510(k) 许可医疗器械的监管提交特征与召回之间的关联
这项探索性横断面分析纳入2003至2018年获美国FDA 510(k)许可的35176件医疗器械,其中4007件(11.4%)被召回。线性概率模型显示,引用有3个及以上正在召回的前代器械、引用前代器械总数增加与召回概率升高相关,而最新前代器械年龄增加与召回概率降低相关。
要点
- 35176件510(k)器械中4007件(11.4%)被召回。
- 引用有3个及以上正在召回前代器械的申请器械,召回概率增加9.31个百分点(95%CI 2.84-15.77)。
- 引用前代器械总数每增加1个标准差,召回概率增加1.25个百分点(95%CI 0.62-1.87)。
核心结论
- 这项探索性横断面研究显示,510(k)提交特征与医疗器械召回之间存在显著关联。
- 需要进一步研究来理解这些关联的含义。
研究设计与样本
- 研究为探索性横断面分析,纳入2003至2018年通过510(k)监管提交途径获美国FDA许可的医疗器械。
- 研究样本共35176件医疗器械,其中4007件(11.4%)被召回。
- 研究使用线性概率模型检验510(k)器械召回状态与其前代器械特征之间的关联。
- 公共文件通过FDA数据库收集,并应用文本提取算法识别510(k)监管提交中引用的前代器械,算法衍生的元数据与2003-2020年FDA召回数据相结合。
主要发现
- 申请器械平均引用2.6个前代器械,最新和最老前代器械的平均年龄分别为3.6年和7.4年。
- 93.9%的申请器械引用的前代器械无正在进行的召回,4.3%引用有1个正在进行的I类或II类召回的前代器械,1.0%引用有2个正在进行的召回的前代器械,0.8%引用有3个或以上正在进行的召回的前代器械。
- 与无正在召回前代器械的器械相比,引用有3个或以上正在召回前代器械的申请器械,召回概率显著增加9.31个百分点(95%CI 2.84-15.77个百分点),相对于平均召回概率增加81.2%。
- 申请器械引用的前代器械总数每增加1个标准差,召回概率显著增加1.25个百分点(95%CI 0.62-1.87个百分点),相对于平均召回概率增加11.0%。
- 最新前代器械年龄每增加1个标准差,召回概率显著降低0.78个百分点(95%CI 1.29-0.30个百分点),相对于平均召回概率降低6.8%。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性;作者在结论中指出需要进一步研究来理解这些关联的含义。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: Most regulated medical devices enter the US market via the 510(k) regulatory submission pathway, wherein manufacturers demonstrate that applicant devices are "substantially equivalent" to 1 or more "predicate" devices (legally marketed medical devices with similar intended use). Most recalled medical devices are 510(k) devices. OBJECTIVE: To examine the association between characteristics of predicate medical devices and recall probability for 510(k) devices. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: In this exploratory cross-sectional analysis of medical devices cleared by the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) between 2003 and 2018 via the 510(k) regulatory submission pathway, linear probability models were used to examine associations between a 510(k) device's recall status and characteristics of its predicate medical devices. Public documents for the 510(k) medical devices were collected using FDA databases. A text extraction algorithm was applied to identify predicate medical devices cited in 510(k) regulatory submissions. Algorithm-derived metadata were combined with 2003-2020 FDA recall data. EXPOSURES: Citation of predicate medical devices with certain characteristics in 510(k) regulatory submissions, including the total number of predicate medical devices cited by the applicant device, the age of the predicate medical devices, the lack of similarity of the predicate medical devices to the applicant device, and the recall status of the predicate medical devices. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Class I or class II recall of a 510(k) medical device between its FDA regulatory clearance date and December 31, 2020. RESULTS: The sample included 35 176 medical devices, of which 4007 (11.4%) were recalled. The applicant devices cited a mean of 2.6 predicate medical devices, with mean ages of 3.6 years and 7.4 years for the newest and oldest, respectively, predicate medical devices. Of the applicant devices, 93.9% cited predicate medical devices with no ongoing recalls, 4.3% cited predicate medical devices with 1 ongoing class I or class II recall, 1.0% cited predicate medical devices with 2 ongoing recalls, and 0.8% cited predicate medical devices with 3 or more ongoing recalls. Applicant devices citing predicate medical devices with 3 or more ongoing recalls were significantly associated with a 9.31-percentage-point increase (95% CI, 2.84-15.77 percentage points) in recall probability compared with devices without ongoing recalls of predicate medical devices, or an 81.2% increase in recall probability relative to the mean recall probability. A 1-SD increase in the total number of predicate medical devices cited by the applicant device was significantly associated with a 1.25-percentage-point increase (95% CI, 0.62-1.87 percentage points) in recall probability, or an 11.0% increase in recall probability relative to the mean recall probability. A 1-SD increase in the newest age of a predicate medical device was significantly associated with a 0.78-percentage-point decrease (95% CI, 1.29-0.30 percentage points) in recall probability, or a 6.8% decrease in recall probability relative to the mean recall probability. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: This exploratory cross-sectional study of 510(k) medical devices cleared by the FDA between 2003 and 2018 demonstrated significant associations between 510(k) submission characteristics and recalls of medical devices. Further research is needed to understand the implications of these associations.
引用
- Everhart AO, Sen S, Stern AD, et al. Association Between Regulatory Submission Characteristics and Recalls of Medical Devices Receiving 510(k) Clearance. JAMA. 2023. PMID: 36625811. doi:10.1001/jama.2022.22974
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。