优先结局间相关性对广义配对比较净获益及其估计的影响
本研究通过理论与数值分析,探讨两个二分类或高斯变量间的相关性对真实净获益值的影响,并基于四种现有方法(Gehan、Péron、带校正的Gehan、带校正的Péron)在右删失下通过模拟和实际肿瘤临床试验数据,研究生存与分类变量间相关性对净获益估计的影响。理论分析显示真实净获益受相关性影响的方向取决于结局分布,二分类结局下方向由有利结局50%阈值这一简单规则决定;模拟显示Gehan或Péron评分规则的净获益估计在右删失下可能显著偏倚,偏倚方向与幅度与结局相关性有关,新近提出的校正方法即使存在强结局相关性也能大幅减少该偏倚。
要点
- 真实净获益受结局间相关性影响,方向随结局分布不同而异。
- 二分类结局下,相关性影响方向由有利结局50%阈值规则决定。
- 右删失下Gehan或Péron评分规则的净获益估计可能显著偏倚。
核心结论
- 结局间相关性对真实净获益值的影响方向与幅度取决于结局分布,二分类结局下方向由有利结局50%阈值规则决定。
- 右删失下基于Gehan或Péron评分规则的净获益估计可能显著偏倚,偏倚方向与幅度与结局相关性有关,校正方法可大幅减少该偏倚。
- 解读净获益及其估计时应仔细考虑相关性的影响。
研究设计与样本
- 通过理论分析和数值分析研究两个二分类或高斯变量间相关性对真实净获益值的影响。
- 通过模拟和应用于实际肿瘤临床试验数据,研究右删失下生存与分类变量间相关性对基于四种现有方法(Gehan、Péron、带校正的Gehan、带校正的Péron)的净获益估计的影响。
主要发现
- 真实净获益值受相关性影响的方向随结局分布不同而异,二分类结局下由有利结局50%阈值规则决定。
- 模拟显示基于Gehan或Péron评分规则的净获益估计在右删失下可能显著偏倚,偏倚方向与幅度与结局相关性有关。
- 新近提出的校正方法即使存在强结局相关性也能大幅减少该偏倚。
关键数值与推荐
- 二分类结局下,相关性影响真实净获益方向由有利结局50%阈值规则决定。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Benefit-risk balance is gaining interest in clinical trials. For the comprehensive assessment of benefits and risks, generalized pairwise comparisons are increasingly used to estimate the net benefit based on multiple prioritized outcomes. Although previous research has demonstrated that the correlations between the outcomes impact the net benefit and its estimate, the direction and magnitude of this impact remain unclear. In this study, we investigated the impact of correlations between two binary or Gaussian variables on the true net benefit values via theoretical and numerical analyses. We also explored the impact of correlations between survival and categorical variables on the net benefit estimates based on four existing methods (Gehan, Péron, Gehan with correction, and Péron with correction) in the presence of right censoring via simulation and application to actual oncology clinical trial data. Our theoretical and numerical analyses revealed that the true net benefit values were impacted by the correlations in various directions depending on the outcome distributions. With binary endpoints, this direction was governed by a simple rule with a threshold of 50% for a favorable outcome. Our simulation showed that the net benefit estimates based on Gehan's or Péron's scoring rule could be substantially biased in the presence of right censoring, and that the direction and magnitude of this bias were associated with the outcome correlations. The recently proposed correction method greatly reduced this bias, even in the presence of strong outcome correlations. The impact of correlations should be carefully considered when interpreting the net benefit and its estimate.
引用
- Fuyama K, Ogawa M, Mizusawa J, et al. Impact of correlations between prioritized outcomes on the net benefit and its estimate by generalized pairwise comparisons. Stat Med. 2023. PMID: 36849124. doi:10.1002/sim.9690
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。