通过随机搜索变量选择识别网络荟萃分析中的不一致性
网络荟萃分析(NMA)结果的可靠性依赖于传递性假设的合理性,该假设通过一致性假设在统计上体现。作者提出随机搜索不一致因子选择(SSIFS)方法,将每个不一致因子描述为候选协变量,应用随机搜索变量选择技术判断不一致因子是否应纳入模型,从而在局部和全局评估一致性假设。该方法基于201篇已发表NMA的历史数据构建信息先验,并在两篇已发表的NMA中评估性能,已开发为R包ssifs发布于CRAN。
要点
- SSIFS方法通过随机搜索变量选择判断不一致因子是否应纳入NMA模型。
- 各不一致因子的后验纳入概率量化特定比较不一致的可能性。
- 使用后验模型优势比或中位概率模型决定不一致因子的重要性。
核心结论
- 提出的SSIFS方法可局部和全局评估NMA的一致性假设,通过随机搜索变量选择决定不一致因子是否纳入模型。
研究设计与样本
- 方法学研究:提出随机搜索不一致因子选择(SSIFS)方法,基于201篇已发表网络荟萃分析的历史数据构建信息先验,并在两篇已发表的网络荟萃分析中评估性能。
主要发现
- 每个不一致因子的后验纳入概率量化特定比较不一致的可能性。
- 使用后验模型优势比或中位概率模型决定不一致因子的重要性。
- 直接与间接证据之间的差异可纳入不一致性检测过程。
- 方法在两篇已发表的网络荟萃分析中进行了性能评估。
关键数值与推荐
- 信息先验基于201篇已发表网络荟萃分析的历史数据构建。
- 使用后验模型优势比或中位概率模型决定不一致因子的重要性。
临床怎么用
- 所提方法已公开提供为R包ssifs,发布于CRAN,由作者开发维护。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
The reliability of the results of network meta-analysis (NMA) lies in the plausibility of the key assumption of transitivity. This assumption implies that the effect modifiers' distribution is similar across treatment comparisons. Transitivity is statistically manifested through the consistency assumption which suggests that direct and indirect evidence are in agreement. Several methods have been suggested to evaluate consistency. A popular approach suggests adding inconsistency factors to the NMA model. We follow a different direction by describing each inconsistency factor with a candidate covariate whose choice relies on variable selection techniques. Our proposed method, stochastic search inconsistency factor selection (SSIFS), evaluates the consistency assumption both locally and globally, by applying the stochastic search variable selection method to determine whether the inconsistency factors should be included in the model. The posterior inclusion probability of each inconsistency factor quantifies how likely is a specific comparison to be inconsistent. We use posterior model odds or the median probability model to decide on the importance of inconsistency factors. Differences between direct and indirect evidence can be incorporated into the inconsistency detection process. A key point of our proposed approach is the construction of a reasonable "informative" prior concerning network consistency. The prior is based on the elicitation of information derived historical data from 201 published network meta-analyses. The performance of our proposed method is evaluated in two published network meta-analyses. The proposed methodology is publicly available in an R package called ssifs, published on CRAN and developed and maintained by the authors of this work.
引用
- Seitidis G, Nikolakopoulos S, Ntzoufras I, et al. Inconsistency identification in network meta-analysis via stochastic search variable selection. Stat Med. 2023. PMID: 37652462. doi:10.1002/sim.9891
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。