英格兰未来烟草控制政策的健康、经济与公平后果:一项微观模拟研究
研究用IMPACTHINT微观模拟模型模拟英格兰30-89岁成人2023至2072年,评估五种烟草控制情景。所有情景均无法在2030年前将吸烟率降至5%以下,但增税30%联合强化戒烟服务可使所有人群在2035年达标,且最富裕五分位组比最贫困组早约十年达标;所有政策均较基线趋势节省成本。
要点
- 增税30%联合强化戒烟服务可使所有剥夺程度人群在2035年达到吸烟率低于5%的目标。
- 最富裕五分位组可在2032年达标,最贫困组需至2038年,差距约十年。
- 到2072年联合情景可减少16万例吸烟相关疾病,增税情景减少14万例。
核心结论
- 富裕人群比最贫困人群早约十年达到5%无烟目标,但通过烟草税增加30%并强化戒烟服务,所有人群可在2035年达标。
- 所有模拟政策与基线趋势相比均节省成本。
研究设计与样本
- 开发、校准并验证微观模拟模型IMPACTHINT,模拟英格兰30-89岁成人2023至2072年的吸烟史与政策结局。
- 模拟五种情景:基线趋势、最低购烟年龄提高至21岁(MinAge21)、烟草税增加30%(TaxUP)、强化戒烟服务(ServicesUP)、TaxUP与ServicesUP联合。
- 从社会视角评估成本效果,并按剥夺五分位组分析公平性。
主要发现
- 无任何情景可在2030年前将总体吸烟率降至5%以下。
- TaxUP及TaxUP联合ServicesUP情景可在2035年达标,ServicesUP情景可在2037年达标,MinAge21与基线情景可在2038年达标。
- TaxUP所减少的全部疾病年数中约50%发生在最贫困五分位组。
- 最富裕五分位组比最贫困组更早达到5%目标(最不贫困组2032年 vs 最贫困组2038年),联合情景下最不贫困组可在2030年达标。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文指出局限性包括任何50年预测均存在不确定性。
- 原文指出该长时间跨度可捕捉政策对较年轻年龄组的潜在获益。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Smoking still generates a huge, costly, and inequitable burden of disease. The UK tobacco-free generation target to reduce smoking prevalence to below 5% by 2030 will be missed if current trends continue. We aimed to determine whether additional policies could speed progress towards meeting the tobacco-free generation target. METHODS: We developed, calibrated, and validated a microsimulation model, IMPACTHINT simulating English adults aged 30-89 years from 2023 to 2072. The model included a detailed smoking history and quantified policy health outcomes including smoking prevalence and smoking-related diseases, economics, and equity. We simulated five scenarios: (1) baseline trends; (2) increasing the minimum age of access to tobacco to 21 years (MinAge21); (3) a 30% increase in tobacco duty (TaxUP); (4) improved smoking cessation services (ServicesUP); and (5) a combination of TaxUP and ServicesUP. We estimated the smoking prevalence, smoking-related diseases and cumulative cases prevented or postponed, and deaths. We evaluated the scenario cost-effectiveness from the societal perspective. Lastly, we analysed the results by deprivation quintile. We present in our findings cumulative cases prevented or postponed over 50 years. FINDINGS: None of the scenarios would reduce overall smoking prevalence to below 5% by 2030. However, that goal could be reached by 2035 under the TaxUP and the combination of TaxUP and ServicesUP scenarios, by 2037 under the ServicesUP scenario, or by 2038 under the MinAge21 and the baseline scenarios. By 2072, the combined scenario might reduce smoking-related diseases by 160 000 cases (95% CI 140 000-200 000), greatly exceeding the reductions by 140 000 cases (120 000-180 000) with TaxUP, 69 000 cases (53 000-86 000) with MinAge21, or 22 000 cases (14 000-31 000) with ServicesUP. Some 50% of all disease-years reduced by TaxUP would occur in the most deprived quintile. The most affluent quintile could reach the 5% goal sooner than the most deprived quintile (by 2032 for the least deprived vs 2038 for the most deprived), and it could reach the 5% target by 2030 under the combined TaxUP and ServicesUP scenario. Finally, all policies would save costs compared with the baseline trend. INTERPRETATION: Affluent groups will achieve the 5% tobacco-free goal a decade sooner than the most deprived. However, that goal could be achieved in all groups by 2035 through a 30% increase in tax and enhanced smoking cessation services. Our limitations included the uncertainties of any 50-year forecast. However, that long time-horizon can capture the potential policy benefits for younger age groups. FUNDING: Economic and Social Research Council.
引用
- Huang V, Buchan I, Capewell S, et al. Health, economic, and equity consequences of future tobacco control policies in England: a microsimulation study. Lancet. 2023. PMID: 37997095. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(23)02079-2
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。