在七个中低收入国家的外科整群随机试验中减少和监测组间偏倚与失衡的策略:来自ChEETAh试验的证据
ChEETAh是一项以医院为整群单位的国际整群随机对照试验,评估腹部伤口缝合前更换无菌手套和器械能否降低术后30天手术部位感染。该文报告了8项预先设定的减少和监测偏倚的策略,纳入70个整群共10686例患者,分析了各策略的执行情况与组间关键特征。
要点
- 符合条件的患者总体纳入率为98.1%(10686/10894)。
- 监测显示干预组恶性肿瘤、中线切口和择期手术比例均高于对照组。
核心结论
- 外科整群随机对照试验存在多种潜在偏倚来源,包括暴露单位不同以及需要在复杂环境中连续纳入所有符合条件的患者;本文报告了一套监测并减少组间偏倚与失衡风险的系统,为未来医院内整群随机对照试验提供了重要经验。
研究设计与样本
- ChEETAh是一项以医院为整群单位的国际整群随机对照试验,评估腹部伤口缝合前更换无菌手套和器械能否降低术后30天手术部位感染。
- 计划从七个中低收入国家的64家医院连续招募12800例患者。
- 本文分析纳入70个整群共10686例患者。
主要发现
- 7个国家中有6个纳入至少4家医院。
- 87.1%(61/70)的医院维持了计划手术室,干预组为82%(27/33),对照组为92%(34/37)。
- 最小化随机化使两组关键因素保持平衡。
- 所有医院均完成随机化后培训,所有站点均开展热身周并利用反馈优化流程。
- 标签和试验登记册得以维持,符合条件的患者总体纳入率为98.1%(10686/10894)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Cluster randomised controlled trials (cRCT) present challenges regarding risks of bias and chance imbalances by arm. This paper reports strategies to minimise and monitor biases and imbalances in the ChEETAh cRCT. METHODS: ChEETAh was an international cRCT (hospitals as clusters) evaluating whether changing sterile gloves and instruments prior to abdominal wound closure reduces surgical site infection at 30 days postoperative. ChEETAh planned to recruit 12,800 consecutive patients from 64 hospitals in seven low-middle income countries. Eight strategies to minimise and monitor bias were pre-specified: (1) minimum of 4 hospitals per country; (2) pre-randomisation identification of units of exposure (operating theatres, lists, teams or sessions) within clusters; (3) minimisation of randomisation by country and hospital type; (4) site training delivered after randomisation; (5) dedicated 'warm-up week' to train teams; (6) trial specific sticker and patient register to monitor consecutive patient identification; (7) monitoring characteristics of patients and units of exposure; and (8) low-burden outcome-assessment. RESULTS: This analysis includes 10,686 patients from 70 clusters. The results aligned to the eight strategies were (1) 6 out of 7 countries included ≥ 4 hospitals; (2) 87.1% (61/70) of hospitals maintained their planned operating theatres (82% [27/33] and 92% [34/37] in the intervention and control arms); (3) minimisation maintained balance of key factors in both arms; (4) post-randomisation training was conducted for all hospitals; (5) the 'warm-up week' was conducted at all sites, and feedback used to refine processes; (6) the sticker and trial register were maintained, with an overall inclusion of 98.1% (10,686/10,894) of eligible patients; (7) monitoring allowed swift identification of problems in patient inclusion and key patient characteristics were reported: malignancy (20.3% intervention vs 12.6% control), midline incisions (68.4% vs 58.9%) and elective surgery (52.4% vs 42.6%); and (8) 0.4% (41/9187) of patients refused consent for outcome assessment. CONCLUSION: cRCTs in surgery have several potential sources of bias that include varying units of exposure and the need for consecutive inclusion of all eligible patients across complex settings. We report a system that monitored and minimised the risks of bias and imbalances by arm, with important lessons for future cRCTs within hospitals.
引用
- Strategies to minimise and monitor biases and imbalances by arm in surgical cluster randomised trials: evidence from ChEETAh, a trial in seven low- and middle-income countries. Trials. 2023. PMID: 37020311. doi:10.1186/s13063-022-06852-2
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。