早产儿及其父母音乐治疗实用性临床试验中的治疗保真度:LongSTEP研究
本研究在7个新生儿重症监护病房(NICU)的213个家庭中评估音乐治疗(MT)的治疗保真度(TF)。11名音乐治疗师实施干预,约10%的会谈录音录像由两名外部评估者和治疗师本人用TF问卷评估。结果显示问卷内部一致性良好(α≥0.70,外部评估者NICU问卷α=0.66),评估者间信度中等(ICC 0.43-0.57),治疗师TD均分为4.88-4.95,家长TR均分为5.66(SD 0.50)。
要点
- TF问卷内部一致性良好(α≥0.70),外部评估者NICU问卷α=0.66。
- 评估者间信度中等,ICC在NICU为0.43、出院后为0.57。
- 治疗师TD均分NICU 4.88、出院后4.95,家长TR均分5.66。
核心结论
- 为评估新生儿护理中音乐治疗而开发的TF问卷显示出良好的内部一致性和中等的评估者间信度。
- TF评分表明各国治疗师按照方案成功实施了MT,高TR评分表明家长按预期接受了干预。
- 未来该领域研究应通过额外培训评估者和改进条目的操作性定义来提高TF测量的评估者间信度。
研究设计与样本
- 实用性随机对照试验(RCT),纳入7个NICU的213个家庭,随机接受标准护理或标准护理加住院期间和/或出院后6个月内的音乐治疗。
- 11名音乐治疗师实施干预,由两名外部评估者和相应治疗师用为本研究设计的TF问卷评估约10%参与者的会谈录音录像(治疗实施,TD)。
- 家长在6个月评估时用相应问卷评估其MT体验(治疗接受,TR)。
主要发现
- 所有TF问卷的Cronbach's α≥0.70,外部评估者NICU问卷α为0.66。
- 评估者间信度ICC:NICU 0.43(CI 0.27, 0.58),出院后0.57(CI 0.39, 0.73)。
- 二分类条目的Gwet's AC在0.32(CI 0.10, 0.54)至0.72(CI 0.55, 0.89)之间。
- 评估了39名参与者的72次NICU会谈和40次随访会谈;治疗师TD复合均分(SD)NICU阶段为4.88(0.92),出院后阶段为4.95(1.05)。
- 138名家长评估了TR,干预条件下平均(SD)得分为5.66(0.50)。
关键数值与推荐
- TF满意度阈值≥4分用于二分类条目的补充分析。
- 所有条目及复合得分为Likert量表,从0(完全不同意)到6(完全同意)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 未来该领域研究应通过额外培训评估者和改进条目的操作性定义来提高TF测量的评估者间信度。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Treatment fidelity (TF) refers to methodological strategies used to monitor and enhance the reliability and validity of interventions. We evaluated TF in a pragmatic RCT of music therapy (MT) for premature infants and their parents. METHODS: Two hundred thirteen families from seven neonatal intensive care units (NICUs) were randomized to receive standard care, or standard care plus MT during hospitalization, and/or during a 6-month period post-discharge. Eleven music therapists delivered the intervention. Audio and video recordings from sessions representing approximately 10% of each therapists' participants were evaluated by two external raters and the corresponding therapist using TF questionnaires designed for the study (treatment delivery (TD)). Parents evaluated their experience with MT at the 6-month assessment with a corresponding questionnaire (treatment receipt (TR)). All items as well as composite scores (mean scores across items) were Likert scales from 0 (completely disagree) to 6 (completely agree). A threshold for satisfactory TF scores (≥4) was used in the additional analysis of dichotomized items. RESULTS: Internal consistency evaluated with Cronbach's alpha was good for all TF questionnaires (α ≥ 0.70), except the external rater NICU questionnaire where it was slightly lower (α 0.66). Interrater reliability measured by intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) was moderate (NICU 0.43 (CI 0.27, 0.58), post-discharge 0.57 (CI 0.39, 0.73)). Gwet's AC for the dichotomized items varied between 0.32 (CI 0.10, 0.54) and 0.72 (CI 0.55, 0.89). Seventy-two NICU and 40 follow-up sessions with 39 participants were evaluated. Therapists' mean (SD) TD composite score was 4.88 (0.92) in the NICU phase and 4.95 (1.05) in the post-discharge phase. TR was evaluated by 138 parents. The mean (SD) score across intervention conditions was 5.66 (0.50). CONCLUSIONS: TF questionnaires developed to assess MT in neonatal care showed good internal consistency and moderate interrater reliability. TF scores indicated that therapists across countries successfully implemented MT in accordance with the protocol. The high treatment receipt scores indicate that parents received the intervention as intended. Future research in this area should aim to improve the interrater reliability of TF measures by additional training of raters and improved operational definitions of items. TRIAL REGISTRATION: Longitudinal Study of music Therapy's Effectiveness for Premature infants and their caregivers - "LongSTEP". CLINICALTRIALS: gov Identifier: NCT03564184. Registered on June 20, 2018.
引用
- Gaden TS, Gold C, Assmus J, et al. Treatment fidelity in a pragmatic clinical trial of music therapy for premature infants and their parents: the LongSTEP study. Trials. 2023. PMID: 36869392. doi:10.1186/s13063-022-06971-w
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。