全科医疗环境中临床试验招募效率相关的站点特异性因素:一项比较描述性分析
该研究利用澳大利亚维多利亚州25家全科诊所参与的一项随机对照试验数据,分析站点层面与患者招募及成本效率相关的因素。结果显示,筛查1968例后招募并随机化299例(15.2%),平均招募效率为7.2,每例随机化患者平均耗时3.7小时、平均成本277澳元;配备临床人员识别潜在参与者与更高效率相关。
要点
- 筛查1968例中招募并随机化299例(15.2%),站点平均招募效率7.2(范围1.4–19.8)。
- 每例随机化患者平均耗时3.7小时(SD 2.4),平均成本277澳元(SD 161),站点间成本74–797澳元。
- 配备临床人员识别潜在参与者的站点招募效率更高(57.14% vs 22.2%)。
核心结论
- 尽管样本量小,本研究量化了招募患者所用时间和成本,并提供了有助于改善全科医疗环境中开展随机对照试验可行性和效率的站点层面特征提示。
研究设计与样本
- 比较描述性分析,利用一项在澳大利亚维多利亚州25家全科诊所开展的随机对照试验的数据。
- 从每个研究站点提取筛查、排除、合格、招募和随机化参与者数量,并通过三部分调查收集站点特征、招募实践和员工时间投入信息。
- 关键结局为招募效率(筛查与随机化之比)、每例招募并随机化参与者的平均时间和成本;结局按第25百分位与其他站点二分类后评估各站点层面因素的关联。
主要发现
- 25个全科研究站点共筛查1968例参与者,其中299例(15.2%)被招募并随机化。
- 平均招募效率为7.2,各站点间从1.4到19.8不等。
- 与效率最强的相关因素是分配临床人员识别潜在参与者(57.14% vs 22.2%)。
- 更高效的站点规模较小,更可能位于农村地区和社会经济地位较低地区。
- 每例随机化患者平均招募时间为3.7小时(SD 2.4),平均成本为277澳元(SD 161),各站点间从74澳元到797澳元不等;招募成本最低25%的站点(n=7)研究参与经验更丰富且护士和/或行政支持水平高。
局限性
- 原文结论自述样本量小。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Recruitment of participants is crucial to the success of randomised control trials (RCTs) but can be challenging and expensive. Current research on trial efficiency is often focused at the patient-level with an emphasis on effective recruitment strategies. Less is known about selection of study sites to optimise recruitment. We examine site-level factors that are associated with patient recruitment and cost efficiency using data from an RCT conducted across 25 general practices (GP) in Victoria, Australia. METHODS: Data on number of participants screened, excluded, eligible, recruited, and randomised from each study site were extracted from a clinical trial. Details regarding site characteristics, recruitment practices, and staff time commitment were collected using a three-part survey. The key outcomes assessed were recruitment efficiency (ratio of screened to randomised), average time, and cost for each participant recruited and randomised. To identify practice-level factors associated with efficient recruitment and lower cost, outcomes were dichotomised (25th percentile vs others) and each practice-level factor assessed against the outcomes to determine its association. RESULTS: Across 25 GP study sites, 1968 participants were screened of which 299 (15.2%) were recruited and randomised. The mean recruitment efficiency was 7.2, varying from 1.4 to 19.8 across sites. The strongest factor associated with efficiency was assigning clinical staff to identify potential participants (57.14% vs. 22.2%). The more efficient sites were smaller practices and were more likely to be rural locations and in areas of lower socioeconomic status. The average time used for recruitment was 3.7 h (SD2.4) per patient randomised. The mean cost per patient randomised was $277 (SD161), and this varied from $74 to $797 across sites. The sites identified with the 25% lowest recruitment cost (n = 7) were more experienced in research participation and had high levels of nurse and/or administrative support. CONCLUSION: Despite the small sample size, this study quantified the time and cost used to recruit patients and provides helpful indications of site-level characteristics that can help improve feasibility and efficiency of conducting RCT in GP settings. Characteristics indicative of high levels of support for research and rural practices, which often tends to be overlooked, were observed to be more efficient in recruiting.
引用
- Tew M, Catchpool M, Furler J, et al. Site-specific factors associated with clinical trial recruitment efficiency in general practice settings: a comparative descriptive analysis. Trials. 2023. PMID: 36869362. doi:10.1186/s13063-023-07177-4
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。