文献速递医学教育与科研方法流行病学与生物统计

系统综述中常使用荟萃分析以外的合成方法但很少具体说明:一项系统综述调查

Synthesis methods other than meta-analysis were commonly used but seldom specified: survey of systematic reviews.
PubMed 文献 · J Clin Epidemiol · 2023-02-08

该研究随机抽取2018年发表于Health Evidence和Health Systems Evidence数据库的100篇公共卫生与卫生系统干预系统综述,编码其总结与统计合成方法的说明和使用情况。结果显示60篇使用其他合成方法,其中54篇使用投票计数法,但仅少数描述了方法;58篇使用荟萃分析,未进行荟萃分析的最常见原因是研究特征多样性。作者认为需要改进方法描述,并提高对基于统计显著性的投票计数法严重局限性的认识。

要点

  • 100篇系统综述中60篇使用荟萃分析以外的合成方法,其中54篇使用投票计数法。
  • 54篇投票计数法中仅3篇基于效应方向、36篇基于统计显著性、15篇不明确。
  • 17篇使用「叙述性合成」等术语但未描述方法,其中15篇实际使用投票计数法。

核心结论

  • 荟萃分析以外的统计合成方法常用,但很少系统综述描述这些方法。
  • 需要改进方法描述,以便用户恰当解读发现、评判所用方法并验证结果。
  • 需要提高对基于统计显著性的投票计数法严重局限性的认识。

研究设计与样本

  • 从Health Evidence和Health Systems Evidence数据库随机抽取2018年发表的100篇公共卫生与卫生系统干预系统综述。
  • 对总结与合成方法的说明和使用进行编码。

主要发现

  • 100篇系统综述中60篇对部分(27/100)或全部(33/100)合成使用其他合成方法。
  • 60篇中54篇使用投票计数法:3篇基于效应方向,36篇基于统计显著性,15篇不明确。
  • 8篇系统综述总结效应估计值(例如使用中位数)。
  • 17篇系统综述使用「叙述性合成」或等同术语但未描述方法,实践中其中15篇使用投票计数法。
  • 100篇中58篇使用荟萃分析;未进行荟萃分析的最常见原因是研究特征多样性(33/39)。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: To examine the specification and use of summary and statistical synthesis methods, focusing on synthesis methods other than meta-analysis. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We coded the specification and use of summary and synthesis methods in 100 randomly sampled systematic reviews (SRs) of public health and health systems interventions published in 2018 from the Health Evidence and Health Systems Evidence databases. RESULTS: Sixty of the 100 SRs used other synthesis methods for some (27/100) or all syntheses (33/100). Of these, 54/60 used vote counting: three based on direction of effect, 36 on statistical significance, and 15 were unclear. Eight SRs summarized effect estimates (for example, using medians). Seventeen SRs used the term 'narrative synthesis' (or equivalent) without describing methods; in practice 15 of these used vote counting. 58/100 SRs used meta-analysis. In SRs providing a rationale for not proceeding with meta-analysis, the most common reason was due to diversity in study characteristics (33/39). CONCLUSION: Statistical synthesis methods other than meta-analysis are commonly used, but few SRs describe the methods. Improved description of methods is required to allow users to appropriately interpret findings, critique methods used and verify the results. Greater awareness of the serious limitations of vote counting based on statistical significance is required.

来源:J Clin Epidemiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Cumpston MS, Brennan SE, Ryan R, et al. Synthesis methods other than meta-analysis were commonly used but seldom specified: survey of systematic reviews. J Clin Epidemiol. 2023. PMID: 36758885. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2023.02.003

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。