改善严重多重劣势人群口腔健康及物质使用、吸烟、饮食等相关健康行为的干预措施:有效性与成本效果的系统综述
该系统综述检索至2023年2月,纳入38项研究(23项随机对照试验和11项准实验研究),评估改善严重多重劣势(SMD)成人群体口腔健康及物质使用、吸烟、不良饮食等行为的干预措施的有效性与成本效果。多组分干预(如住房服务联合物质使用和心理健康支持)可有效减少物质使用,但随访期短、失访率高;仅1项研究关注口腔健康结局,无研究关注饮食,3项随机对照试验涉及吸烟。部分有限证据提示物质使用干预具有成本效果。
要点
- 多组分干预(住房联合物质使用和心理健康支持)可有效减少SMD群体的物质使用。
- 仅1项研究评估口腔健康结局,无研究关注饮食,3项随机对照试验涉及吸烟。
- 部分有限证据提示物质使用干预具有成本效果。
核心结论
- 将住房等服务与其他医疗服务整合可能有效改善健康行为,尤其是SMD群体的物质使用。
- 仍需更多专门针对口腔健康、吸烟和饮食干预的证据。
- 本综述结果的普适性限于高收入国家和较短期的结局。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索MEDLINE、EMBASE、PsycINFO、CINAHL、EBSCO、Scopus及灰色文献,发表时间从建库至2023年2月。
- 纳入随机对照试验、比较研究和经济学评价,由两名研究者独立筛选,评估偏倚风险,结果进行叙述性综合。
- 共纳入38项研究(发表于1991年至2023年),其中34项报告有效性,包括23项随机对照试验和11项准实验研究。
- 研究地点:美国25项、加拿大7项、法国1项、西班牙1项。
- 已在PROSPERO注册,注册号CRD42020202416。
主要发现
- 涉及多组分的干预(如住房服务联合物质使用和心理健康支持)有效减少了SMD群体的物质使用,且多为个体水平干预。
- 这些研究随访期短且失访率高。
- 仅1项研究关注口腔健康结局,无研究关注饮食,3项随机对照试验涉及吸烟,其中1项干预显示4周时戒烟。
- 部分有限证据提示物质使用干预具有成本效果。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 这些研究随访期短且失访率高。
- 仅1项研究关注口腔健康结局,无研究关注饮食,3项随机对照试验涉及吸烟。
- 部分有限证据提示物质使用干预具有成本效果。
- 本综述结果的普适性限于高收入国家和较短期的结局。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Homelessness overlapping with substance use and offending is described as severe and multiple disadvantage (SMD). People experiencing SMD have poor oral health along with high levels of related behaviours such as substance use, smoking, and poor diet. Existing evidence largely describes the prevalence of oral health problems, substance use, and smoking in SMD groups. Little is known about interventions that can address these conditions in SMD groups. We aimed to review the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of interventions on oral health and related health behaviours in adults experiencing SMD. METHODS: For this systematic review, we searched bibliographic databases (MEDLINE, EMBASE, PsycINFO, CINAHL, EBSCO, Scopus) and grey literature for papers published from inception to February 2023. Two researchers independently reviewed the searches. Randomised controlled trials (RCTs), comparative studies and economic evaluations were included. Risk of bias was assessed. Population included adults experiencing SMD (including homelessness and substance use or repeat offending). Outcomes included oral health, and related behaviours (substance use, smoking, poor diet). Results were narratively synthesised. This review was registered with PROSPERO, CRD42020202416. FINDINGS: The review included 38 studies (published between 1991 and 2023), with 34 reporting effectiveness. These studies comprised of 23 RCTs and 11 quasi-experimental studies conducted in the USA (25 studies), Canada (seven studies), France (one study), and Spain (one study). The interventions involving multiple components, such as housing services with substance use and mental health support, effectively reduced substance use in SMD groups; these were mostly individual-level interventions. However, these studies had short follow-up periods and high attrition rates. Only one study addressed oral health outcomes, none focused on diet, and three RCTs covered smoking, with one intervention showing smoking abstinence at 4 weeks. Some limited evidence suggested cost-effectiveness of substance use interventions. INTERPRETATION: This review found that integrating services such as housing with other health-care services together could be effective in improving health behaviours, especially substance use among SMD groups. More evidence is needed specifically on oral health, smoking, and diet-related interventions. The generalisability of findings of this review is limited to high-income countries and shorter-term outcomes. FUNDING: National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Policy Research Programme.
引用
- John DA, McGowan LJ, Kenny RPW, et al. Interventions to improve oral health and related health behaviours of substance use, smoking, and diet in people with severe and multiple disadvantage: a systematic review of effectiveness and cost-effectiveness. Lancet. 2023. PMID: 37997101. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(23)02151-7
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。