采用单样本Mantel-Haenszel方法对篮式试验进行频率学分析
针对篮式试验,现有贝叶斯方法建模复杂且可能无法控制I类错误,本文提出基于单样本Mantel-Haenszel过程的纯频率学方法,在共同治疗效应假设下借用信息。证明了治疗效应的Mantel-Haenszel估计量在大分层与稀疏数据两种极限模型下一致(双重一致),并提出双重一致方差估计量。估计量在共同效应假设违背时仍可解释,可用于确证性篮式试验设计,并提出信息准则方法识别有效篮子亚类。
要点
- 提出纯频率学单样本Mantel-Haenszel方法用于篮式试验,避免贝叶斯建模复杂性。
- 治疗效应估计量在大分层和稀疏数据极限模型下双重一致,并给出双重一致方差估计量。
- 估计量在共同治疗效应假设不成立时仍可解释,并提出信息准则识别有效篮子亚类。
核心结论
- 所提出的Mantel-Haenszel治疗效应估计量在两种极限模型下一致(双重一致),且即使共同治疗效应假设被违背仍可解释,从而可按确证性方式设计篮式试验。
研究设计与样本
- 基于单样本Mantel-Haenszel过程的纯频率学方法,在共同治疗效应假设下跨篮子借用信息,并推导双重一致方差估计量及识别有效篮子亚类的信息准则方法。
主要发现
- 治疗效应的Mantel-Haenszel估计量在大分层和稀疏数据两种极限模型下一致(双重一致),并提出了双重一致方差估计量。
- 所提出的估计量在共同治疗效应假设被违背时仍可解释。
- 提出信息准则方法用于识别有效的篮子亚类。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为所提频率学方法可用于以确证性方式设计篮式试验,并可用信息准则识别有效篮子亚类。
局限性
- 原文指出贝叶斯方法需要复杂建模且可能无法将I类错误概率控制在名义水平,但未报告所提方法自身的局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Recent substantial advances of molecular targeted oncology drug development is requiring new paradigms for early-phase clinical trial methodologies to enable us to evaluate efficacy of several subtypes simultaneously and efficiently. The concept of the basket trial is getting of much attention to realize this requirement borrowing information across subtypes, which are called baskets. Bayesian approach is a natural approach to this end and indeed the majority of the existing proposals relies on it. On the other hand, it required complicated modeling and may not necessarily control the type 1 error probabilities at the nominal level. In this article, we develop a purely frequentist approach for basket trials based on one-sample Mantel-Haenszel procedure relying on a very simple idea for borrowing information under the common treatment effect assumption over baskets. We show that the proposed Mantel-Haenszel estimator for the treatment effect is consistent under two limiting models of the large strata and sparse data limiting models (dually consistent) and propose dually consistent variance estimators. The proposed estimators are interpretable even if the common treatment effect assumptions are violated. Then, we can design basket trials in a confirmatory matter. We also propose an information criterion approach to identify effective subclasses of baskets.
引用
- Hattori S, Morita S. Frequentist analysis of basket trials with one-sample Mantel-Haenszel procedures. Stat Med. 2023. PMID: 37670577. doi:10.1002/sim.9890
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。