解释人口健康干预中社会经济效应的差异:一种新工具的开发与应用,用于分类干预的能动性需求
研究开发了一种分类人口健康干预能动性需求的新工具,通过系统识别饮食与身体活动干预、编码干预行动者与行动、专家反馈及信度评估形成工具,并在26项干预的163个组分中验证其可行性。干预组分分类与干预公平性相关,但与有效性无关。
要点
- 新工具基于暴露、作用机制和参与三个概念形成20个能动性需求类别。
- 在26项人口健康干预的163个组分中,组分集中于少数类别。
- 组分分类与干预公平性相关,但与干预有效性无关。
核心结论
- 研究提出了一种分类人口健康干预能动性需求的新工具,并在系统综述中证明其可行性。
- 将干预类型与其对不平等的影响联系起来,有助于在设计或选择干预时考虑这些因素。
研究设计与样本
- 迭代开发过程包括系统识别饮食与身体活动人口健康干预、编码干预行动者与行动、数据合成、专家定性反馈和信度评估。
- 检索九个数据库,纳入2010年1月1日至2020年8月17日发表的文章。
- 在概念验证综述中,从三个已有的关注公平的系统综述中提取研究,应用最终工具。
主要发现
- 识别出影响干预组分能动性需求的三个概念:暴露(两个水平)、作用机制(五个水平)和参与(两个水平)。
- 组合这些概念形成20个类别,将具有相似能动性需求的干预分组。
- 在综述中,工具应用于26项人口健康干预,共包括163个组分。
- 干预组分集中在少数类别中,其分类与干预公平性相关,但与有效性无关。
临床怎么用
- 工具使用者可以避免实施可能扩大不平等的干预类型,或与对策一起实施以最小化任何不利的公平效应。
- 在未来研究、政策和实践中应用该工具来设计、选择、评估和合成人口健康干预的证据,有可能增进对干预如何起作用及其对社会经济不平等影响的理解。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The agentic demand of population health interventions (PHIs) might influence how interventions work. Highly agentic interventions (eg, information campaigns) rely on recipients noticing and responding to the intervention. Resources required for individuals to benefit from highly agentic interventions have a socioeconomical pattern, thus agentic demand might affect intervention effectiveness and equity. Systematic evidence exploring these associations is missing due to the absence of adequate tools to classify agentic demands. We aimed to develop such a tool and test its application. METHODS: Our iterative development process involved: (1) systematic identification of diet and physical activity PHIs; (2) coding of intervention actors and actions; (3) data synthesis; (4) expert qualitative feedback; and (5) reliability assessment. We searched nine databases for articles published between Jan 1, 2010, and Aug 17, 2020. For all included articles, we coded the actors (people required to act within an intervention) and their actions (what they were required to do for the intervention to have its intended effects). We combined these codes for similar intervention types to develop overarching schematic flow chart diagrams used to identify concepts, and we organised these into a draft tool. After expert feedback, and we assessed inter-rater reliability of the final version. We applied the final tool in a proof-of-concept review, extracting studies from three existing equity-focused systematic reviews on tool category, overall intervention effect, and differential socioeconomic effects and visualised findings. FINDINGS: We identified three concepts affecting agentic demands of intervention components: exposure, two levels (how recipients encounter the intervention); mechanism of action, five levels; and engagement, two levels (how recipients respond to the intervention). We then combined these concepts to form 20 categories that grouped together interventions with similar agentic demands. In the review, we applied the tool to 26 PHIs that included 163 components. Intervention components were concentrated in a small number of categories, and their categorisation was related to intervention equity but not to effectiveness. INTERPRETATION: We present a novel tool to classify the agentic demand of PHIs and demonstrate its feasibility within a systematic review. Linking intervention types to their effect on inequalities enables these factors to be considered when designing or selecting interventions. Users of the tool can avoid implementing intervention types that are likely to widen inequalities or implement them alongside counter-strategies to minimise any adverse equity effects. Applying this tool within future research, policy, and practice to design, select, evaluate, and synthesise evidence from PHIs has the potential to advance our understanding of how interventions work and their effect on socioeconomic inequalities. FUNDING: Public Health Policy Research Unit (PH-PRU), National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Policy Research Programme.
引用
- Garrott K, Ogilvie D, Panter J, et al. Explaining differential socioeconomic effects in population health interventions: development and application of a new tool to classify intervention agentic demand. Lancet. 2023. PMID: 37997070. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(23)02056-1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。