手术治疗与非手术治疗坐骨神经痛:随机对照试验的系统综述与Meta分析
该系统综述与Meta分析纳入24项随机对照试验,比较椎间盘切除术与非手术治疗或硬膜外类固醇注射对坐骨神经痛的疗效与安全性。极低至低确定性证据表明,椎间盘切除术在短期至中期减轻腿痛方面优于非手术治疗,但获益随时间下降;任何不良事件风险两组相似(RR 1.34,95%CI 0.91-1.98)。
要点
- 椎间盘切除术对比非手术治疗,即刻至短期腿痛改善为中至小效应,长期效应可忽略。
- 椎间盘切除术与硬膜外类固醇注射对腿痛效果相似,短期残疾改善为中效应。
- 任何不良事件风险在椎间盘切除术与非手术治疗间相似(RR 1.34,95%CI 0.91-1.98)。
核心结论
- 极低至低确定性证据提示,对于有手术指征的坐骨神经痛患者,椎间盘切除术在减轻腿痛和残疾方面优于非手术治疗或硬膜外类固醇注射,但获益随时间下降。
- 对于认为椎间盘切除术提供的快速缓解超过手术相关风险与费用的坐骨神经痛患者,椎间盘切除术可能是一个选择。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与Meta分析,检索Medline、Embase、CINAHL、Cochrane CENTRAL、ClinicalTrials.gov及WHO ICTRP自建库至2022年6月。
- 纳入比较任何手术治疗与非手术治疗、硬膜外类固醇注射或安慰剂/假手术的随机对照试验,对象为因腰椎间盘突出(影像学诊断)导致的任何病程坐骨神经痛患者。
- 共纳入24项试验,其中一半探讨椎间盘切除术对比非手术治疗或硬膜外类固醇注射(1711名受试者)。
- 主要结局为腿痛和残疾,采用随机效应模型合并数据,偏倚风险用Cochrane工具评估,证据确定性用GRADE框架评估。
- 随访时间分为即刻(≤6周)、短期(>6周且≤3个月)、中期(>3个月且<12个月)和长期(12个月)。
主要发现
- 椎间盘切除术对比非手术治疗,腿痛效应量在即刻期为中等(平均差-12.1,95%CI -23.6至-0.5),短期为中等(-11.7,95%CI -18.6至-4.7),中期为小(-6.5,95%CI -11.0至-2.1),长期可忽略(-2.3,95%CI -4.5至-0.2)。
- 椎间盘切除术对比非手术治疗,残疾方面发现小、可忽略或无效应。
- 椎间盘切除术对比硬膜外类固醇注射,腿痛效果相似;残疾在短期为中等效应,但中期和长期无效应。
- 椎间盘切除术与非手术治疗之间任何不良事件风险相似(风险比1.34,95%CI 0.91至1.98)。
关键数值与推荐
- 椎间盘切除术对比非手术治疗腿痛平均差:即刻期-12.1(95%CI -23.6至-0.5),短期-11.7(95%CI -18.6至-4.7),中期-6.5(95%CI -11.0至-2.1),长期-2.3(95%CI -4.5至-0.2)。
- 任何不良事件风险比:椎间盘切除术对比非手术治疗为1.34(95%CI 0.91至1.98)。
- 证据确定性为极低至低。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,对于有手术指征的坐骨神经痛患者,椎间盘切除术可能是一个选择,前提是患者认为其快速缓解超过手术相关风险与费用。
- 原文未据此给出其他推荐。
局限性
- 证据确定性为极低至低。
- 原文未报告其他局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To investigate the effectiveness and safety of surgery compared with non-surgical treatment for sciatica. DESIGN: Systematic review and meta-analysis. DATA SOURCES: Medline, Embase, CINAHL, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, ClinicalTrials.gov, and the World Health Organisation International Clinical Trials Registry Platform from database inception to June 2022. ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA FOR SELECTING STUDIES: Randomised controlled trials comparing any surgical treatment with non-surgical treatment, epidural steroid injections, or placebo or sham surgery, in people with sciatica of any duration due to lumbar disc herniation (diagnosed by radiological imaging). DATA EXTRACTION AND SYNTHESIS: Two independent reviewers extracted data. Leg pain and disability were the primary outcomes. Adverse events, back pain, quality of life, and satisfaction with treatment were the secondary outcomes. Pain and disability scores were converted to a scale of 0 (no pain or disability) to 100 (worst pain or disability). Data were pooled using a random effects model. Risk of bias was assessed with the Cochrane Collaboration's tool and certainty of evidence with the grading of recommendations assessment, development, and evaluation (GRADE) framework. Follow-up times were into immediate term (≤six weeks), short term (>six weeks and ≤three months), medium term (>three and <12 months), and long term (at 12 months). RESULTS: 24 trials were included, half of these investigated the effectiveness of discectomy compared with non-surgical treatment or epidural steroid injections (1711 participants). Very low to low certainty evidence showed that discectomy, compared with non-surgical treatment, reduced leg pain: the effect size was moderate at immediate term (mean difference -12.1 (95% confidence interval -23.6 to -0.5)) and short term (-11.7 (-18.6 to -4.7)), and small at medium term (-6.5 (-11.0 to -2.1)). Negligible effects were noted at long term (-2.3 (-4.5 to -0.2)). For disability, small, negligible, or no effects were found. A similar effect on leg pain was found when comparing discectomy with epidural steroid injections. For disability, a moderate effect was found at short term, but no effect was observed at medium and long term. The risk of any adverse events was similar between discectomy and non-surgical treatment (risk ratio 1.34 (95% confidence interval 0.91 to 1.98)). CONCLUSION: Very low to low certainty evidence suggests that discectomy was superior to non-surgical treatment or epidural steroid injections in reducing leg pain and disability in people with sciatica with a surgical indication, but the benefits declined over time. Discectomy might be an option for people with sciatica who feel that the rapid relief offered by discectomy outweighs the risks and costs associated with surgery. SYSTEMATIC REVIEW REGISTRATION: PROSPERO CRD42021269997.
引用
- Liu C, Ferreira GE, Abdel Shaheed C, et al. Surgical versus non-surgical treatment for sciatica: systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials. BMJ. 2023. PMID: 37076169. doi:10.1136/bmj-2022-070730
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。