评估网络Meta分析中环路不一致性的新方法
针对网络Meta分析中直接与间接证据需满足一致性假设的问题,提出新的局部与全局不一致性检验方法,将不一致性定位于治疗环路而非节点或治疗比较,构建含单一环路不一致参数的模型,并扩展为每个独立环路一个自由度的全局检验,在三个示例网络中演示了应用。
要点
- 新局部检验将不一致性定位于治疗环路,模型基于节点拆分与边拆分思想。
- 全局模型每个独立环路一个自由度,自由度少于设计-治疗交互法,可能提高检验效能。
- 所提模型对治疗对称处理且不依赖于参照治疗的选择,结果受模型参数化影响较小。
核心结论
- 提出的局部与全局检验能将不一致性定位于环路而非节点或治疗比较,且对参照治疗选择不变,全局模型自由度少于现有设计-治疗交互方法并可能提高检验效能。
研究设计与样本
- 方法学论文,提出新的局部与全局不一致性检验并应用于三个规模和复杂度不同的网络Meta分析示例。
主要发现
- 局部检验基于含单一环路不一致参数的模型,该模型建立在节点拆分与边拆分思想之上。
- 全局检验将模型扩展至多个独立环路,每个独立环路一个自由度,并开发了识别网络Meta分析中独立环路的新算法。
- 全局模型对独立环路的选择不变,且在三个示例网络中进行了局部与全局不一致性检验。
关键数值与推荐
- 全局模型每个独立环路使用一个自由度,少于现有设计-治疗交互方法。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
In network meta-analysis, studies evaluating multiple treatment comparisons are modeled simultaneously, and estimation is informed by a combination of direct and indirect evidence. Network meta-analysis relies on an assumption of consistency, meaning that direct and indirect evidence should agree for each treatment comparison. Here we propose new local and global tests for inconsistency and demonstrate their application to three example networks. Because inconsistency is a property of a loop of treatments in the network meta-analysis, we locate the local test in a loop. We define a model with one inconsistency parameter that can be interpreted as loop inconsistency. The model builds on the existing ideas of node-splitting and side-splitting in network meta-analysis. To provide a global test for inconsistency, we extend the model across multiple independent loops with one degree of freedom per loop. We develop a new algorithm for identifying independent loops within a network meta-analysis. Our proposed models handle treatments symmetrically, locate inconsistency in loops rather than in nodes or treatment comparisons, and are invariant to choice of reference treatment, making the results less dependent on model parameterization. For testing global inconsistency in network meta-analysis, our global model uses fewer degrees of freedom than the existing design-by-treatment interaction approach and has the potential to increase power. To illustrate our methods, we fit the models to three network meta-analyses varying in size and complexity. Local and global tests for inconsistency are performed and we demonstrate that the global model is invariant to choice of independent loops.
引用
- Turner RM, Band T, Morris TP, et al. A new approach to evaluating loop inconsistency in network meta-analysis. Stat Med. 2023. PMID: 37767752. doi:10.1002/sim.9872
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。