南非整群随机对照试验中文化胜任力的评估:对试验报告标准的启示
本案例研究在南非一项复杂临床试验中,比较9条目Gibbs框架与GRIPP-2简表(SF)5点清单测量文化胜任力的效用与可比性。Gibbs框架显示该试验在9个条目中7个得分为2分,提示完全文化胜任力;但研究问题未由患者需求驱动,患者、照护者和临床提供者未参与干预开发。作者认为当前试验报告标准在文化胜任力方面存在差距。
要点
- Gibbs框架评估显示该试验9个条目中7个得分为2分,提示完全文化胜任力。
- 该试验的研究问题未由患者明确需求驱动,患者、照护者和临床提供者未参与干预开发。
- 与GRIPP-2简表(SF)比较,Gibbs框架在评估社区伙伴关系、文化胜任数据源与目标人群识别、包容性任命试验人员方面表现更好。
核心结论
- 全面评估试验的文化胜任力需同时审查已发表手稿以及源数据和程序数据,提示当前试验报告标准在文化胜任力方面存在差距。
研究设计与样本
- 本案例研究识别并整理了与该试验相关的所有出版物、源数据和程序数据,整合为动态试验时间线。
- 两名独立研究者对试验产生的四篇出版物应用并评分Gibbs框架和GRIPP-2简表(SF)清单,记录工具的功能性和可比性。
- 当文化胜任力未满足时,由第三名研究者筛查所有程序数据和源数据,判断文化胜任力是否已达成但未在出版物中报告,或试验基于文档未达到适当的文化胜任力。
主要发现
- 应用Gibbs框架发现该试验在9个Gibbs条目中7个得分为2分,表明这些问题的完全文化胜任力。
- Gibbs框架表明该试验的研究问题未由患者明确需求驱动,患者、照护者和临床提供者未参与干预开发。
- 与GRIPP-2简表(SF)清单的可比性显示,Gibbs框架在评估与社区的伙伴关系、识别文化胜任的数据源和目标人群、以及以包容方式任命试验人员方面表现更好。
关键数值与推荐
- Gibbs框架为9条目工具,该试验在9个条目中7个得分为2分,提示完全文化胜任力。
- GRIPP-2简表(SF)为5点清单,用于评估患者和公众参与。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Failure to consider relevant cultural, ethnic and diversity parameters (and the intersection between these parameters) during trial protocol development and trial conduct may negatively impact recruitment, intervention development and delivery, and participant adherence and retention, potentially reducing overall internal validity. This case study aimed to evaluate the utility and comparability between the 9-item Gibbs Framework to measure cultural competency and the GRIPP-2(Short Form (SF)) 5-point checklist to assess patient and public involvement in the context of a complex clinical trial conducted in an African setting. METHODS: We identified and collated all relevant publications, source and procedural data related to the trial and integrated the documents into a dynamic trial timeline. Two independent investigators applied and scored the Gibbs Framework and the GRIPP-2(SF) checklist to the four publications arising from the trial, noting functionality and comparability between tools. Where cultural competency was not met, a third investigator screened all procedural and source data and identified if cultural competency had been achieved but not reported in the publications, or if the trial had not met appropriate cultural competency based on the documentation. RESULTS: Application of the Gibbs Framework found that the trial scored '2' for seven of the nine Gibbs items, indicating full cultural competency for those questions. The Framework indicated that the trial research question was not driven by the articulated needs of patients, and neither were patients, caregivers and clinical providers involved in the development of the intervention. Comparability with the GRIPP-2(SF) checklist showed that the Gibbs performed better on evaluation of partnerships with the community, identification of culturally competent data sources and target populations, and appointment of trial staff in an inclusive manner. CONCLUSIONS: Comprehensive evaluation of the trial's cultural competency required scrutiny of both published manuscripts and source and procedural data, suggesting that there is a gap in current trial reporting standards with respect to cultural competence. TRIAL REGISTRATION: PACTR201610001825403. Registered on 17 October 2016.
引用
- Siegfried NL, Hopewell S, Erasmus-Claassen LA, et al. Evaluation of cultural competency in a South African cluster randomised controlled trial: lessons learned for trial reporting standards. Trials. 2022. PMID: 36309756. doi:10.1186/s13063-022-06767-y
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。