报告指南采用多种不同方法制定推荐意见
该研究调查了EQUATOR网络数据库中报告指南的制定方法,2018年10月筛查全部记录,排除非报告指南后由12名研究者对文献计量、范围、制定方法、呈现与传播进行双人数据提取。405条记录中262条描述了报告指南的制定,数量从1990年代的5部增至2010年代的157部,制定方法差异较大。
要点
- 报告指南数量从1990年代5部增至2010年代157部,制定方法差异较大。
- 56%的报告指南在制定过程中进行了文献评价,42%对推荐意见进行了预试验或寻求外部反馈。
- 18%的纳入出版物存在一定程度的spin(表述偏向)。
核心结论
- 报告指南的制定方法各不相同,制定者应使用现有指导并采取循证方法,而非基于有限人群的专家意见提出推荐。
研究设计与样本
- 2018年10月筛查EQUATOR网络数据库全部记录,排除非报告指南描述后,由12名研究者对文献计量、范围、制定方法、呈现与传播进行双人数据提取,采用描述性统计总结。
主要发现
- 405条筛查记录中262条描述了报告指南的制定。
- 报告指南数量过去30年增加,从1990年代的5部、2000年代的63部增至2010年代的157部。
- 制定小组人数为2至151人。
- 56%的报告指南在制定过程中进行了文献评价,33%使用调查收集外部对报告条目的意见,42%对推荐意见进行了预试验或寻求外部反馈。
- 30%的报告指南为所有报告条目提供了良好报告示例,18%的纳入出版物存在一定程度的spin。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: We investigated the developing methods of reporting guidelines in the EQUATOR (Enhancing the QUAlity and Transparency Of health Research) Network's database. METHODS: In October 2018, we screened all records and excluded those not describing reporting guidelines from further investigation. Twelve researchers performed duplicate data extraction on bibliometrics, scope, development methods, presentation, and dissemination of all publications. Descriptive statistics were used to summarize the findings. RESULTS: Of the 405 screened records, 262 described a reporting guidelines development. The number of reporting guidelines increased over the past 3 decades, from 5 in the 1990s and 63 in the 2000s to 157 in the 2010s. Development groups included 2-151 people. Literature appraisal was performed during the development of 56% of the reporting guidelines; 33% used surveys to gather external opinion on items to report; and 42% piloted or sought external feedback on their recommendations. Examples of good reporting for all reporting items were presented in 30% of the reporting guidelines. Eighteen percent of the reviewed publications included some level of spin. CONCLUSION: Reporting guidelines have been developed with varying methodology. Reporting guideline developers should use existing guidance and take an evidence-based approach, rather than base their recommendations on expert opinion of limited groups of individuals.
引用
- Schlussel MM, Sharp MK, de Beyer JA, et al. Reporting guidelines used varying methodology to develop recommendations. J Clin Epidemiol. 2023. PMID: 36965598. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2023.03.018
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。