评估代表缺乏同意能力成人参与研究的代理决策质量的量表开发:代理知情同意决策联合量表(CONCORD量表)
本研究采用四阶段流程开发并 refine 了评估代理决策质量的新量表 CONCORD,通过范围综述、共识研究、内容覆盖评估和认知访谈(11名家属)确立了量表的理解性、可接受性、可行性和内容充分性,并形成修订版。该量表可简要评估非急诊情况下代表缺乏同意能力成人所做决策的质量,初步评价表明其内容充分且可行,进一步的统计验证正在进行中。
要点
- CONCORD量表用于评估非急诊情况下代理知情同意决策的质量。
- 开发基于范围综述、共识研究、内容覆盖评估和11名家属的认知访谈。
- 初步评价显示量表具有内容充分性且可行,修订版已形成。
核心结论
- CONCORD量表提供了一种简要测量工具,用于评估在非急诊情况下代表缺乏同意能力成人所做决策的质量,从而能够评价改善代理决策质量的干预措施。
- 初步评价表明该量表具有内容充分性且使用可行。
- 进一步的统计验证工作正在进行中。
研究设计与样本
- 采用既定的量表开发原则,通过四阶段流程开发并 refine 代理决策质量新量表的条目。
- 第一阶段:回顾近期范围综述和共识研究的发现,以确定量表纳入的条目及现有结局测量工具。
- 第二阶段:评估现有测量工具的内容覆盖情况并识别不足。
- 第三阶段:构建新量表。
- 第四阶段:通过访谈缺乏同意能力者的家属(共11名家庭成员)进行认知测试,探索量表的理解性并检验其内容充分性。
主要发现
- 范围综述中识别出多种与医疗决策和知情同意决策相关的结局测量工具,如决策冲突量表(Decisional Conflict Scale)。
- 将这些测量工具与共识研究确定的关键构念进行映射以评估内容覆盖,发现现有工具对代理特异性满意度和知识充分性等领域的覆盖不足,表明需要新量表。
- 起草了联合测量工具(CONCORD量表)的初始版本,并在11名家庭成员的认知访谈中进行测试。
- 访谈确立了量表的理解性、可接受性、可行性和内容充分性。
- 参与者建议对部分问题进行重新措辞和重新排序,从而形成了修订版。
局限性
- 进一步的统计验证工作正在进行中。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Recruitment of adults lacking the capacity to consent to trials requires the involvement of an alternative 'proxy' decision-maker, usually a family member. This can be challenging for family members, with some experiencing emotional and decisional burdens. Interventions to support proxy consent decisions in non-emergency settings are being developed. However, the ability to evaluate interventions is limited due to a lack of measures that capture outcomes of known importance, as identified through a core outcome set (COS). METHODS: Using established measure development principles, a four-stage process was used to develop and refine items for a new measure of proxy decision quality: (1) findings from a recent scoping review and consensus study were reviewed to identify items for inclusion in the scale and any existing outcome measures, (2) assessment of content coverage by existing measures and identification of insufficiency, (3) construction of a novel scale, and (4) cognitive testing to explore comprehension of the scale and test its content adequacy through interviews with family members of people with impaired capacity. RESULTS: A range of outcome measures associated with healthcare decision-making and informed consent decisions, such as the Decisional Conflict Scale, were identified in the scoping review. These measures were mapped against the key constructs identified in the COS to assess content coverage. Insufficient coverage of areas such as proxy-specific satisfaction and knowledge sufficiency by existing instruments indicated that a novel measure was needed. An initial version of a combined measure (the CONCORD scale) was drafted and tested during cognitive interviews with eleven family members. The interviews established comprehension, acceptability, feasibility, and content adequacy of the scale. Participants suggested re-phrasing and re-ordering some questions, leading to the creation of a revised version. CONCLUSIONS: The CONCORD scale provides a brief measure to evaluate the quality of decisions made on behalf of an adult who lacks the capacity to consent in non-emergency settings, enabling the evaluation of interventions to improve proxy decision quality. Initial evaluation indicates it has content adequacy and is feasible to use. Further statistical validation work is being undertaken.
引用
- Shepherd V, Hood K, Gillies K, et al. Development of a measure to assess the quality of proxy decisions about research participation on behalf of adults lacking capacity to consent: the Combined Scale for Proxy Informed Consent Decisions (CONCORD scale). Trials. 2022. PMID: 36195929. doi:10.1186/s13063-022-06787-8
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。