纵向结局篮式试验的贝叶斯借力方法
篮式试验在多个患者亚组中研究单一干预,可共享信息以提高检验效能。本文针对连续纵向结局扩展三种贝叶斯借力方法,并在真实数据集和模拟研究中验证,结果表明共享信息方法在许多场景下可提高检验效能和精度,但在高度异质性场景下需权衡效能与I类错误风险。
要点
- 篮式试验可共享亚组间信息,降低样本量并提高效率。
- 针对连续纵向结局扩展了三种贝叶斯借力方法。
- 共享信息方法可提高检验效能,但高度异质性时I类错误风险增加。
核心结论
- 共享信息的贝叶斯借力方法在许多场景下可提高检测阳性治疗效应的检验效能和精度,但在高度异质性场景下需权衡效能增加与I类错误风险增加。
- 方法选择应基于试验优先事项和预期的亚组间治疗效应分布。
研究设计与样本
- 方法学研究,扩展三种贝叶斯借力方法用于具有连续纵向终点的篮式设计,并在真实世界数据集和模拟研究中展示,模拟研究旨在检测阳性的篮式治疗效应。
主要发现
- 共享信息的方法在许多场景下与各篮独立分析相比可提高检验效能并增加精度。
- 在高度异质性场景下,共享信息方法存在效能增加与I类错误风险增加之间的权衡。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 在高度异质性场景下,共享信息方法存在效能增加与I类错误风险增加之间的权衡。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Basket trials are a novel clinical trial design in which a single intervention is investigated in multiple patient subgroups, or "baskets." They offer the opportunity to share information between subgroups, potentially increasing power to detect treatment effects. Basket trials offer several advantages over running a series of separate trials, including reduced sample sizes, increased efficiency, and reduced costs. Primarily, basket trials have been undertaken in Phase II oncology settings, but could be a promising design in other areas where a shared underlying biological mechanism drives different diseases. One such area is chronic aging-related diseases. However, trials in this area frequently have longitudinal outcomes, and therefore suitable methods are needed to share information in this setting. In this paper, we extend three Bayesian borrowing methods for a basket design with continuous longitudinal endpoints. We demonstrate our methods on a real-world dataset and in a simulation study where the aim is to detect positive basketwise treatment effects. Methods are compared with standalone analysis of each basket without borrowing. Our results confirm that methods that share information can improve power to detect positive treatment effects and increase precision over independent analysis in many scenarios. In highly heterogeneous scenarios, there is a trade-off between increased power and increased risk of type I errors. Our proposed methods for basket trials with continuous longitudinal outcomes aim to facilitate their applicability in the area of aging related diseases. Choice of method should be made based on trial priorities and the expected basketwise distribution of treatment effects.
引用
- Whitehead LE, Sailer O, Witham MD, et al. Bayesian borrowing for basket trials with longitudinal outcomes. Stat Med. 2023. PMID: 37120858. doi:10.1002/sim.9751
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。