) was linear regression accounting for site pair (using cluster-robust variance). Additional weighted, paired and non-parametric sensitivity analyses were conducted. Secondary outcomes were the site average number of completed pages, time to return diary, and cost related to the incentive (administration and postage). RESULTS: Of the 42 randomised sites (21 for each intervention), only 28 recruited at least one participant with only 10 practice pairs recruiting participants at both constituent sites. Raw diaries return proportions were 0.58 (127/220) and 0.73 (91/125) for non-conditional and conditional incentive groups. Regression analysis adjusted for site pair showed no significant difference in returns, - 0.09, (95% CI, - 0.29, 0.10, p = 0.34); when weighted, there was still no clear difference: 0.15 (95% CI, - 0.02, 0.31, p = 0.07). There was no clear statistical evidence of a difference in time taken to return questionnaires, nor the proportion of pages completed, by the intervention group in the main analyses (all p > 0.05). The conditional incentive was approximately £23 cheaper per diary returned based upon observed data. CONCLUSION: There was no clear evidence of a statistically significant difference in the proportion of participant-completed diaries returned between conditional or non-conditional incentive groups. The time to questionnaire return and completeness of the returned questionnaires were similar in both groups. There was substantial statistical uncertainty in the findings. Some of the sensitivity analyses suggested that a meaningful benefit of a conditional incentive of a magnitude that would be meaningful was plausible. The conditional approach costs less in cash terms.

来源:Trials,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Cook J, Cook JA, Bongard E, et al. Conditional versus non-conditional incentives to maximise return of participant completed questionnaires in clinical trials: a cluster randomised study within a trial. Trials. 2023. PMID: 37936228. doi:10.1186/s13063-023-07604-6

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。