临床研究护士对试验失败、招募与保留的预测:呼吁将其早期纳入试验设计
研究随机选取2014至2018年ClinicalTrials.gov上18项终止、撤回或完成的试验方案,由5名临床研究护士(CRN)盲法判断试验状态、招募达标、按时招募与参与者保留情况。CRN预测招募成功/失败的准确率为74%(95%CI 54-87%),识别达标中心的敏感度为100%,识别未达标中心的特异度为63%(95%CI 36-84%)。作者认为CRN是试验团队的重要成员,并结合ESP研究主张在试验设计阶段扩大团队并早期纳入广泛技能。
要点
- CRN对招募成功/失败的预测准确率为74%(95%CI 54-87%)。
- CRN识别招募达标中心的敏感度为100%,识别未达标中心的特异度为63%(95%CI 36-84%)。
- CRN对试验状态、按时招募和参与者保留的预测准确率分别为48%、70%和52%。
核心结论
- CRN能很好地判断试验招募和中心绩效问题,是临床试验团队的重要部分。
- 结合ESP研究,作者为在试验设计阶段扩大团队、早期纳入广泛技能提出了有力依据。
- 早期纳入广泛技能可能有助于抵消招募、保留和试验失败的问题。
研究设计与样本
- 从ClinicalTrials.gov随机选取2014至2018年(含端点)的18项试验方案,状态为终止、撤回或完成。
- 5名CRN通过12项问卷对试验状态、招募是否达标、是否按时招募、是否保留参与者及CRN是否可能参与设计进行判断并给出理由。
- CRN对研究结局盲法,未接受方案阅读培训,禁止或放弃使用互联网完成任务。
主要发现
- 5名CRN完成了23份问卷,涉及23项试验方案(18项不同试验)。
- CRN正确预测试验状态的准确率为48%(95%CI 29-67%,11/23)。
- CRN预测招募成功/失败的准确率为74%(95%CI 54-87%,17/23)。
- CRN预测按时招募的准确率为70%(95%CI 49-84%,16/23)。
- CRN预测参与者保留的准确率为52%(95%CI 33-71%,12/23)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为CRN是临床试验团队的重要部分,能很好地判断试验招募和中心绩效问题。
- 作者结合ESP研究主张在试验设计阶段扩大团队并早期纳入广泛技能,以潜在抵消招募、保留和试验失败的问题。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Clinical research nurses are a key part of the clinical trial team but typically get involved later in the trial, usually during recruitment. The purpose of our study was to establish if CRNs who read the trial protocol can predict the performance of the trial. METHODS: We randomly selected 18 trial protocols with three statuses, terminated, withdrawn, and completed, from ClinicalTrials.gov, between 2014 and 2018 inclusive. We gave the protocols to five CRNs, asked them to make a judgement and provide a reason for that judgement (via a 12-item questionnaire) on the status of the trial (terminated, withdrawn or completed), if the trial met its recruitment target, if it recruited on time, and if it retained its participants. We also asked if it was likely a CRN was involved in the design of the trial. The CRNs were blinded to the study outcomes, did not receive any training on how to read a protocol and were prohibited from using/abstained from using the internet while completing the task. RESULTS: Twenty-three questionnaires on 23 trial protocols (18 different trials) were completed by 5 CRNs. The CRNs correctly predicted the trial status 48%, 95% CI: 29-67% (11/23) of the time; successful/unsuccessful recruitment 74%, 95% CI: 54-87% (17/23) of the time; on-time recruitment 70%, 95% CI: 49-84% (16/23) of the time; and participant retention 52%, 95% CI: 33-71% (12/23). CRNs identified 100% (sensitivity) of sites that hit their target and 63%, 95% CI: 36-84% (specificity) of sites that missed their target. CONCLUSIONS: CRNs are very good judges of trial recruitment and site performance issues and are a vital part of the clinical trial team. Taken with the ESP (Estimating Site Performance) study, we have made a strong case for broadening the trial team at the trial design stage. Early engagement of a broad skillset can potentially offset problems of recruitment, retention and trial failure.
引用
- Shiely F, Murphy D, Millar SR, et al. Clinical research nurse predictions of trial failure, recruitment and retention: a case for their early inclusion in trial design. Trials. 2023. PMID: 37464255. doi:10.1186/s13063-023-07504-9
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。