系统综述的问题:一项动态系统综述
该动态系统综述旨在识别并记录已发表系统综述中的缺陷。第一轮纳入485篇文章,记录了67个与系统综述实施和报告相关的问题,这些问题可能危及综述的可靠性或有效性。尽管指南存在且被频繁应用,大量文章仍揭示了系统综述在实施、方法和报告方面的诸多缺陷。
要点
- 第一轮动态系统综述纳入485篇文章,记录67个系统综述缺陷问题。
- 这些缺陷可能危及系统综述的可靠性或有效性。
- 尽管指南存在且被频繁应用,系统综述在实施、方法和报告方面仍存在大量缺陷。
核心结论
- 数百篇文章表明,尽管指南存在且被频繁应用,已发表系统综述在实施、方法和报告方面仍存在诸多缺陷。
- 鉴于系统综述在医学决策中的核心作用,未能认识和规范这些高被引研究设计的问题是对可信科学的威胁。
研究设计与样本
- 动态系统综述,全面评估所有探讨已发表系统综述相关问题的文献。
- 第一轮动态系统综述纳入485篇文章。
主要发现
- 第一轮动态系统综述发现485篇文章记录了67个与系统综述实施和报告相关的离散问题。
- 这些问题可能危及系统综述的可靠性或有效性。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Systematic reviews and meta-analyses are proliferating as they are an important building block to inform evidence-based guidelines and decision-making. Enforcement of best practice in clinical trials is firmly on the research agenda of good clinical practice, but there is less clarity as to how evidence syntheses that combine these studies can be influenced by bad practice. Our aim was to conduct a living systematic review of articles that highlight flaws in published systematic reviews to formally document and understand these problems. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We conducted a comprehensive assessment of all literature examining problems, which relate to published systematic reviews. RESULTS: The first iteration of our living systematic review (https://systematicreviewlution.com/) has found 485 articles documenting 67 discrete problems relating to the conduct and reporting of systematic reviews which can potentially jeopardize their reliability or validity. CONCLUSION: Many hundreds of articles highlight that there are many flaws in the conduct, methods, and reporting of published systematic reviews, despite the existence and frequent application of guidelines. Considering the pivotal role that systematic reviews have in medical decision-making due to having apparently transparent, objective, and replicable processes, a failure to appreciate and regulate problems with these highly cited research designs is a threat to credible science.
引用
- Uttley L, Quintana DS, Montgomery P, et al. The problems with systematic reviews: a living systematic review. J Clin Epidemiol. 2023. PMID: 36796736. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2023.01.011
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。