脊髓损伤患者的运动与有氧能力:系统综述及荟萃分析与荟萃回归
该系统综述纳入120项研究,主要荟萃分析显示运动超过2周可显著改善脊髓损伤患者峰值摄氧量和峰值功率输出;汇总荟萃分析提示最长12周的运动干预对相对峰值摄氧量改善最大,上肢有氧运动和抗阻训练似乎最有效;证据确定性为中等至低。
要点
- 运动超过2周可显著改善脊髓损伤患者绝对和相对峰值摄氧量及峰值功率输出。
- 持续达12周的运动干预对相对峰值摄氧量的改善最大。
- 上肢有氧运动和抗阻训练似乎对改善相对峰值摄氧量和峰值功率输出最有效。
核心结论
- 主要荟萃分析证实,进行超过2周的运动可使脊髓损伤个体的绝对峰值摄氧量、相对峰值摄氧量和峰值功率输出显著改善。
- 汇总荟萃分析的亚组比较发现,持续达12周的运动干预对相对峰值摄氧量产生最大变化。
- 上肢有氧运动和抗阻训练似乎对改善相对峰值摄氧量和峰值功率输出最有效。
- 此外,急性损伤、截瘫个体每周运动≥3次可能经历峰值功率输出的最大变化。
- 年龄增长似乎减弱脊髓损伤个体对有氧运动训练的心肺适能适应反应。
研究设计与样本
- 数据库检索MEDLINE、EMBASE、CENTRAL和Web of Science,自建库至2023年3月。
- 主要荟萃分析纳入随机对照试验(运动干预持续>2周相对于对照组)。
- 次要荟萃分析汇总纵向前后研究和随机对照试验中持续>2周的独立运动干预。
- 进一步分析包括队列、横断面和观察性研究设计。
- 共纳入120项研究:29项随机对照试验、67项前后研究、11项队列研究、7项横断面研究和6项观察性研究。
主要发现
- 主要荟萃分析显示,相对于对照组,运动使绝对峰值摄氧量改善0.16(0.07,0.25)L/min、相对峰值摄氧量改善2.9(1.8,3.9)mL/kg/min、峰值功率输出改善9(5,14)W(p < 0.001)。
- 次要汇总荟萃分析纳入96项研究(117项独立运动干预,包含1,331名脊髓损伤成人),显示运动干预后绝对峰值摄氧量增加0.22(0.17,0.26)L/min、相对峰值摄氧量增加2.8(2.2,3.3)mL/kg/min、峰值功率输出增加11(9,13)W(p < 0.001)。
- 相对峰值摄氧量基于运动方式(p = 0.002)和干预时长(p = 0.01)存在亚组差异,但绝对峰值摄氧量无差异。
- 峰值功率输出基于损伤后时间、神经损伤平面、运动方式和频率存在亚组差异(p ≤ 0.018)。
- 荟萃回归发现,参与者平均年龄较高的研究其绝对峰值摄氧量和相对峰值摄氧量的变化较小(p < 0.10)。
关键数值与推荐
- 心肺适能定义为峰值摄氧量或峰值功率输出。
- 主要荟萃分析纳入运动干预持续>2周的随机对照试验。
- 次要荟萃分析汇总持续>2周的独立运动干预。
- 偏倚/质量通过Cochrane风险偏倚2和NIH质量评估工具评估。
- 证据确定性使用GRADE方法评估。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 本综述可能受限于随机对照试验数量少,无法在该特定研究设计内进行亚组分析。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: A low level of cardiorespiratory fitness [CRF; defined as peak oxygen uptake ([Formula: see text]O2peak) or peak power output (PPO)] is a widely reported consequence of spinal cord injury (SCI) and a major risk factor associated with chronic disease. However, CRF can be modified by exercise. This systematic review with meta-analysis and meta-regression aimed to assess whether certain SCI characteristics and/or specific exercise considerations are moderators of changes in CRF. METHODS AND FINDINGS: Databases (MEDLINE, EMBASE, CENTRAL, and Web of Science) were searched from inception to March 2023. A primary meta-analysis was conducted including randomised controlled trials (RCTs; exercise interventions lasting >2 weeks relative to control groups). A secondary meta-analysis pooled independent exercise interventions >2 weeks from longitudinal pre-post and RCT studies to explore whether subgroup differences in injury characteristics and/or exercise intervention parameters explained CRF changes. Further analyses included cohort, cross-sectional, and observational study designs. Outcome measures of interest were absolute (A[Formula: see text]O2peak) or relative [Formula: see text]O2peak (R[Formula: see text]O2peak), and/or PPO. Bias/quality was assessed via The Cochrane Risk of Bias 2 and the National Institute of Health Quality Assessment Tools. Certainty of the evidence was assessed using the Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) approach. Random effects models were used in all meta-analyses and meta-regressions. Of 21,020 identified records, 120 studies comprising 29 RCTs, 67 pre-post studies, 11 cohort, 7 cross-sectional, and 6 observational studies were included. The primary meta-analysis revealed significant improvements in A[Formula: see text]O2peak [0.16 (0.07, 0.25) L/min], R[Formula: see text]O2peak [2.9 (1.8, 3.9) mL/kg/min], and PPO [9 (5, 14) W] with exercise, relative to controls (p < 0.001). Ninety-six studies (117 independent exercise interventions comprising 1,331 adults with SCI) were included in the secondary, pooled meta-analysis which demonstrated significant increases in A[Formula: see text]O2peak [0.22 (0.17, 0.26) L/min], R[Formula: see text]O2peak [2.8 (2.2, 3.3) mL/kg/min], and PPO [11 (9, 13) W] (p < 0.001) following exercise interventions. There were subgroup differences for R[Formula: see text]O2peak based on exercise modality (p = 0.002) and intervention length (p = 0.01), but there were no differences for A[Formula: see text]O2peak. There were subgroup differences (p ≤ 0.018) for PPO based on time since injury, neurological level of injury, exercise modality, and frequency. The meta-regression found that studies with a higher mean age of participants were associated with smaller changes in A[Formula: see text]O2peak and R[Formula: see text]O2peak (p < 0.10). GRADE indicated a moderate level of certainty in the estimated effect for R[Formula: see text]O2peak, but low levels for A[Formula: see text]O2peak and PPO. This review may be limited by the small number of RCTs, which prevented a subgroup analysis within this specific study design. CONCLUSIONS: Our primary meta-analysis confirms that performing exercise >2 weeks results in significant improvements to A[Formula: see text]O2peak, R[Formula: see text]O2peak, and PPO in individuals with SCI. The pooled meta-analysis subgroup comparisons identified that exercise interventions lasting up to 12 weeks yield the greatest change in R[Formula: see text]O2peak. Upper-body aerobic exercise and resistance training also appear the most effective at improving R[Formula: see text]O2peak and PPO. Furthermore, acutely injured, individuals with paraplegia, exercising for ≥3 sessions/week will likely experience the greatest change in PPO. Ageing seemingly diminishes the adaptive CRF responses to exercise training in individuals with SCI. REGISTRATION: PROSPERO: CRD42018104342.
引用
- Hodgkiss DD, Bhangu GS, Lunny C, et al. Exercise and aerobic capacity in individuals with spinal cord injury: A systematic review with meta-analysis and meta-regression. PLoS Med. 2023. PMID: 38011304. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1004082
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。