活指南制定方法:基于实践经验的早期指导。第5篇:活指南证据合成与推荐意见制定方法的选择
本文通过访谈、反馈和国际活指南制定者共识的迭代过程,为活指南制定者提供框架,以选择适合其主题、问题或情境的活指南模型。文中识别了系统综述流程、证据评价方法(含未发表数据使用)及纳入新研究的触发因素等关键决策及其权衡。结论认为最合适且最可持续的制定与更新模式取决于这些领域的选择。
要点
- 活指南制定前及持续维护中需做多项关键决策。
- 系统综述流程、证据评价方法及未发表数据使用需权衡选择。
- 纳入新研究的触发因素选择存在多种选项与权衡。
核心结论
- 识别了活指南制定全程需考虑的权衡与重要决策,最合适且最可持续的制定与更新模式取决于各领域的选择。
研究设计与样本
- 通过访谈、反馈和国际活指南制定者小组的共识过程进行迭代开发。
主要发现
- 活指南制定与维护的持续过程中需在开始前和全程做出多项关键决策。
- 关键决策包括系统综述流程的取径、证据评价方法(含未发表数据的使用)以及纳入新研究的触发因素选择。
- 每个决策均存在多种选项与权衡。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Producing living guidelines requires making important decisions about methods for evidence identification, appraisal, and integration to allow the living mode to function. Clarifying what these decisions are and the trade-offs between options is necessary. This article provides living guideline developers with a framework to enable them to choose the most suitable model for their living guideline topic, question, or context. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We developed this guidance through an iterative process informed by interviews, feedback, and a consensus process with an international group of living guideline developers. RESULTS: Several key decisions need to be made both before commencing and throughout the continual process of living guideline development and maintenance. These include deciding what approach is taken to the systematic review process; decisions about methods to be applied for the evidence appraisal process, including the use of unpublished data; and selection of "triggers" to incorporate new studies into living guideline recommendations. In each case, there are multiple options and trade-offs. CONCLUSION: We identify trade-offs and important decisions to be considered throughout the living guideline development process. The most appropriate, and most sustainable, mode of development and updating will be dependent on the choices made in each of these areas.
引用
- Fraile Navarro D, Cheyne S, Hill K, et al. Methods for living guidelines: early guidance based on practical experience. Paper 5: decisions on methods for evidence synthesis and recommendation development for living guidelines. J Clin Epidemiol. 2023. PMID: 36608720. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2022.12.022
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。