文献速递流行病学与生物统计医学教育与科研方法

自闭症早期儿童干预Meta分析(Project AIM):更新系统综述与二次分析

Autism intervention meta-analysis of early childhood studies (Project AIM): updated systematic review and secondary analysis.
PubMed 文献 · BMJ · 2023-11-14

该更新系统综述与Meta分析检索截至2021年11月的数据库,纳入252项研究、13304名8岁以下自闭症儿童,评估非药物干预对发育结局的效应。随机对照试验中,行为干预、发展干预、自然主义发展行为干预和技术干预在部分结局上显示显著汇总效应,但排除高风险偏倚研究后仅自然主义发展行为干预对自闭症诊断特征 measures 保持显著。不良事件监测不足,可能常见。

要点

  • 4年内证据量约翻倍,共252项研究、13304名8岁以下自闭症儿童。
  • 随机对照试验中自然主义发展行为干预对社交沟通(g=0.35)和诊断特征(g=0.38)有显著效应。
  • 排除高风险检测偏倚后仅自然主义发展行为干预对诊断特征保持显著(g=0.30)。

核心结论

  • 随机对照试验证据显示行为干预改善照顾者对挑战性行为的感知和儿童社交情绪功能,技术干预支持特定社交沟通和社交情绪技能的近端改善。
  • 发展干预改善与照顾者互动中的社交沟通,自然主义发展行为干预改善自闭症核心挑战尤其是社交沟通困难。
  • 由于监测和报告不足,这些干预的潜在获益无法与潜在不良效应进行权衡。

研究设计与样本

  • 更新系统综述与Meta分析(Project AIM),检索2021年11月(更新2017年11月检索),涵盖多个数据库和试验注册库。
  • 纳入任何对照分组研究,测试任何非药物干预对8岁以下自闭症儿童任何结局的效应。
  • 共纳入252项研究的289篇报告,代表13304名参与者和3291个结局的效应。
  • 采用Cochrane指南评估偏倚风险,使用稳健方差估计处理研究内和亚组内效应的相关性。

主要发现

  • 随机对照试验中,行为干预对社交情绪或挑战性行为结局的汇总效应Hedges' g=0.58(95%CI 0.11至1.06;P=0.02)。
  • 发展干预对社交沟通g=0.28(95%CI 0.12至0.44;P=0.003)。
  • 自然主义发展行为干预对适应行为g=0.23(95%CI 0.02至0.43;P=0.03)、语言g=0.16(95%CI 0.01至0.31;P=0.04)、游戏g=0.19(95%CI 0.02至0.36;P=0.03)、社交沟通g=0.35(95%CI 0.23至0.47;P<0.001)和自闭症诊断特征测量g=0.38(95%CI 0.17至0.59;P=0.002)。
  • 技术干预对社交沟通g=0.33(95%CI 0.02至0.64;P=0.04)和社交情绪或挑战性行为结局g=0.57(95%CI 0.04至1.09;P=0.04)。
  • 排除照顾者或教师报告结局后,仅发展干预对社交沟通g=0.31(95%CI 0.13至0.49;P=0.003)、自然主义发展行为干预对社交沟通g=0.36(95%CI 0.23至0.49;P<0.001)和诊断特征g=0.44(95%CI 0.20至0.68;P=0.002)显著。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 不良事件监测不足,可能常见。
  • 潜在获益无法与潜在不良效应进行权衡,因监测和报告不足。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: To summarize the breadth and quality of evidence supporting commonly recommended early childhood autism interventions and their estimated effects on developmental outcomes. DESIGN: Updated systematic review and meta-analysis (autism intervention meta-analysis; Project AIM). DATA SOURCES: A search was conducted in November 2021 (updating a search done in November 2017) of the following databases and registers: Academic Search Complete, CINAHL Plus with full text, Education Source, Educational Administration Abstracts, ERIC, Medline, ProQuest Dissertations and Theses, PsycINFO, Psychology and Behavioral Sciences Collection, and SocINDEX with full text, Trials, and ClinicalTrials.gov. ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA FOR SELECTING STUDIES: Any controlled group study testing the effects of any non-pharmacological intervention on any outcome in young autistic children younger than 8 years. REVIEW METHODS: Newly identified studies were integrated into the previous dataset and were coded for participant, intervention, and outcome characteristics. Interventions were categorized by type of approach (such as behavioral, developmental, naturalistic developmental behavioral intervention, and technology based), and outcomes were categorized by domain (such as social communication, adaptive behavior, play, and language). Risks of bias were evaluated following guidance from Cochrane. Effects were estimated for all intervention and outcome types with sufficient contributing data, stratified by risk of bias, using robust variance estimation to account for intercorrelation of effects within studies and subgroups. RESULTS: The search yielded 289 reports of 252 studies, representing 13 304 participants and effects for 3291 outcomes. When contributing effects were restricted to those from randomized controlled trials, significant summary effects were estimated for behavioral interventions on social emotional or challenging behavior outcomes (Hedges' g=0.58, 95% confidence interval 0.11 to 1.06; P=0.02), developmental interventions on social communication (0.28, 0.12 to 0.44; P=0.003); naturalistic developmental behavioral interventions on adaptive behavior (0.23, 0.02 to 0.43; P=0.03), language (0.16, 0.01 to 0.31; P=0.04), play (0.19, 0.02 to 0.36; P=0.03), social communication (0.35, 0.23 to 0.47; P<0.001), and measures of diagnostic characteristics of autism (0.38, 0.17 to 0.59; P=0.002); and technology based interventions on social communication (0.33, 0.02 to 0.64; P=0.04) and social emotional or challenging behavior outcomes (0.57, 0.04 to 1.09; P=0.04). When effects were further restricted to exclude caregiver or teacher report outcomes, significant effects were estimated only for developmental interventions on social communication (0.31, 0.13 to 0.49; P=0.003) and naturalistic developmental behavioral interventions on social communication (0.36, 0.23 to 0.49; P<0.001) and measures of diagnostic characteristics of autism (0.44, 0.20 to 0.68; P=0.002). When effects were then restricted to exclude those at high risk of detection bias, only one significant summary effect was estimated-naturalistic developmental behavioral interventions on measures of diagnostic characteristics of autism (0.30, 0.03 to 0.57; P=0.03). Adverse events were poorly monitored, but possibly common. CONCLUSION: The available evidence on interventions to support young autistic children has approximately doubled in four years. Some evidence from randomized controlled trials shows that behavioral interventions improve caregiver perception of challenging behavior and child social emotional functioning, and that technology based interventions support proximal improvements in specific social communication and social emotional skills. Evidence also shows that developmental interventions improve social communication in interactions with caregivers, and naturalistic developmental behavioral interventions improve core challenges associated with autism, particularly difficulties with social communication. However, potential benefits of these interventions cannot be weighed against the potential for adverse effects owing to inadequate monitoring and reporting.

来源:BMJ,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Sandbank M, Bottema-Beutel K, Crowley LaPoint S, et al. Autism intervention meta-analysis of early childhood studies (Project AIM): updated systematic review and secondary analysis. BMJ. 2023. PMID: 37963634. doi:10.1136/bmj-2023-076733

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。