评估社区健康工作者家访干预改善南非儿童发育:整群随机对照试验
在南非林波波省开展整群随机对照试验,将社区健康工作者及所服务看护者-儿童对随机分为干预组和对照组。干预组接受儿童健康、营养、发育里程碑及游戏活动培训。调整模型显示干预对身高别年龄Z评分、发育迟缓及MDAT各项技能无显著影响,但实验室子样本中干预组扫视反应时间及脑电图绝对γ功率和总功率有显著改善。
要点
- 干预对身高别年龄Z评分和发育迟缓无显著影响。
- 干预对粗大运动、精细运动、语言和社会情绪技能无显著影响。
- 实验室子样本中干预组扫视反应时间和脑电图绝对γ功率、总功率显著改善。
核心结论
- 家访干预未显著影响线性生长或发育技能,但扫视反应时间有显著改善。
- 本研究为低收入和中等收入国家家访干预对儿童发育的积极效应提供了证据。
- 本研究证明在低资源环境中收集脑电图功率和扫视反应时间等神经功能标志物的可行性。
研究设计与样本
- 在南非林波波省开展整群随机对照试验,以 ward-based outreach teams(WBOTs)为整群。
- 2017年9月1日将51个整群随机分配至干预组(26个整群,607对看护者-儿童)或对照组(25个整群,488对看护者-儿童)。
- 纳入标准为居住于参与社区健康工作者服务区域、看护者至少18岁、儿童出生于2017年12月15日之后。
- 干预组社区健康工作者接受工作辅助工具培训,内容包括儿童健康、营养、发育里程碑及鼓励参与适合发育的玩耍活动,用于每月对2岁以下儿童看护者的常规家访;对照组提供当地标准照护。
- 主要结局包括身高别年龄Z评分和发育迟缓、Malawi发育评估工具(MDAT)发育评分、脑电图绝对γ功率和总功率、相对γ功率及扫视反应时间,采用意向性治疗分析。
主要发现
- 调整模型显示干预对身高别年龄Z评分无显著影响(aMD 0.11,95%CI -0.07至0.30;p=0.220)。
- 调整模型显示干预对发育迟缓无显著影响(aOR 0.63,95%CI 0.32至1.25;p=0.184)。
- 调整模型显示干预对粗大运动技能(aMD 0.04,95%CI -0.15至0.24;p=0.656)、精细运动技能(aMD -0.04,95%CI -0.19至0.11;p=0.610)、语言技能(aMD -0.02,95%CI -0.18至0.14;p=0.820)和社会情绪技能(aMD -0.02,95%CI -0.20至0.16;p=0.816)均无显著影响。
- 实验室子样本中,干预组扫视反应时间显著改善(aMD -7.13,95%CI -12.69至-1.58;p=0.012),绝对脑电图γ功率显著降低(aMD -0.14,95%CI -0.24至-0.04;p=0.005),总脑电图功率显著降低(aMD -0.15,95%CI -0.23至-0.08;p<0.001),相对γ功率无显著影响(aMD 0.02,95%CI -0.78至0.83;p=0.959)。
- 扫视反应时间的效应在前两次实验室访视时观察到,第三次访视时不再存在,第三次访视与总体终点评估同时进行;干预第一年末43%的社区健康工作者坚持每月家访。
局限性
- 由于COVID-19大流行,无法在干预期结束后1年才评估结局。
- 干预第一年末仅43%的社区健康工作者坚持每月家访。
- 扫视反应时间的效应在前两次实验室访视时观察到,第三次访视时不再存在。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Effective integration of home visit interventions focused on early childhood development into existing service platforms is important for expanding access in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). We designed and evaluated a home visit intervention integrated into community health worker (CHW) operations in South Africa. METHODS AND FINDINGS: We conducted a cluster-randomized controlled trial in Limpopo Province, South Africa. CHWs operating in ward-based outreach teams (WBOTs; clusters) and caregiver-child dyads they served were randomized to the intervention or control group. Group assignment was masked from all data collectors. Dyads were eligible if they resided within a participating CHW catchment area, the caregiver was at least 18 years old, and the child was born after December 15, 2017. Intervention CHWs were trained on a job aid that included content on child health, nutrition, developmental milestones, and encouragement to engage in developmentally appropriate play-based activities, for use during regular monthly home visits with caregivers of children under 2 years of age. Control CHWs provided the local standard of care. Household surveys were administered to the full study sample at baseline and endline. Data were collected on household demographics and assets; caregiver engagement; and child diet, anthropometry, and development scores. In a subsample of children, electroencephalography (EEG) and eye-tracking measures of neural function were assessed at a lab concurrent with endline and at 2 interim time points. Primary outcomes were as follows: height-for-age z-scores (HAZs) and stunting; child development scores measured using the Malawi Developmental Assessment Tool (MDAT); EEG absolute gamma and total power; relative EEG gamma power; and saccadic reaction time (SRT)-an eye-tracking measure of visual processing speed. In the main analysis, unadjusted and adjusted impacts were estimated using intention-to-treat analysis. Adjusted models included a set of demographic covariates measured at baseline. On September 1, 2017, we randomly assigned 51 clusters to intervention (26 clusters, 607 caregiver-child dyads) or control (25 clusters, 488 caregiver-child dyads). At endline (last assessment June 11, 2021), 432 dyads (71%) in 26 clusters remained in the intervention group, and 332 dyads (68%) in 25 clusters remained in the control group. In total, 316 dyads attended the first lab visit, 316 dyads the second lab visit, and 284 dyads the third lab visit. In adjusted models, the intervention had no significant impact on HAZ (adjusted mean difference (aMD) 0.11 [95% confidence interval (CI): -0.07, 0.30]; p = 0.220) or stunting (adjusted odds ratio (aOR) 0.63 [0.32, 1.25]; p = 0.184), nor did the intervention significantly impact gross motor skills (aMD 0.04 [-0.15, 0.24]; p = 0.656), fine motor skills (aMD -0.04 [-0.19, 0.11]; p = 0.610), language skills (aMD -0.02 [-0.18, 0.14]; p = 0.820), or social-emotional skills (aMD -0.02 [-0.20, 0.16]; p = 0.816). In the lab subsample, the intervention had a significant impact on SRT (aMD -7.13 [-12.69, -1.58]; p = 0.012), absolute EEG gamma power (aMD -0.14 [-0.24, -0.04]; p = 0.005), and total EEG power (aMD -0.15 [-0.23, -0.08]; p < 0.001), and no significant impact on relative gamma power (aMD 0.02 [-0.78, 0.83]; p = 0.959). While the effect on SRT was observed at the first 2 lab visits, it was no longer present at the third visit, which coincided with the overall endline assessment. At the end of the first year of the intervention period, 43% of CHWs adhered to monthly home visits. Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, we were not able to assess outcomes until 1 year after the end of the intervention period. CONCLUSIONS: While the home visit intervention did not significantly impact linear growth or skills, we found significant improvement in SRT. This study contributes to a growing literature documenting the positive effects of home visit interventions on child development in LMICs. This study also demonstrates the feasibility of collecting markers of neural function like EEG power and SRT in low-resource settings. TRIAL REGISTRATION: PACTR 201710002683810; https://pactr.samrc.ac.za/TrialDisplay.aspx?TrialID=2683; South African Clinical Trials Registry, SANCTR 4407.
引用
- Rockers PC, Leppänen JM, Tarullo A, et al. Evaluation of a community health worker home visit intervention to improve child development in South Africa: A cluster-randomized controlled trial. PLoS Med. 2023. PMID: 37058529. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1004222
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。