文献速递医学教育与科研方法临床试验与 GCP

需要急诊住院的危及生命的疾病临床研究:对参与者及其照护者体验相关定性数据的批判性解释性综合

Clinical research for life-threatening illnesses requiring emergency hospitalisation: a critical interpretive synthesis of qualitative data related to the experience of participants and their caregivers.
PubMed 文献 · Trials · 2023-02-28

该研究对22篇文献中的定性数据进行批判性解释性综合,探讨危及生命的疾病患者在急诊住院期间参与临床研究的体验。多数个体此前无临床研究知识,决策者正处于或目睹紧急状态;临床研究与常规诊疗难以区分,对随机化和均衡等核心概念理解有限,导致低估风险、高估获益并期望被分配到干预组。决策过程深受对研究团队信任的影响;个体建议在研究全程以多种方式提供简化的信息,以提高知识和对研究过程的满意度。

要点

  • 多数个体此前无临床研究知识或经验,决策者正处于或目睹紧急状态并伴有多种躯体和心理症状。
  • 临床研究与常规诊疗难以区分,对随机化和均衡等核心概念理解有限,导致低估风险、高估获益并期望被分配到干预组。
  • 决策过程深受对研究团队的信任影响;个体建议在研究全程以多种方式提供简化信息,以提高知识和对研究过程的满意度。

核心结论

  • 被邀请参与临床研究的危及生命的疾病患者,其管理方式需要适应疾病严重程度,并据此调整研究流程(包括知情同意)。
  • 作者提供了针对危及生命的疾病个体参与研究的进一步研究和实施工作的建议。

研究设计与样本

  • 对试验参与者及替代决策者的定性数据进行批判性解释性综合;先以范围综述为系统综述提供信息,检索研究数据库并筛选论文纳入。
  • 共纳入22篇论文;从每篇论文提取原始数据和对数据的解释,采用相互翻译分析、反驳性综合和论点综合进行分析以形成综合构念。
  • 试验注册号:PROSPERO CRD42020207296。

主要发现

  • 多数个体此前无临床研究知识或经验。
  • 做出决策的个体正处于或目睹紧急状态,并伴有多种躯体和心理症状。
  • 临床研究与常规诊疗难以区分,对研究核心概念(尤其是随机化和均衡)的理解有限。
  • 上述情况导致低估风险、高估获益以及期望被分配到干预组。
  • 决策过程深受对研究团队信任的影响;个体建议在研究全程以不同方式持续提供简化信息,可提高知识和对研究过程的满意度。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为,被邀请参与临床研究的危及生命的疾病患者,其管理方式需要适应疾病严重程度。
  • 作者认为,需要据此调整研究流程,包括知情同意。
  • 个体建议在研究全程以不同方式持续提供简化信息,以提高知识和对研究过程的满意度。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Research into life-threatening illnesses which require emergency hospitalisation is essential. This group of patients is unique in that they are experiencing an unfolding emergency when they are approached, enrolled, and followed up in a research study. We aimed to synthesise qualitative data from trial participants and surrogate decision-makers to deepen our understanding and inform the design and conduct of future clinical trials for life-threatening illnesses. METHODS: We conducted a critical interpretive synthesis of qualitative data from trial participants and surrogate decision-makers related to the experience of participating in a clinical research study when suffering from a life-threatening illness. A scoping review informed a systematic review of published data. We searched research databases and reviewed papers for inclusion. Primary data and interpretations of data were extracted from each paper. Data were analysed using reciprocal translational analysis, refutational synthesis, and lines of argument synthesis to develop a synthetic construct. RESULTS: Twenty-two papers were included. Most individuals had no previous knowledge or experience with clinical research. Individuals making decisions were directly experiencing or witness to an unfolding emergency which came with a myriad of physical and psychological symptoms. It was difficult to differentiate clinical research and routine care, and understanding of core concepts around research, particularly randomisation and equipoise, was limited. We found that this led to an underestimation of risk, an overestimation of benefit, and an expectation of being allocated to the intervention arm. The decision-making process was heavily influenced by trust in the research team. Individuals suggested that abbreviated information, presented in different ways and continuously throughout the research process, would have increased knowledge and satisfaction with the research process. CONCLUSION: Individuals suffering from a life-threatening illness who are being invited to participate in clinical research need to be managed in a way that adapts to the severity of their illness and there is a need to tailor research processes, including informed consent, accordingly. We provide suggestions for further research and implementation work around research participation for individuals suffering from a life-threatening illness. TRIAL REGISTRATION: PROSPERO CRD42020207296.

来源:Trials,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Lawrence DS, Ssali A, Jarvis JN, et al. Clinical research for life-threatening illnesses requiring emergency hospitalisation: a critical interpretive synthesis of qualitative data related to the experience of participants and their caregivers. Trials. 2023. PMID: 36849961. doi:10.1186/s13063-023-07183-6

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。