一项系统综述发现以健康不平等/不公为重点的综述在方法学上缺乏共识
该研究系统检索六个社会科学数据库(1990年至2022年5月)及灰色文献,纳入2008至2022年间发表的62篇(30%)以健康不平等/不公为重点的综述,发现其在方法学、人群、干预层面和临床领域方面多样,仅19篇(31%)讨论了不平等/不公的定义,并识别出PROGRESS/Plus框架和PRISMA-Equity清单两个方法学指南。结论认为现有指南对如何考虑健康不平等/不公缺乏清晰性,需要概念框架展示各维度的路径和交互作用。
要点
- 62篇(30%)综述以健康不平等/不公为重点,方法学、人群、干预层面和临床领域多样。
- 仅19篇(31%)综述讨论了不平等/不公的定义。
- 识别出PROGRESS/Plus框架和PRISMA-Equity清单两个方法学指南,但均存在不足。
核心结论
- 对方法学指南的批判性分析再次确认,关于如何考虑健康不平等/不公缺乏清晰性或指导。
- PROGRESS/Plus框架狭隘地聚焦于健康不平等/不公的维度,但很少考虑这些维度的路径和交互作用及其对结局的影响。
- PRISMA-Equity清单则提供了报告方面的指导。
- 需要一个概念框架来展示健康不平等/不公各维度的路径和交互作用。
研究设计与样本
- 对使用健康不平等/不公指导的证据合成文章进行批判性综述和分析。
- 全面系统检索六个社会科学数据库(1990年至2022年5月)和灰色文献来源。
- 采用叙述性方法进行合成,描述并归类纳入文章的特征。
- 对现有方法学指南进行比较,讨论其异同。
主要发现
- 从2008年至2022年间发表的205篇综述中,62篇(30%)以健康不平等/不公为重点并符合标准。
- 纳入综述在方法学、人群、干预层面和临床领域方面多样。
- 仅19篇(31%)综述讨论了不平等/不公的定义。
- 识别出两个方法学指南:PROGRESS/Plus框架和PRISMA-Equity清单。
关键数值与推荐
- PROGRESS/Plus框架狭隘地聚焦于健康不平等/不公的维度,但很少考虑这些维度的路径和交互作用及其对结局的影响。
- PRISMA-Equity清单提供报告方面的指导。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To critically review and analyze evidence synthesis articles using health inequality/inequity guidance to support their review. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: A comprehensive, systematic search of six social science databases (1990 to May 2022) and grey literature sources was undertaken. A narrative approach to synthesis was adopted, describing and categorizing the characteristics of included articles. A comparison of the existing methodological guides was also conducted, discussing the similarities and differences between them. RESULTS: From 205 identified reviews published between 2008 and 2022, 62 (30%) focusing on health inequality/inequity, met the criteria. The reviews were diverse in terms of methodology, populations, intervention level, and clinical areas. Only 19 (31%) reviews discussed the definition of inequality/inequity. Two methodological guides were identified: (i) the PROGRESS/Plus framework and (ii) the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses-Equity checklist. CONCLUSION: A critique on the methodological guides reaffirms a lack of clarity or guidance on how health inequality/inequity should be considered. The PROGRESS/Plus framework narrowly focuses on dimensions of health inequality/inequity but rarely considers the pathways and interactions of these dimensions and their effect on outcomes. The Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses-Equity checklist on the other hand provides guidance on report. A conceptual framework is needed to show the pathways and interactions of dimensions of health inequality/inequity.
引用
- Kunonga TP, Hanratty B, Bower P, et al. A systematic review finds a lack of consensus in methodological approaches in health inequality/inequity focused reviews. J Clin Epidemiol. 2023. PMID: 36813002. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2023.02.013
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。