文献速递流行病学与生物统计

针对结核病预防与控制的移民后强制、自愿、重复或一次性随访:系统综述

Mandatory, voluntary, repetitive, or one-off post-migration follow-up for tuberculosis prevention and control: A systematic review.
PubMed 文献 · PLoS Med · 2023-01-31

该系统综述与Meta分析纳入7个国家的24项随访筛查规划报告,评估移民后结核病随访策略。规划覆盖率与检出率差异大,自愿与强制规划检出率相当,重复筛查未见高于一次性筛查,作者建议考虑每轮额外筛查的边际成本。

要点

  • 移民后随访规划的覆盖率与结核检出率在国家和规划间差异很大。
  • 自愿规划与强制规划的检出率在幅度和不确定性上相当。
  • 重复筛查似乎未较一次性筛查带来更高检出率,作者建议考虑边际成本。

核心结论

  • 移民后随访筛查的规划特征、覆盖率与检出率差异很大;自愿与强制规划检出率相似,重复筛查未较一次性筛查带来更高检出率;筛查策略应考虑每轮额外筛查的边际成本。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统综述与Meta分析,纳入报告主动随访筛查规划结核检出率的研究;检索Chan等系统综述截至2017年1月12日的研究,并更新检索2017年1月12日至2022年9月30日Medline和Embase(通过Ovid)。

主要发现

  • 共纳入来自7个国家的24篇筛查规划报告,合格人群、筛查时间间隔和诊断方案差异很大。
  • 覆盖率在15项研究中高于60%,自愿规划趋于低于强制规划,美国、以色列和澳大利亚的研究趋于更高。
  • 检出率在国家内和国家间变异,范围从荷兰研究的53.05(31.94至82.84)到美国研究的5,927.05(4,248.29至8,013.71)。
  • 15个窄95%CI的检出率估计中,12个低于每10万合格移民1,500例。
  • 一次性随访规划的检出率估计趋于更高且不确定性更小;自愿与强制规划的检出率在幅度和不确定性上相当。

临床怎么用

  • 作者建议筛查策略应考虑每轮额外筛查的边际成本。

局限性

  • 研究受限于所识别筛查规划设计的异质性,有效性、覆盖率和检出率还取决于常被低报或未知的因素,如相应人群的基线发病率、再激活率、教育和行政流程以及不遵守强制措施的后果。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Post-migration follow-up of migrants identified to be at-risk of developing tuberculosis during the initial screening is effective, but programmes vary across countries. We aimed to review main strategies applied to design follow-up programmes and analyse the effect of key programme characteristics on reported coverage (i.e., proportion of migrants screened among those eligible for screening) or yields (i.e., proportion of active tuberculosis among those identified as eligible for follow-up screening). METHODS AND FINDINGS: We performed a systematic review and meta-analysis of studies reporting yields of follow-up screening programmes. Studies were included if they reported the rate of tuberculosis disease detected in international migrants through active case finding strategies and applied a post-migration follow-up (defined as one or more additional rounds of screening after finalising the initial round). For this, we retrieved all studies identified by Chan and colleagues for their systematic review (in their search until January 12, 2017) and included those reporting from active follow-up programmes. We then updated the search (from January 12, 2017 to September 30, 2022) using Medline and Embase via Ovid. Data were extracted on reported coverage, yields, and key programme characteristics, including eligible population, mode of screening, time intervals for screening, programme providers, and legal frameworks. Differences in follow-up programmes were tabulated and synthesised narratively. Meta-analyses in random effect models and exploratory analysis of subgroups showed high heterogeneity (I2 statistic > 95.0%). We hence refrained from pooling, and estimated yields and coverage with corresponding 95% confidence intervals (CIs), stratified by country, legal character (mandatory versus voluntary screening), and follow-up scheme (one-off versus repetitive screening) using forest plots for comparison and synthesis. Of 1,170 articles, 24 reports on screening programmes from 7 countries were included, with considerable variation in eligible populations, time intervals of screening, and diagnostic protocols. Coverage varied, but was higher than 60% in 15 studies, and tended to be lower in voluntary compared to compulsory programmes, and higher in studies from the United States of America, Israel, and Australia. Yield varied within and between countries and ranged between 53.05 (31.94 to 82.84) in a Dutch study and 5,927.05 (4,248.29 to 8,013.71) in a study from the United States. Of 15 estimates with narrow 95% CIs for yields, 12 were below 1,500 cases per 100,000 eligible migrants. Estimates of yields in one-off follow-up programmes tended to be higher and were surrounded by less uncertainty, compared to those in repetitive follow-up programmes. Yields in voluntary and mandatory programmes were comparable in magnitude and uncertainty. The study is limited by the heterogeneity in the design of the identified screening programmes as effectiveness, coverage and yields also depend on factors often underreported or not known, such as baseline incidence in the respective population, reactivation rate, educative and administrative processes, and consequences of not complying with obligatory measures. CONCLUSION: Programme characteristics of post-migration follow-up screening for prevention and control of tuberculosis as well as coverage and yield vary considerably. Voluntary programmes appear to have similar yields compared with mandatory programmes and repetitive screening apparently did not lead to higher yields compared with one-off screening. Screening strategies should consider marginal costs for each additional round of screening.

来源:PLoS Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Wahedi K, Zenner D, Flores S, et al. Mandatory, voluntary, repetitive, or one-off post-migration follow-up for tuberculosis prevention and control: A systematic review. PLoS Med. 2023. PMID: 36719863. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1004030

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。