Cochrane营养综述对膳食依从性的评估差异很大
本研究调查Cochrane营养综述如何评估特定膳食方案的依从性,纳入226篇综述。多数综述在正文提及膳食依从性(174篇),但仅76篇进行了评估、19篇给出定义,评估方式异质性大。作者建议系统综述应报告所纳入原始研究对膳食依从性的评估及程度,并可将其作为结局、在偏倚风险中评价并纳入敏感性分析。
要点
- 226篇Cochrane营养综述中174篇提及膳食依从性,但仅76篇实际评估、19篇给出定义。
- 20篇将膳食依从性纳入偏倚风险评估,其中9篇使用新创建的偏倚风险域。
- 37篇将膳食依从性作为结局,75篇涉及依从程度,5篇分析考虑依从程度的治疗效果。
核心结论
- Cochrane营养综述对膳食依从性的报告方式异质性很大。
- 鉴于膳食依从性重要性高,作者建议系统综述报告原始研究中对膳食依从性的评估及依从程度。
- 作者提出膳食依从性可进一步作为结局 examined、在偏倚风险(偏离预期干预)中评价并纳入敏感性分析。
研究设计与样本
- 纳入符合以下标准的Cochrane营养综述:系统综述随机对照试验,纳入成人,研究热量限制、膳食模式、食物、营养素、补充剂或其他营养相关干预的效果。
- 共纳入226篇Cochrane综述,进行广泛数据提取和描述性统计。
主要发现
- 多数综述在正文提及膳食依从性(n=174),主要在方法和结果部分。
- 76篇综述评估了膳食依从性,19篇给出定义。
- 20篇将膳食依从性纳入偏倚风险评估,其中9篇使用新创建的膳食依从性偏倚风险域。
- 37篇将膳食依从性作为结局。
- 75篇涉及依从程度,5篇分析考虑依从程度的治疗效果。
关键数值与推荐
- 76篇综述评估膳食依从性,19篇给出定义。
- 20篇将膳食依从性纳入偏倚风险评估,其中9篇使用新创建的偏倚风险域。
- 37篇将膳食依从性作为结局。
- 75篇涉及依从程度,5篇分析考虑依从程度的治疗效果。
临床怎么用
- 作者建议系统综述报告原始研究中对膳食依从性的评估及依从程度。
- 作者提出膳食依从性可进一步作为结局 examined、在偏倚风险(偏离预期干预)中评价并纳入敏感性分析。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Our aim was to investigate if and how Cochrane nutrition reviews assess dietary adherence to a specific dietary regimen. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: Cochrane nutrition reviews fulfilling the following criteria were included: systematic review of randomized controlled trials including adults and investigating the effect of caloric restriction, dietary pattern, foods, nutrients, supplements, or other nutrition-related-interventions. Extensive data extraction and descriptive statistics were conducted. RESULTS: Overall, 226 Cochrane reviews were included. Most reviews mentioned dietary adherence in the main text (n = 174), predominantly in the Methods and Results. Dietary adherence was assessed in 76 reviews and defined in 19. It was included in the risk of bias (RoB) assessment in 20 reviews with nine using a newly created RoB domain for dietary adherence, and considered as outcome in 37 reviews. Seventy-five reviews addressed degree of adherence and five treatment effects considering the degree of adherence. CONCLUSION: Dietary adherence was reported in a heterogeneous manner in Cochrane nutrition reviews. Due to its high importance, we suggest that systematic reviews report the assessment and degree of dietary adherence measured in primary studies. Dietary adherence can further be examined as outcome, evaluated within the RoB (deviations from intended interventions) and included in sensitivity analyses.
引用
- Schwingshackl L, Stadelmaier J, Lay R, et al. In Cochrane nutrition reviews assessment of dietary adherence varied considerably. J Clin Epidemiol. 2023. PMID: 36965600. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2023.03.016
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。