为全球健康临床研究参与者沟通计划创建最佳实践模板
该混合方法研究通过挖掘48份公开临床试验方案并访谈7名临床试验专家,了解沟通计划在全球健康临床研究中的作用。结果显示48份方案均未包含沟通计划,仅21%含沟通相关表述、10%描述了向参与者分享结果的计划。作者据此开发了适用于中低收入国家的沟通计划模板,并建议研究人员全程使用。
要点
- 48份全球健康临床试验方案均未包含完整的参与者沟通计划。
- 仅21%(n=21)方案含沟通相关表述,10%(n=5)描述向参与者分享结果的计划。
- 作者建议研究人员在研究全程使用所开发的沟通计划模板。
核心结论
- 全球健康临床试验中沟通计划的使用存在缺失,据作者所知这是迄今对临床试验沟通计划的首次深度分析。
- 作者建议研究人员在研究全程使用所开发的沟通计划模板,以确保以人为中心的参与者沟通。
- 该沟通计划应适用于试验所有阶段,尤其强调试验完成后以可及且有吸引力的方式分享结果。
研究设计与样本
- 混合方法研究,历时6个月,包括对公开临床试验方案中沟通相关语言的半定量分析,以及7名临床试验专家的定性访谈。
- 共挖掘48份公开临床试验方案,访谈7名临床试验专家,以指导沟通计划模板的开发。
主要发现
- 48份挖掘的临床试验方案中,无一包含沟通计划。
- 48份方案中,21%(n=21)包含沟通相关语言,10%(n=5)描述了向参与者分享试验结果的计划。
临床怎么用
- 作者建议研究人员在研究全程使用所开发的沟通计划模板,以确保以人为中心的参与者沟通。
- 作者提出该沟通计划应适用于试验所有阶段,尤其强调试验完成后以可及且有吸引力的方式分享结果。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Clinical trial participants have a right to be informed throughout the entire process of human subject research. As part of this pillar of research ethics, participants and other stakeholders should be made aware of research findings after a trial has been completed. Though participants have both a right, and a desire to be informed of research outcomes, studies show that they rarely receive communication about study findings. Our aim was (1) to understand what, if any, role communication plans play in current global health clinical research protocols and (2) to use our findings to develop a communication plan template tailored to clinical research carried out in low-and-middle-income countries (LMIC) while minimizing colonial assumptions. While the template was drafted in the LMIC context, the principles are universally applicable and should be considered best practices for all global health clinical trials. METHODS: We carried out a mixed-method study over a period of 6 months to understand the role of communication with study participants and other stakeholders in clinical trials. The semiquantitative analysis included mining publicly available clinical trial protocols for communication-related language. Qualitative interviews (n = 7) were used to gather knowledge and insight from clinical trial experts to inform the development of a communication plan template. RESULTS: None of the 48 mined clinical trial protocols included a communication plan. Of the 48, 21% (n = 21) protocols included communication-related language, and 10% (n = 5) described plans to share trial results with participants. CONCLUSION: The use of communication plans in global health clinical trials is lacking. To our knowledge, this is the first in-depth analysis of communication plans in clinical trials to date. We recommend that researchers utilize the developed communication plan template throughout the entire research process to ensure a human-centered approach to participant communication. This communication plan should apply to all phases of a research trial, with a particular emphasis on plans to share results in an accessible and engaging manner once the trial has been completed.
引用
- Shelly CE, Logan C, Skorochod B, et al. Creating a best practice template for participant communication plans in global health clinical studies. Trials. 2023. PMID: 36864516. doi:10.1186/s13063-023-07185-4
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。