贝叶斯自适应决策理论方法可减少多臂运动肿瘤试验的样本量
该研究将PACES三臂运动肿瘤试验的230例化疗乳腺癌患者数据重新分析为采用贝叶斯决策理论与频率学组序贯方法的自适应试验,每36例进行中期分析。贝叶斯自适应设计在「选择优胜者」设置下72例即识别出OnTrack最有效,频率学设置下180例即停止,OnTrack治疗修改比例显著低于UC。
要点
- 贝叶斯自适应决策理论设计在「选择优胜者」设置下仅72例即识别OnTrack为最有效干预。
- 频率学组序贯设置下试验在180例时停止,OnTrack治疗修改比例显著低于UC。
- UC与OncoMove组治疗修改发生率为34%,OnTrack组为12%(P=0.002)。
核心结论
- 贝叶斯自适应决策理论方法大幅减少了该三臂运动试验所需的样本量,尤其在「选择优胜者」设置下。
研究设计与样本
- 将PACES试验中230例接受化疗的乳腺癌患者随机分配至监督下抗阻与有氧运动(OnTrack)、居家体力活动(OncoMove)或常规照护(UC)的数据重新分析为自适应试验。
- 采用贝叶斯决策理论与频率学组序贯方法,每36例患者进行中期分析,终点为化疗治疗修改(任何vs无)。
- 贝叶斯分析在不同继续阈值和设置下进行,包括有无臂剔除,以及「选择优胜者」和「选择所有优于对照的治疗」两种设置。
主要发现
- UC和OncoMove组治疗修改发生率为34%,OnTrack组为12%(P=0.002)。
- 贝叶斯自适应决策理论设计中,OnTrack在「选择优胜者」设置下72例后被识别为最有效,在「选择所有优于对照的治疗」设置下72-180例后被识别。
- 频率学设置下试验将在180例后停止,OnTrack治疗修改比例显著低于UC。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Adaptive designs may reduce trial sample sizes and costs. This study illustrates a Bayesian-adaptive decision-theoretic design applied to a multiarm exercise oncology trial. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: In the Physical exercise during Adjuvant Chemotherapy Effectiveness Study (PACES) trial, 230 breast cancer patients receiving chemotherapy were randomized to supervised resistance and aerobic exercise (OnTrack), home-based physical activity (OncoMove) or usual care (UC). Data were reanalyzed as an adaptive trial using both Bayesian decision-theoretic and a frequentist group-sequential approach incorporating interim analyses after every 36 patients. Endpoint was chemotherapy treatment modifications (any vs. none). Bayesian analyses were performed for different continuation thresholds and settings with and without arm dropping and both in a 'pick-the-winner' and a 'pick-all-treatments-superior-to-control' setting. RESULTS: Treatment modifications occurred in 34% of patients in UC and OncoMove vs. 12% in OnTrack (P = 0.002). Using a Bayesian-adaptive decision-theoretic design, OnTrack was identified as most effective after 72 patients in the 'pick-the-winner' setting and after 72-180 patients in the 'pick-all-treatments-superior-to-control' setting. In a frequentist setting, the trial would have been stopped after 180 patients, and the proportion of patients with treatment modifications was significantly lower for OnTrack than UC. CONCLUSION: A Bayesian-adaptive decision-theoretic approach substantially reduced the sample size required for this three-arm exercise trial, especially in the 'pick-the-winner' setting.
引用
- Buffart LM, Bassi A, Stuiver MM, et al. A Bayesian-adaptive decision-theoretic approach can reduce the sample sizes for multiarm exercise oncology trials. J Clin Epidemiol. 2023. PMID: 37245703. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2023.05.019
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。