检验时间依赖性治疗效应的证据:使用回归方法的示例
该研究比较了多种回归方法建模时间依赖性治疗效应,并以一项低剂量每日阿司匹林的大型社区临床试验的选定终点为例进行展示。在中位随访4.7年的试验中,发现阿司匹林对癌症死亡率存在非比例性和时间依赖性治疗效应的证据,未在既往试验结果中报告;还发现阿司匹林与年龄交互对主要不良心血管事件的时间依赖性有一定证据。结论推荐将这些分析方法作为主要分析的补充,以充分探索临床试验发现。
要点
- 在中位随访4.7年的低剂量阿司匹林试验中,发现癌症死亡率存在非比例性和时间依赖性治疗效应证据。
- 发现阿司匹林与年龄交互对主要不良心血管事件的时间依赖性有一定证据。
- 对其他终点,时间固定治疗效应估计被确认是合适的。
核心结论
- 同时使用相对和绝对估计量考虑治疗效应,增强了对潜在动态治疗效应的临床洞察。
- 推荐将这些分析方法作为主要分析的补充,以充分探索临床试验发现。
研究设计与样本
- 方法学研究,比较多种基于回归的方法建模时间依赖性治疗效应。
- 以一项低剂量每日阿司匹林的大型社区临床试验的选定终点为例进行展示,中位随访4.7年,分析在所有参与者中进行,并在选定亚组中使用回归模型中的交互项进行额外探索性分析。
主要发现
- 在该试验中,发现阿司匹林对癌症死亡率存在非比例性和时间依赖性治疗效应的证据,未在既往试验结果中报告。
- 发现阿司匹林与年龄交互对主要不良心血管事件的时间依赖性有一定证据。
- 对其他终点,时间固定治疗效应估计被确认是合适的。
临床怎么用
- 作者建议将这些分析方法作为主要分析的补充,以充分探索临床试验发现。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: For the design and analysis of clinical trials with time-to-event outcomes, the Cox proportional hazards model and the logrank test have been the cornerstone methods for many decades. Increasingly, the key assumption of proportionality-or time-fixed effects-that underpins these methods has been called into question. The availability of novel therapies with new mechanisms of action and clinical trials of longer duration mean that non-proportional hazards are now more frequently encountered. METHODS: We compared several regression-based methods to model time-dependent treatment effects. For illustration purposes, we used selected endpoints from a large, community-based clinical trial of low dose daily aspirin in older persons. Relative and absolute estimands were defined, and analyses were conducted in all participants. Additional exploratory analyses were undertaken by selected subgroups of interest using interaction terms in the regression models. DISCUSSION: In the trial with median 4.7 years follow-up, we found evidence for non-proportionality and a time-dependent treatment effect of aspirin on cancer mortality not previously reported in trial findings. We also found some evidence of time-dependence to an aspirin by age interaction for major adverse cardiovascular events. For other endpoints, time-fixed treatment effect estimates were confirmed as appropriate. CONCLUSIONS: The consideration of treatment effects using both absolute and relative estimands enhanced clinical insights into potential dynamic treatment effects. We recommend these analytical approaches as an adjunct to primary analyses to fully explore findings from clinical trials.
引用
- Jachno KM, Heritier S, Woods RL, et al. Examining evidence of time-dependent treatment effects: an illustration using regression methods. Trials. 2022. PMID: 36203169. doi:10.1186/s13063-022-06803-x
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。