管理随机外科试验设计与分析中的聚类效应和学习效应:现有指南综述
该综述通过电子检索Equator Network及定向检索英国主要资助机构、监管机构和医学期刊推荐的指南,共纳入28份文档,比较其对外科随机试验中聚类效应和学习曲线的覆盖情况。结果显示,针对设计层面的指南(20/28,71%)是分析层面(10/28,36%)的两倍,中心聚类管理记录充分,外科医生聚类覆盖较少且存在不一致,学习曲线设计管理仅见于8/28(29%)文档,且仅1份涉及报告指导并限于早期阶段研究。作者认为需要制定一份统一文档以指导试验设计与分析。
要点
- 针对设计层面的指南文档数量(20/28,71%)是分析层面(10/28,36%)的两倍。
- 按中心聚类的设计管理记录充分,按外科医生聚类的覆盖较少且存在不一致。
- 学习曲线的设计管理仅见于8/28(29%)文档,其中仅1份涉及报告指导且限于早期阶段研究。
核心结论
- 据作者所知,这是首篇综述,评估现有随机外科试验设计与分析指南对中心或外科医生聚类及外科学习曲线的覆盖程度。
- 识别出的文档中针对设计层面的数量是分析层面的两倍。
- 最值得注意的是,不存在可供设计此类研究时使用的单一文档,可能导致实践不一致。
- 需要制定一份单一文档,包含商定的原则,以指导一系列现实临床场景下的试验设计与分析。
研究设计与样本
- 对现有指南进行综述,这些指南旨在为随机对照试验的设计和分析提供信息。
- 指南通过Equator Network内的电子检索,以及对英国主要资助机构、监管机构和医学期刊认可的指南进行定向检索来识别。
- 符合条件文档与预先指定的关键标准进行比较,以识别建议中的差距或不一致。
- 共28份文档符合条件(Equator Network 12份;定向检索16份)。
主要发现
- 针对设计层面的指南文档数量(n/N=20/28,71%)是分析层面(n/N=10/28,36%)的两倍。
- 通过设计管理按中心聚类已有充分记录。
- 按外科医生聚类的覆盖较少,且包含一些不一致之处。
- 通过设计管理外科学习曲线或随时间推移的实施变化见于若干文档(n/N=8/28,29%),其中一份提供了报告指导且仅限早期阶段研究。
- 分析聚类效应和学习的方法分别在五份和四份文档中提供(N=28)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The complexities associated with delivering randomised surgical trials, such as clustering effects, by centre or surgeon, and surgical learning, are well known. Despite this, approaches used to manage these complexities, and opinions on these, vary. Guidance documents have been developed to support clinical trial design and reporting. This work aimed to identify and examine existing guidance and consider its relevance to clustering effects and learning curves within surgical trials. METHODS: A review of existing guidelines, developed to inform the design and analysis of randomised controlled trials, is undertaken. Guidelines were identified using an electronic search, within the Equator Network, and by a targeted search of those endorsed by leading UK funding bodies, regulators, and medical journals. Eligible documents were compared against pre-specified key criteria to identify gaps or inconsistencies in recommendations. RESULTS: Twenty-eight documents were eligible (12 Equator Network; 16 targeted search). Twice the number of guidance documents targeted design (n/N=20/28, 71%) than analysis (n/N=10/28, 36%). Managing clustering by centre through design was well documented. Clustering by surgeon had less coverage and contained some inconsistencies. Managing the surgical learning curve, or changes in delivery over time, through design was contained within several documents (n/N=8/28, 29%), of which one provided guidance on reporting this and restricted to early phase studies only. Methods to analyse clustering effects and learning were provided in five and four documents respectively (N=28). CONCLUSIONS: To our knowledge, this is the first review as to the extent to which existing guidance for designing and analysing randomised surgical trials covers the management of clustering, by centre or surgeon, and the surgical learning curve. Twice the number of identified documents targeted design aspects than analysis. Most notably, no single document exists for use when designing these studies, which may lead to inconsistencies in practice. The development of a single document, with agreed principles to guide trial design and analysis across a range of realistic clinical scenarios, is needed.
引用
- Conroy EJ, Blazeby JM, Burnside G, et al. Managing clustering effects and learning effects in the design and analysis of randomised surgical trials: a review of existing guidance. Trials. 2022. PMID: 36221107. doi:10.1186/s13063-022-06743-6
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。