文献速递流行病学与生物统计真实世界研究与卫生经济

电离辐射与心血管疾病:系统综述与荟萃分析

Ionising radiation and cardiovascular disease: systematic review and meta-analysis.
PubMed 文献 · BMJ · 2023-03-08

该系统综述与荟萃分析纳入93项研究,评估个体辐射剂量估算人群的辐射相关心血管疾病风险。全心血管疾病每Gy超额相对风险为0.11(95%CI 0.08-0.14),各亚型风险亦升高,但存在研究间异质性;人群归因超额绝对风险因国家而异,结论支持高剂量下辐射与心血管疾病的因果关联,低剂量下关联较弱。

要点

  • 全心血管疾病每Gy超额相对风险0.11(95%CI 0.08至0.14),四个主要亚型风险均升高。
  • 研究间异质性显著(除其他心脏病外所有终点P<0.05),限制于高质量或中等剂量/低剂量率研究后异质性明显降低。
  • 缺血性心脏病和全心血管疾病中,低剂量和分次暴露下每单位剂量风险更大(逆剂量效应和逆剂量分次效应)。

核心结论

  • 结果提供证据支持高剂量辐射暴露与心血管疾病的因果关联,低剂量下关联较弱,急慢性暴露间风险差异需进一步研究。
  • 观察到的异质性使因果解释复杂化,但仅纳入高质量研究或中等剂量/低剂量率研究时异质性大大降低。
  • 需要研究更详细评估生活方式和医学危险因素对辐射效应的修饰作用。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统综述与荟萃分析,检索PubMed、Medline、Embase、Scopus、Web of Science核心合集数据库,检索日期为2022年10月6日,不限发表时间或语言,排除动物研究和无摘要研究。
  • 最终纳入93项相关研究,均具有个体辐射剂量估算。
  • 主要结局指标为每单位剂量(Gy)的超额相对风险,采用限制性最大似然法估计。

主要发现

  • 全心血管疾病每Gy超额相对风险为0.11(95%CI 0.08至0.14),四个主要亚型(缺血性心脏病、其他心脏病、脑血管疾病、所有其他心血管疾病)风险均升高。
  • 研究间异质性显著(除其他心脏病外所有终点P<0.05),可能源于未测量混杂因素或效应修饰因素的变异,限制于高质量研究或中等剂量(<0.5 Gy)或低剂量率(<5 mGy/h)研究后异质性明显降低。
  • 缺血性心脏病和全心血管疾病中,低剂量下每单位剂量风险更大(逆剂量效应),分次暴露下风险更大(逆剂量分次效应)。
  • 基于人群的超额绝对风险估计因国家而异:英格兰和威尔士为每Gy 2.33%(95%CI 1.69%至2.98%),德国为每Gy 3.66%(2.65%至4.68%),主要反映各国心血管疾病死亡率基线水平。
  • 心血管疾病死亡风险估计一般以脑血管疾病为主(约每Gy 0.94-1.26%),其次为缺血性心脏病(约每Gy 0.30-1.20%)。

局限性

  • 研究间异质性显著(除其他心脏病外所有终点P<0.05),可能源于未测量混杂因素或效应修饰因素的变异。
  • 观察到的异质性使因果解释复杂化。
  • 急慢性暴露间风险差异需进一步研究。
  • 需要研究更详细评估生活方式和医学危险因素对辐射效应的修饰作用。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: To systematically review and perform a meta-analysis of radiation associated risks of cardiovascular disease in all groups exposed to radiation with individual radiation dose estimates. DESIGN: Systematic review and meta-analysis. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Excess relative risk per unit dose (Gy), estimated by restricted maximum likelihood methods. DATA SOURCES: PubMed and Medline, Embase, Scopus, Web of Science Core collection databases. ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA FOR SELECTING STUDIES: Databases were searched on 6 October 2022, with no limits on date of publication or language. Animal studies and studies without an abstract were excluded. RESULTS: The meta-analysis yielded 93 relevant studies. Relative risk per Gy increased for all cardiovascular disease (excess relative risk per Gy of 0.11 (95% confidence interval 0.08 to 0.14)) and for the four major subtypes of cardiovascular disease (ischaemic heart disease, other heart disease, cerebrovascular disease, all other cardiovascular disease). However, interstudy heterogeneity was noted (P<0.05 for all endpoints except for other heart disease), possibly resulting from interstudy variation in unmeasured confounders or effect modifiers, which is markedly reduced if attention is restricted to higher quality studies or those at moderate doses (<0.5 Gy) or low dose rates (<5 mGy/h). For ischaemic heart disease and all cardiovascular disease, risks were larger per unit dose for lower dose (inverse dose effect) and for fractionated exposures (inverse dose fractionation effect). Population based excess absolute risks are estimated for a number of national populations (Canada, England and Wales, France, Germany, Japan, USA) and range from 2.33% per Gy (95% confidence interval 1.69% to 2.98%) for England and Wales to 3.66% per Gy (2.65% to 4.68%) for Germany, largely reflecting the underlying rates of cardiovascular disease mortality in these populations. Estimated risk of mortality from cardiovascular disease are generally dominated by cerebrovascular disease (around 0.94-1.26% per Gy), with the next largest contribution from ischaemic heart disease (around 0.30-1.20% per Gy). CONCLUSIONS: Results provide evidence supporting a causal association between radiation exposure and cardiovascular disease at high dose, and to a lesser extent at low dose, with some indications of differences in risk between acute and chronic exposures, which require further investigation. The observed heterogeneity complicates a causal interpretation of these findings, although this heterogeneity is much reduced if only higher quality studies or those at moderate doses or low dose rates are considered. Studies are needed to assess in more detail modifications of radiation effect by lifestyle and medical risk factors. SYSTEMATIC REVIEW REGISTRATION: PROSPERO CRD42020202036.

来源:BMJ,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Little MP, Azizova TV, Richardson DB, et al. Ionising radiation and cardiovascular disease: systematic review and meta-analysis. BMJ. 2023. PMID: 36889791. doi:10.1136/bmj-2022-072924

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。