多重插补后个体化治疗规则的估计与评价
针对缺失数据下最优个体化治疗规则(ITR)的估计与评价方法缺乏指导的问题,以STEP UP试验为动机,描述了两种基于多重插补的框架,并用模拟数据评估其性能。一种框架将数据分为独立训练集与测试集分别用于估计和评价,另一种用全数据估计并构建m-out-of-n bootstrap置信区间评价性能,最后对STEP UP数据做示例分析并讨论插补次数等实际考量。
要点
- 多重插补在个性化医学中应用普遍但关注较少,本文填补缺失数据下ITR估计与评价的空白。
- 提出两种框架:训练/测试集拆分框架与全数据估计加m-out-of-n bootstrap置信区间框架。
- 以STEP UP试验数据示例分析,关注插补次数选择等实际考量。
核心结论
- 描述了两种多重插补后估计与评价最优个体化治疗规则的框架,并用模拟数据评估其性能。
研究设计与样本
- 方法学研究,以STEP UP试验为动机,使用模拟数据评估两种框架性能,并对STEP UP数据做示例分析。
主要发现
- 一种框架将数据拆分为独立训练集与测试集,分别用于估计和评价最优个体化治疗规则。
- 另一种框架用全数据估计最优个体化治疗规则,并构建m-out-of-n bootstrap置信区间评价其性能。
- STEP UP试验中参与者被随机分配到对照组或三种旨在增加身体活动的干预之一,并佩戴可穿戴设备记录每日步数。
- 许多参与者在研究期间至少缺失一个每日步数计数。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
An individualized treatment rule (ITR) is a function that inputs patient-level information and outputs a recommended treatment. An important focus of precision medicine is to develop optimal ITRs that maximize a population-level distributional summary. However, guidance for estimating and evaluating optimal ITRs in the presence of missing data is limited. Our work is motivated by the Social Incentives to Encourage Physical Activity and Understand Predictors (STEP UP) study. Participants were randomized to a control or one of three interventions designed to increase physical activity and were given wearable devices to record daily steps as a measure of physical activity. Many participants were missing at least one daily step count during the study period. In the primary analysis of the STEP UP trial, multiple imputation (MI) was used to address missingness in daily step counts. Despite ubiquitous use of MI in practice, it has been given relatively little attention in the context of personalized medicine. We fill this gap by describing two frameworks for estimation and evaluation of an optimal ITR following MI and assessing their performance using simulated data. One framework relies on splitting the data into independent training and testing sets for estimation and evaluation, respectively. The other framework estimates an optimal ITR using the full data and constructs an m $$ m $$ -out-of- n $$ n $$ bootstrap confidence interval to evaluate its performance. Finally, we provide an illustrative analysis to estimate and evaluate an optimal ITR from the STEP UP data with a focus on practical considerations such as choosing the number of imputations.
引用
- Shen J, Hubbard RA, Linn KA, et al. Estimation and evaluation of individualized treatment rules following multiple imputation. Stat Med. 2023. PMID: 37496450. doi:10.1002/sim.9857
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。