改善家庭饮用水、环境卫生和个人卫生(WASH)干预对儿童死亡率的影响:系统综述与Meta分析
该研究系统检索11个学术数据库及试验注册库等,纳入24项随机和11项非随机WASH干预研究,涉及2600例死亡。Meta分析显示WASH干预与儿童全因死亡率降低17%相关(OR=0.83,95%CI=0.74,0.92),与腹泻死亡率降低45%相关(OR=0.55,95%CI=0.35,0.84)。约半数研究在归因儿童死亡率方面为中度偏倚风险,无低偏倚风险研究。
要点
- WASH干预与儿童全因死亡率降低17%相关(OR=0.83,95%CI=0.74,0.92)。
- WASH干预与腹泻死亡率降低45%相关(OR=0.55,95%CI=0.35,0.84)。
- 约半数纳入研究为中度偏倚风险,无低偏倚风险研究。
核心结论
- WASH干预与儿童全因死亡率和腹泻死亡率显著降低相关,结果与传染病传播理论一致。
- 证据合成可提供超越试验原始数据的新发现,为政策提供关键见解。
- 透明报告使研究合成能够回答单个干预研究无法可靠设计的死亡率问题。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与Meta分析,使用已发表方案,系统检索11个学术数据库和试验注册库及组织仓库。
- 纳入在中低收入国家地方病条件下实施的WASH干预研究,报告截至2020年3月的发现。
- 纳入24项随机研究和11项非随机研究,涉及2600例死亡,分析纳入48个WASH治疗组。
- 由两名作者独立收集数据,使用Meta分析提高统计效能。
主要发现
- WASH干预与儿童全因死亡率降低17%相关(OR=0.83,95%CI=0.74,0.92;38项干预)。
- WASH干预与腹泻死亡率降低45%相关(OR=0.55,95%CI=0.35,0.84;10项干预)。
- 按WASH技术分析,向家庭提供改善水量的干预与全因死亡率降低最一致相关。
- 社区-wide环境卫生与腹泻死亡率降低最一致相关。
- 约半数纳入研究在归因儿童死亡率方面为中度偏倚风险,无低偏倚风险研究。
局限性
- 约半数纳入研究在归因儿童死亡率方面为中度偏倚风险,无低偏倚风险研究。
- 该综述应更新以纳入更多已发表和未发表的参与者流程数据。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: In low- and middle-income countries (L&MICs), the biggest contributing factors to the global burden of disease in childhood are deaths due to respiratory illness and diarrhoea, both of which are closely related to use of water, sanitation, and hygiene (WASH) services by households. However, current estimates of the health impacts of WASH interventions use self-reported morbidity, which may fail to capture longer-term or more severe impacts. Reported mortality is thought to be less prone to bias than other reported measures. This study aimed to answer the question: What are the impacts of WASH interventions on reported childhood mortality in L&MICs? METHODS AND FINDINGS: We conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis, using a published protocol. Systematic searches of 11 academic databases and trial registries, plus organisational repositories, were undertaken to locate studies of WASH interventions, which were published in peer review journals or other sources (e.g., organisational reports and working papers). Intervention studies of WASH improvements implemented under endemic disease circumstances in L&MICs were eligible, which reported findings at any time until March 2020. We used the participant flow data supplied in response to journal editors' calls for greater transparency. Data were collected by two authors working independently. We included evidence from 24 randomized and 11 nonrandomized studies of WASH interventions from all global regions, incorporating 2,600 deaths. Effects of 48 WASH treatment arms were included in analysis. We critically appraised and synthesised evidence using meta-analysis to improve statistical power. We found WASH interventions are associated with a significant reduction of 17% in the odds of all-cause mortality in childhood (OR = 0.83, 95% CI = 0.74, 0.92, evidence from 38 interventions), and a significant reduction in diarrhoea mortality of 45% (OR = 0.55, 95% CI = 0.35, 0.84; 10 interventions). Further analysis by WASH technology indicated interventions providing improved water in quantity to households were most consistently associated with reductions in all-cause mortality. Community-wide sanitation was most consistently associated with reductions in diarrhoea mortality. Around one-half of the included studies were assessed as being at "moderate risk of bias" in attributing mortality in childhood to the WASH intervention, and no studies were found to be at "low risk of bias." The review should be updated to incorporate additional published and unpublished participant flow data. CONCLUSIONS: The findings are congruent with theories of infectious disease transmission. Washing with water presents a barrier to respiratory illness and diarrhoea, which are the two biggest contributors to all-cause mortality in childhood in L&MICs. Community-wide sanitation halts the spread of diarrhoea. We observed that evidence synthesis can provide new findings, going beyond the underlying data from trials to generate crucial insights for policy. Transparent reporting in trials creates opportunities for research synthesis to answer questions about mortality, which individual studies of interventions cannot be reliably designed to address.
引用
- Sharma Waddington H, Masset E, Bick S, et al. Impact on childhood mortality of interventions to improve drinking water, sanitation, and hygiene (WASH) to households: Systematic review and meta-analysis. PLoS Med. 2023. PMID: 37079510. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1004215
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。