在生存趋势存在时使用时间再校准改善竞争风险场景下风险预测模型的校准度
本文演示如何在竞争风险场景中对每个病因别(或亚分布)风险模型分别进行时间再校准,并使用SEER项目中1995—2004年诊断的结肠癌患者数据拟合两种死亡原因模型,在2005年诊断的新数据中评估校准度。10年校准图显示标准方法高估结肠癌死亡风险和总死亡风险,而时间再校准或时期分析可改善校准度。
要点
- 时间再校准先用全数据集估计预测因子效应,再用最近数据子集重新估计基线而约束预测因子效应不变。
- 在竞争风险场景中需对每个病因别或亚分布风险模型分别进行时间再校准。
- 标准方法高估结肠癌死亡风险和总死亡风险,时间再校准或时期分析可改善校准度。
核心结论
- 在生存趋势存在时,标准方法高估结肠癌死亡风险和总死亡风险,使用时间再校准或时期分析可改善校准度。
研究设计与样本
- 使用SEER项目中1995—2004年诊断的结肠癌患者数据拟合结肠癌死亡和其他原因死亡两个模型,并在2005年诊断的新数据中评估校准度。
- 时间再校准先用全数据集估计预测因子效应,再用最近数据子集重新估计基线而约束预测因子效应不变。
- 在竞争风险场景中需对每个病因别(或亚分布)风险模型分别进行时间再校准。
主要发现
- 10年校准图显示标准方法高估结肠癌死亡风险和总死亡风险。
- 使用时间再校准或时期分析后校准度得到改善。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出临床推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
We have previously proposed temporal recalibration to account for trends in survival over time to improve the calibration of predictions from prognostic models for new patients. This involves first estimating the predictor effects using data from all individuals (full dataset) and then re-estimating the baseline using a subset of the most recent data whilst constraining the predictor effects to remain the same. In this article, we demonstrate how temporal recalibration can be applied in competing risk settings by recalibrating each cause-specific (or subdistribution) hazard model separately. We illustrate this using an example of colon cancer survival with data from the Surveillance Epidemiology and End Results (SEER) program. Data from patients diagnosed in 1995-2004 were used to fit two models for deaths due to colon cancer and other causes respectively. We discuss considerations that need to be made in order to apply temporal recalibration such as the choice of data used in the recalibration step. We also demonstrate how to assess the calibration of these models in new data for patients diagnosed subsequently in 2005. Comparison was made to a standard analysis (when improvements over time are not taken into account) and a period analysis which is similar to temporal recalibration but differs in the data used to estimate the predictor effects. The 10-year calibration plots demonstrated that using the standard approach over-estimated the risk of death due to colon cancer and the total risk of death and that calibration was improved using temporal recalibration or period analysis.
引用
- Booth S, Mozumder SI, Archer L, et al. Using temporal recalibration to improve the calibration of risk prediction models in competing risk settings when there are trends in survival over time. Stat Med. 2023. PMID: 37705296. doi:10.1002/sim.9898
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。