文献速递医学教育与科研方法

实用性试验随机化中的临床推理:一项质性访谈研究

Clinical reasoning in pragmatic trial randomization: a qualitative interview study.
PubMed 文献 · Trials · 2023-06-27

该质性研究访谈了参与REGAIN试验的29名麻醉科医生,探讨其在实用性试验中决定是否将合格患者随机化的推理过程。医生以预防围术期和术中并发症为主要临床职能,使用原型推理或概率推理判断禁忌症患者是否应随机化,并因受托责任而毫不迟疑地表达个人倾向。医生支持临床研究,但参与主要受生产压力和工作流程中断阻碍。

要点

  • 麻醉科医生视预防围术期和术中并发症为主要临床职能。
  • 对禁忌症患者是否随机化,采用原型推理或概率推理。
  • 医生因受托责任不迟疑表达个人倾向,即使复杂化招募。

核心结论

  • 评估临床医生关于试验随机化决策的常用方法基于对临床推理的可疑假设。
  • 密切检查常规临床实践并关注本文揭示的临床推理特征,有助于评估、预测和回应特定试验中的入组决定。

研究设计与样本

  • 质性访谈研究,访谈29名参与REGAIN试验的麻醉科医生。
  • REGAIN为多中心实用性随机试验,比较髋部骨折的脊椎麻醉与全身麻醉。
  • 访谈包括图表刺激部分和半结构化部分,采用建构主义扎根理论方法分析。

主要发现

  • 麻醉科医生感知主要临床职能为预防围术期和术中并发症。
  • 部分情况下使用原型推理判断禁忌症患者是否应随机化,另一些情况使用概率推理,涉及不同类型的不确定性。
  • 接受患者随机化时,麻醉科医生对麻醉选择表示自信。
  • 麻醉科医生视自身对患者有受托责任,不迟疑沟通个人倾向,即使复杂化试验招募。
  • 麻醉科医生强烈支持临床研究,参与主要受生产压力和工作流程中断阻碍。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Pragmatic trials, because they study widely used treatments in settings of routine practice, require intensive participation from clinicians who determine whether patients can be enrolled. Clinicians are often conflicted between their therapeutic obligation to patients and their willingness to enroll them in trials in which treatments are randomly determined and thus potentially suboptimal. Refusal to enroll eligible patients can hinder trial completion and damage generalizability. In order to help evaluate and mitigate clinician refusal, this qualitative study examined how clinicians reason about whether to randomize eligible patients. METHODS: We performed interviews with 29 anesthesiologists who participated in REGAIN, a multicenter pragmatic randomized trial comparing spinal and general anesthesia in hip fracture. Interviews included a chart-stimulated section in which physicians described their reasoning pertaining to specific eligible patients as well as a general semi-structured section about their views on clinical research. Guided by a constructivist grounded theory approach, we analyzed data via coding, synthesized thematic patterns using focused coding, and developed an explanation using abduction. RESULTS: Anesthesiologists perceived their main clinical function as preventing peri- and intraoperative complications. In some cases, they used prototype-based reasoning to determine whether patients with contraindications should be randomized; in others, they used probabilistic reasoning. These modes of reasoning involved different types of uncertainty. In contrast, anesthesiologists expressed confidence about anesthetic options when they accepted patients for randomization. Anesthesiologists saw themselves as having a fiduciary responsibility to patients and thus did not hesitate to communicate their inclinations, even when this complicated trial recruitment. Nevertheless, they voiced strong support for clinical research, stating that their involvement was mainly hindered by production pressure and workflow disruptions. CONCLUSIONS: Our findings suggest that prominent ways of assessing clinician decisions about trial randomization are based on questionable assumptions about clinical reasoning. Close examination of routine clinical practice, attuned to the features of clinical reasoning we reveal here, will help both in evaluating clinicians' enrollment determinations in specific trials and in anticipating and responding to them. TRIAL REGISTRATION: Regional Versus General Anesthesia for Promoting Independence After Hip Fracture (REGAIN). CLINICALTRIALS: gov NCT02507505. Prospectively registered on July 24, 2015.

来源:Trials,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Clapp JT, Dinh C, Hsu M, et al. Clinical reasoning in pragmatic trial randomization: a qualitative interview study. Trials. 2023. PMID: 37365614. doi:10.1186/s13063-023-07445-3

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。